OSSP: CVS Repository: ossp-pkg/sio/BRAINSTORM/smli

ossp-pkg/sio/BRAINSTORM/smli_tr-99-76.ps 1.1
%!PS-Adobe-3.0
%%Title: (Finished.pdf)
%%Version: 1 2
%%Creator: (FrameMaker xm5.5.3L15a)
%%CreationDate: (D:19990427163055)
%%DocumentData: Clean7Bit
%%LanguageLevel: 2
%%BoundingBox: 0 0 612 792
%%Pages: 30
%%DocumentProcessColors: Cyan Magenta Yellow Black
%%DocumentSuppliedResources:
%%+ font Times-Italic
%%+ font Times-Bold
%%+ font Courier
%%+ font Symbol
%%+ font Courier-Bold
%%+ font Helvetica
%%+ font Times-Roman
%%+ font Helvetica-Bold
%%+ font Times-Roman
%%+ procset (Adobe Acrobat - PDF operators) 1.2 0
%%+ procset (Adobe Acrobat - type operators) 1.2 0
%%EndComments
%%BeginDefaults
%%EndDefaults
%%BeginProlog
%%EndProlog
%%BeginSetup
%%BeginFile: l2check
%%Copyright: Copyright 1993 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
/languagelevel where
{ pop languagelevel 1 eq }
{ true }
ifelse
{
initgraphics /Helvetica findfont 18 scalefont setfont
72 600 moveto (Error: Your printer driver needs to be configured) dup show
72 580 moveto (for printing to a PostScript Level 1 printer.) dup show
exch = =
/Helvetica-Bold findfont 16 scalefont setfont
72 520 moveto (Windows and Unix) show
/Times-Roman findfont 16 scalefont setfont
72 500 moveto (Select ŞLevel 1ş in the PostScript options section) show
72 480 moveto (of the Acrobat Exchange or Reader print dialog.) show
/Helvetica-Bold findfont 16 scalefont setfont
72 440 moveto (Macintosh) show
/Times-Roman findfont 16 scalefont setfont
72 420 moveto (In the Chooser, select your printer driver.) show
72 400 moveto (Then select your printer and click the Setup button.) show
72 380 moveto (Follow any on-screen dialogs that may appear.) show
showpage
quit
}
if
%%EndFile
/currentpacking where{pop currentpacking true setpacking}if
userdict /PDF 85 dict put
%%BeginFile: pdfvars.prc
%%Copyright: Copyright 1987-1996 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
userdict /PDFVars 75 dict dup begin put
/_save 0 def
/_cshow 0 def
/InitAll 0 def
/TermAll 0 def
/_lp /none def
/_doClip 0 def
/sfc 0 def
/_sfcs 0 def
/_sfc 0 def
/ssc 0 def
/_sscs 0 def
/_ssc 0 def
/_fcs 0 def
/_scs 0 def
/_fp 0 def
/_sp 0 def
/_f0 0 array def
/_f1 1 array def
/_f3 3 array def
/_f4 4 array def
/_fc null def
/_s0 0 array def
/_s1 1 array def
/_s3 3 array def
/_s4 4 array def
/_sc null def
/_cpcf null def
/_cpcs null def
/_inT false def
/_tr -1 def
/_rise 0 def
/_ax 0 def
/_cx 0 def
/_ld 0 def
/_tm matrix def
/_ctm matrix def
/_mtx matrix def
/_hy (-) def
/_fScl 0 def
/_hs 1 def
/_pdfEncodings 2 array def
/_Tj 0 def
/_italMtx[1 0 .212557 1 0 0]def
/_basefont 0 def
/_basefonto 0 def
/_categories 10 dict def
/_sa? true def
/_op? false def
/_ColorSep5044? false def
/_tmpcolr? [] def
/_tmpop? {} def
end
%%EndFile
PDFVars begin PDF begin
%%BeginFile: pdfutil.prc
%%Copyright: Copyright 1993 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
/bd {bind def} bind def
/ld {load def} bd
/dd { PDFVars 3 1 roll put } bd
/xdd { exch dd } bd
/Level2?
/languagelevel where { pop languagelevel 2 ge } { false } ifelse
def
/here {
dup currentdict exch known
{ currentdict exch get true }
{ pop false }
ifelse
} bd
/isdefined? { where { pop true } { false } ifelse } bd
/StartLoad { dup dup not { /_save save dd } if } bd
/EndLoad { if not { _save restore } if } bd
/npop { { pop } repeat } bd
%%EndFile
%%BeginFile: pdf.prc
%%Copyright: Copyright 1987-1996 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
/initialize {
_ColorSep5044? {sep_ops begin 50 dict begin} if
newpath
} bd
/terminate {
_ColorSep5044? {end end} if
} bd
Level2? StartLoad
{ /m/moveto ld
/l/lineto ld
/c/curveto ld
/setSA/setstrokeadjust ld
} EndLoad
Level2? not StartLoad
{
/pl {
transform
0.25 sub round 0.25 add exch
0.25 sub round 0.25 add exch
itransform
} bd
/m { _sa? { pl } if moveto } bd
/l { _sa? { pl } if lineto } bd
/c { _sa? { pl } if curveto } bd
/setSA { /_sa? xdd } bd
} EndLoad
/v { currentpoint 6 2 roll c } bd
/y { 2 copy c } bd
/h/closepath ld
/d/setdash ld
/j/setlinejoin ld
/J/setlinecap ld
/M/setmiterlimit ld
/w/setlinewidth ld
/cf currentflat def
/i {
dup 0 eq { pop cf } if
setflat
} bd
/ilp { /_lp /none dd } bd
/sfc {
_lp /fill ne {
_sfcs
_sfc
/_lp /fill dd
} if
} dd
/ssc {
_lp /stroke ne {
_sscs
_ssc
/_lp /stroke dd
} if
} dd
/n {
_doClip 1 ge {
_doClip 1 eq { clip } { eoclip } ifelse
/_doClip 0 dd
} if
newpath
} bd
/f {
_doClip 1 ge
{
gsave sfc fill grestore
_doClip 1 eq { clip } { eoclip } ifelse
newpath
ilp
/_doClip 0 dd
}
{ sfc fill }
ifelse
} bd
/f* {
_doClip 1 ge
{
gsave sfc eofill grestore
_doClip 1 eq { clip } { eoclip } ifelse
newpath
ilp
/_doClip 0 dd
}
{ sfc eofill }
ifelse
} bd
/S {
_doClip 1 ge
{
gsave ssc stroke grestore
_doClip 1 eq { clip } { eoclip } ifelse
newpath
ilp
/_doClip 0 dd
}
{ ssc stroke }
ifelse
} bd
/s { h S } bd
/B {
_doClip dup 1 ge
gsave f grestore
{
gsave S grestore
1 eq { clip } { eoclip } ifelse
newpath
ilp
/_doClip 0 dd
}
{ pop S }
ifelse
} bd
/b { h B } bd
/B* {
_doClip dup 1 ge
gsave f* grestore
{
gsave S grestore
1 eq { clip } { eoclip } ifelse
newpath
ilp
/_doClip 0 dd
}
{ pop S }
ifelse
} bd
/b* { h B* } bd
/W { /_doClip 1 dd } bd
/W* { /_doClip 2 dd } bd
/q/save ld
/Q { restore ilp } bd
Level2? StartLoad
{ /defineRes/defineresource ld
/findRes/findresource ld
currentglobal
true systemdict /setglobal get exec
[/Function /ExtGState /Form]
{ /Generic /Category findresource dup length dict copy /Category defineresource pop }
forall
systemdict /setglobal get exec
} EndLoad
Level2? not StartLoad
{ /AlmostFull?
{ dup maxlength exch length sub 2 le
} bind def
/Expand
{ 1 index maxlength mul cvi dict
dup begin exch { def } forall end
} bind def
/xput
{ 3 2 roll
dup 3 index known not
{ dup AlmostFull? { 1.5 Expand } if
} if
dup 4 2 roll put
} bind def
/defineRes
{ _categories 1 index known not
{ /_categories _categories 2 index 10 dict xput store
} if
_categories exch 2 copy get 5 -1 roll 4 index xput put
} bind def
/findRes
{ _categories exch get exch get
} bind def
} EndLoad
/cs
{
dup where { pop load } if
dup /_fcs xdd
ucs
_cpcf exch get
/_fc xdd
/_fp null dd
} bd
/CS
{
dup where { pop load } if
dup /_scs xdd ucs _cpcs exch get /_sc xdd /_sp null dd
} bd
/ucs {
dup type /arraytype eq
{ dup 0 get
dup /Indexed eq
{ pop 0 get }
{ /Pattern eq
{ dup length 2 eq
{ 1 get ucs }
{ 0 get }
ifelse }
{ 0 get }
ifelse }
ifelse }
if }
bd
/_cpcf
15 dict dup begin
/DefaultGray _f1 def
/DeviceGray _f1 def
/DefaultRGB _f3 def
/DeviceRGB _f3 def
/DeviceCMYK _f4 def
/CalGray _f1 def
/CalRGB _f3 def
/CalCMYK _f4 def
/Lab _f3 def
/Pattern _f0 def
/Indexed _f1 def
/Separation _f1 def
/CIEBasedA _f1 def
/CIEBasedABC _f3 def
end
dd
/_cpcs
15 dict dup begin
/DefaultGray _s1 def
/DeviceGray _s1 def
/DefaultRGB _s3 def
/DeviceRGB _s3 def
/DeviceCMYK _s4 def
/CalGray _s1 def
/CalRGB _s3 def
/CalCMYK _s4 def
/Lab _s3 def
/Pattern _s0 def
/Indexed _s1 def
/Separation _s1 def
/CIEBasedA _s1 def
/CIEBasedABC _s3 def
end
dd
Level2? not StartLoad {
/ri/pop ld
/makePat/pop ld
} EndLoad
Level2? StartLoad {
/ri
{
/findcolorrendering isdefined?
{
mark exch
findcolorrendering
counttomark 2 eq
{ type /booleantype eq
{ dup type /nametype eq
{ dup /ColorRendering resourcestatus
{ pop pop
dup /DefaultColorRendering ne
{
/ColorRendering findresource
setcolorrendering
} if
} if
} if
} if
} if
cleartomark
}
{ pop
} ifelse
} bd
/makePat /makepattern ld
} EndLoad
Level2? not _ColorSep5044? or StartLoad
{
/L1setcolor {
aload length
dup 0 eq
{ pop .5 setgray }
{ dup 1 eq
{ pop setgray }
{ 3 eq
{ setrgbcolor }
{ setcmykcolor }
ifelse }
ifelse }
ifelse
} bind dd
/_sfcs { } dd
/_sscs { } dd
} EndLoad
Level2? not _ColorSep5044? not and StartLoad
{
/_sfc { _fc L1setcolor } dd
/_ssc { _sc L1setcolor } dd
} EndLoad
Level2? _ColorSep5044? not and StartLoad
{
/_sfcs
{
_fcs setcolorspace
} bind dd
/_sscs
{
_scs setcolorspace
} bind dd
/_sfc
{
_fc aload pop
_fp null eq
{ setcolor }
{ _fp setpattern }
ifelse
} bind dd
/_ssc
{
_sc aload pop
_sp null eq { setcolor } { _sp setpattern } ifelse
} bind dd
} EndLoad
/sc
{
_fc astore pop
ilp
} bd
/SC
{
_sc astore pop
ilp
} bd
/scn {
dup type /dicttype eq
{ dup /_fp xdd
/PaintType get 1 eq
{ /_fc _f0 dd ilp }
{ /_fc _cpcf _fcs ucs get dd
sc }
ifelse }
{ sc }
ifelse
} bd
/SCN {
dup type /dicttype eq
{ dup /_sp xdd
/PaintType get 1 eq
{ /_sc _s0 dd ilp }
{ /_sc _cpcs _scs ucs get dd
SC }
ifelse }
{ SC }
ifelse
} bd
/g { /DefaultGray cs sc } bd
/rg { /DefaultRGB cs sc } bd
/k { /DeviceCMYK cs sc } bd
/G { /DefaultGray CS SC } bd
/RG { /DefaultRGB CS SC } bd
/K { /DeviceCMYK CS SC } bd
/cm { _mtx astore concat } bd
/re {
4 2 roll m
1 index 0 rlineto
0 exch rlineto
neg 0 rlineto
h
} bd
/RC/rectclip ld
/EF/execform ld
/PS { cvx exec } bd
/initgs {
/DefaultGray where
{ pop }
{ /DefaultGray /DeviceGray dd }
ifelse
/DefaultRGB where
{ pop }
{ /DefaultRGB /DeviceRGB dd }
ifelse
0 g 0 G
[] 0 d 0 j 0 J 10 M 1 w
true setSA
} bd
21 dict dup begin
/CosineDot
{ 180 mul cos exch 180 mul cos add 2 div } bd
/Cross
{ abs exch abs 2 copy gt { exch } if pop neg } bd
/Diamond
{ abs exch abs 2 copy add .75 le
{ dup mul exch dup mul add 1 exch sub }
{ 2 copy add 1.23 le
{ .85 mul add 1 exch sub }
{ 1 sub dup mul exch 1 sub dup mul add 1 sub }
ifelse }
ifelse } bd
/Double
{ exch 2 div exch 2 { 360 mul sin 2 div exch } repeat add } bd
/DoubleDot
{ 2 { 360 mul sin 2 div exch } repeat add } bd
/Ellipse
{ abs exch abs 2 copy 3 mul exch 4 mul add 3 sub dup 0 lt
{ pop dup mul exch .75 div dup mul add 4 div
1 exch sub }
{ dup 1 gt
{pop 1 exch sub dup mul exch 1 exch sub
.75 div dup mul add 4 div 1 sub }
{ .5 exch sub exch pop exch pop }
ifelse }
ifelse } bd
/EllipseA
{ dup mul .9 mul exch dup mul add 1 exch sub } bd
/EllipseB
{ dup 5 mul 8 div mul exch dup mul exch add sqrt 1 exch sub } bd
/EllipseC
{ dup .5 gt { 1 exch sub } if
dup .25 ge
{ .5 exch sub 4 mul dup mul 1 sub }
{ 4 mul dup mul 1 exch sub }
ifelse
exch
dup .5 gt { 1 exch sub } if
dup .25 ge
{ .5 exch sub 4 mul dup mul 1 sub }
{ 4 mul dup mul 1 exch sub }
ifelse
add -2 div } bd
/InvertedDouble
{ exch 2 div exch 2 { 360 mul sin 2 div exch } repeat add neg } bd
/InvertedDoubleDot
{ 2 { 360 mul sin 2 div exch } repeat add neg } bd
/InvertedEllipseA
{ dup mul .9 mul exch dup mul add 1 sub } bd
/InvertedSimpleDot
{ dup mul exch dup mul add 1 sub } bd
/Line
{ exch pop abs neg } bd
/LineX
{ pop } bd
/LineY
{ exch pop } bd
/Rhomboid
{ abs exch abs 0.9 mul add 2 div } bd
/Round
{ abs exch abs 2 copy add 1 le
{ dup mul exch dup mul add 1 exch sub }
{ 1 sub dup mul exch 1 sub dup mul add 1 sub }
ifelse } bd
/SimpleDot
{ dup mul exch dup mul add 1 exch sub } bd
/Square
{ abs exch abs 2 copy lt { exch } if pop neg } bd
end
{ /Function defineRes pop } forall
/Identity {} /Function defineRes pop
Level2? StartLoad {
/gs
{
begin
/SA here { setstrokeadjust } if
/OP here { setoverprint } if
/BG here { setblackgeneration } if
/UCR here { setundercolorremoval } if
/HT here { sethalftone } if
/sethalftonephase isdefined? { /HTP here { sethalftonephase } if } if
/TR here
{
dup xcheck { settransfer } { aload pop setcolortransfer } ifelse
} if
end
} bd
{ /Default /Halftone findresource pop } stopped
{
currenthalftone exch defineresource pop }
if
} EndLoad
Level2? not StartLoad {
/gs
{
begin
/SA here { /_sa? xdd } if
/OP here { dup /_op? xdd
/setoverprint where {pop setoverprint}
{pop} ifelse
} if
/HT here { sethalftone } if
/TR here { dup xcheck
{ settransfer }
{ pop }
ifelse } if
end
} bd
5 dict dup
begin
currentscreen 1 [/HalftoneType /SpotFunction /Angle /Frequency]
{ exch def } forall
end
/Default exch /Halftone defineRes pop
} EndLoad
/int {
dup 2 index sub 3 index 5 index sub div 6 -2 roll sub mul
exch pop add exch pop
} bd
/limit {
dup 2 index le { exch } if pop
dup 2 index ge { exch } if pop
} bd
_ColorSep5044? StartLoad {
/_sfc
{
_fp null eq
{ _fcs type /arraytype eq
{_fcs 0 get /Separation eq
{
_fcs 1 get /All eq
{
_fc aload pop 1 exch sub
/setseparationgray where pop begin setseparationgray end
}
{
1 _fcs 3 get exec _fcs 1 get
/findcmykcustomcolor where pop begin findcmykcustomcolor end
_fc aload pop
/setcustomcolor where pop begin setcustomcolor end
}
ifelse
}
{ _fc L1setcolor }
ifelse
}
{ _fc L1setcolor }
ifelse
}
{ _fp setpattern }
ifelse
} bind dd
/_ssc
{
_sp null eq
{ _scs type /arraytype eq
{_scs 0 get /Separation eq
{
_scs 1 get /All eq
{
_sc aload pop 1 exch sub
/setseparationgray where pop begin setseparationgray end
}
{
1 _scs 3 get exec _scs 1 get
/findcmykcustomcolor where pop begin findcmykcustomcolor end
_sc aload pop
/setcustomcolor where pop begin setcustomcolor end
}
ifelse
}
{ _sc L1setcolor }
ifelse
}
{ _sc L1setcolor }
ifelse
}
{ _sp setpattern }
ifelse
} bind dd
} EndLoad
%%EndFile
%%BeginFile: pdftext.prc
%%Copyright: Copyright 1987-1994 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All Rights Reserved.
PDF /PDFText 51 dict dup begin put
/initialize { PDFText begin } bd
/terminate { end } bd
/CopyFont {
{
1 index /FID ne 2 index /UniqueID ne and
{ def } { pop pop } ifelse
} forall
} bd
/modEnc {
/_enc xdd
/_icode 0 dd
counttomark 1 sub -1 0
{
index
dup type /nametype eq
{
_enc _icode 3 -1 roll put
_icode 1 add
}
if
/_icode xdd
} for
cleartomark
_enc
} bd
/trEnc {
/_enc xdd
255 -1 0 {
exch dup -1 eq
{ pop /.notdef }
{ Encoding exch get }
ifelse
_enc 3 1 roll put
} for
pop
_enc
} bd
/TE {
/_i xdd
StandardEncoding 256 array copy modEnc
_pdfEncodings exch _i exch put
} bd
/TZ
{
/_usePDFEncoding xdd
findfont
dup length 2 add dict
begin
{
1 index /FID ne { def } { pop pop } ifelse
} forall
/FontName exch def
_usePDFEncoding 0 ge
{
/Encoding _pdfEncodings _usePDFEncoding get def
pop
}
{
_usePDFEncoding -1 eq
{
counttomark 0 eq
{ pop }
{
Encoding 256 array copy
modEnc /Encoding exch def
}
ifelse
}
{
256 array
trEnc /Encoding exch def
}
ifelse
}
ifelse
FontName currentdict
end
definefont pop
}
bd
/_pdfIsLevel2
systemdict /languagelevel known
{languagelevel 2 ge}
{false}
ifelse
def
_pdfIsLevel2
{
/_pdfFontStatus
{
dup /Font resourcestatus
{pop pop pop true}
{
/CIDFont /Category resourcestatus
{
pop pop
/CIDFont resourcestatus
{pop pop true}
{false}
ifelse
}
{ pop false }
ifelse
}
ifelse
} bd
}
{
/_pdfFontStatusString 50 string def
_pdfFontStatusString 0 (fonts/) putinterval
/_pdfFontStatus
{
_pdfFontStatusString 6 42 getinterval
cvs length 6 add
_pdfFontStatusString exch 0 exch getinterval
status
{ pop pop pop pop true}
{ false }
ifelse
} bd
}
ifelse
/_pdfString100 100 string def
/_pdfComposeFontName
{
dup length 1 eq
{
0 get
1 index
type /nametype eq
{
_pdfString100 cvs
length dup dup _pdfString100 exch (-) putinterval
_pdfString100 exch 1 add dup _pdfString100 length exch sub getinterval
2 index exch cvs length
add 1 add _pdfString100 exch 0 exch getinterval
exch pop
true
}
{
pop pop
false
}
ifelse
}
{
false
}
ifelse
} bd
systemdict /composefont known
{
/_pdfComposeFont
{
1 index /CMap resourcestatus
{pop pop true}
{false}
ifelse
1 index true exch
{
_pdfFontStatus not
{pop false exit}
if
}
forall
and
{composefont true}
{
_pdfComposeFontName
{
dup _pdfFontStatus
{ findfont definefont true }
{ pop pop false }
ifelse
}
{
dup _pdfFontStatus
{ findfont true }
{ pop false }
ifelse
}
ifelse
}
ifelse
} bd
}
{
/_pdfComposeFont
{
_pdfComposeFontName not
{
dup
}
if
2 copy _pdfFontStatus
{ pop findfont definefont true }
{
eq
{pop false}
{
dup _pdfFontStatus
{findfont true}
{pop false}
ifelse
}
ifelse
}
ifelse
} bd
}
ifelse
/_pdfFaceByStyleDict 4 dict dup begin
_pdfIsLevel2
{
/Serif
/Ryumin-Light-83pv-RKSJ-H /Font resourcestatus
{pop pop /Ryumin-Light}
{/HeiseiMin-W3}
ifelse
def
/SansSerif
/GothicBBB-Medium-83pv-RKSJ-H /Font resourcestatus
{pop pop /GothicBBB-Medium}
{/HeiseiKakuGo-W5}
ifelse
def
/Jun101-Light-83pv-RKSJ-H /Font resourcestatus
{pop pop /RoundSansSerif /Jun101-Light def }
{
/HeiseiMaruGo-W4-83pv-RKSJ-H /Font resourcestatus
{pop pop /RoundSansSerif /HeiseiMaruGo-W4 def}
if
}
ifelse
/Default Serif def
}
{
/Serif /Ryumin-Light def
/SansSerif /GothicBBB-Medium def
{
(fonts/Jun101-Light-83pv-RKSJ-H) status
}stopped
{pop}{
{pop pop pop pop /RoundSansSerif /Jun101-Light def }
if
}ifelse
/Default Serif def
}
ifelse
end
def
/TZzero
{
/_styleArr xdd
3 copy
_pdfComposeFont
{exch pop exch pop exch pop}
{
[
0 1 _styleArr length 1 sub
{
_styleArr exch get
_pdfFaceByStyleDict exch 2 copy known not
{ pop /Default }
if
get
}
for
]
exch pop
2 index 3 1 roll
_pdfComposeFont
{exch pop}
{
findfont
dup length dict
begin
{1 index /FID ne {def}{pop pop} ifelse }
forall
currentdict
end
}
ifelse
}
ifelse
definefont pop
}
bd
/swj {
dup 4 1 roll
dup length exch stringwidth
exch 5 -1 roll 3 index mul add
4 1 roll 3 1 roll mul add
6 2 roll /_cnt 0 dd
{1 index eq {/_cnt _cnt 1 add dd} if} forall pop
exch _cnt mul exch _cnt mul 2 index add 4 1 roll 2 index add 4 1 roll pop pop
} bd
/jss {
4 1 roll
{
2 npop
(0) exch 2 copy 0 exch put
gsave
32 eq
{
exch 6 index 6 index 6 index 5 -1 roll widthshow
currentpoint
}
{
false charpath currentpoint
4 index setmatrix stroke
}
ifelse
grestore
moveto
2 copy rmoveto
} exch cshow
6 npop
} def
/jsp
{
{
2 npop
(0) exch 2 copy 0 exch put
32 eq
{ exch 5 index 5 index 5 index 5 -1 roll widthshow }
{ false charpath }
ifelse
2 copy rmoveto
} exch cshow
5 npop
} bd
/trj { _cx 0 32 _ax 0 6 5 roll } bd
/pjsf { trj sfc awidthshow } bd
/pjss { trj _ctm ssc jss } bd
/pjsc { trj jsp } bd
/_Tjdef [
/pjsf load
/pjss load
{
dup
currentpoint 3 2 roll
pjsf
newpath moveto
pjss
} bind
{
trj swj rmoveto
} bind
{
dup currentpoint 4 2 roll gsave
pjsf
grestore 3 1 roll moveto
pjsc
} bind
{
dup currentpoint 4 2 roll
currentpoint gsave newpath moveto
pjss
grestore 3 1 roll moveto
pjsc
} bind
{
dup currentpoint 4 2 roll gsave
dup currentpoint 3 2 roll
pjsf
newpath moveto
pjss
grestore 3 1 roll moveto
pjsc
} bind
/pjsc load
] def
/BT
{
/_inT true dd
_ctm currentmatrix pop matrix _tm copy pop
0 _rise translate _hs 1 scale
0 0 moveto
} bd
/ET
{
/_inT false dd
_tr 3 gt {clip} if
_ctm setmatrix newpath
} bd
/Tr {
_inT { _tr 3 le {currentpoint newpath moveto} if } if
dup /_tr xdd
_Tjdef exch get /_Tj xdd
} bd
/Tj {
userdict /$$copystring 2 index put
_Tj
} bd
/iTm { _ctm setmatrix _tm concat 0 _rise translate _hs 1 scale } bd
/Tm { _tm astore pop iTm 0 0 moveto } bd
/Td { _mtx translate _tm _tm concatmatrix pop iTm 0 0 moveto } bd
/TD { dup /_ld xdd Td } bd
/Tf {
dup 1000 div /_fScl xdd
exch findfont exch scalefont setfont
} bd
/TL { neg /_ld xdd } bd
/Tw { /_cx xdd } bd
/Tc { /_ax xdd } bd
/Ts { /_rise xdd currentpoint iTm moveto } bd
/Tz { 100 div /_hs xdd iTm } bd
/Tk { exch pop _fScl mul neg 0 rmoveto } bd
/T* { 0 _ld Td } bd
/' { T* Tj } bd
/" { exch Tc exch Tw ' } bd
/TJ {
{
dup type /stringtype eq
{ Tj }
{ 0 exch Tk }
ifelse
} forall
} bd
/T- { _hy Tj } bd
/d0/setcharwidth ld
/d1 { setcachedevice /sfc{}dd /ssc{}dd } bd
/nND {{/.notdef} repeat} bd
/T3Defs {
/BuildChar
{
1 index /Encoding get exch get
1 index /BuildGlyph get exec
}
def
/BuildGlyph {
exch begin
GlyphProcs exch get exec
end
} def
} bd
/MakeBold {
findfont dup dup length 2 add dict
begin
CopyFont
/PaintType 2 def
/StrokeWidth .03 0 FontMatrix idtransform pop def
/dummybold currentdict
end
definefont
8 dict begin
/_basefont exch def
/_basefonto exch def
/FontType 3 def
/FontMatrix[1 0 0 1 0 0]def
/FontBBox[0 0 1 1]def
/Encoding StandardEncoding def
/BuildChar
{
exch begin
_basefont setfont
( )dup 0 4 -1 roll put
dup stringwidth
1 index 0 ne { exch .03 add exch }if
setcharwidth
0 0 moveto
gsave
dup show
grestore
_basefonto setfont
show
end
}bd
currentdict
end
definefont pop
}bd
/MakeItalic {
findfont _italMtx makefont
dup length dict
begin
CopyFont
currentdict
end
definefont pop
}bd
/MakeBoldItalic {
/dummybold exch
MakeBold
/dummybold
MakeItalic
}bd
currentdict readonly pop end
%%EndFile
PDFText begin
[39/quotesingle 96/grave 128/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis
/Udieresis/aacute/agrave/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex/idieresis/ntilde
/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex
/udieresis/dagger/degree/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph/germandbls
/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis/.notdef/AE/Oslash
/.notdef/plusminus/.notdef/.notdef/yen/mu/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae/oslash
/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin/.notdef/.notdef
/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe
/endash/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/divide
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft/guilsinglright
/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase/quotedblbase/perthousand
/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex
/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex
/Ugrave/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent/ring/cedilla
/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
0 TE
[1/dotlessi/caron 39/quotesingle 96/grave 
127/bullet/bullet/bullet/quotesinglbase/florin/quotedblbase/ellipsis
/dagger/daggerdbl/circumflex/perthousand/Scaron/guilsinglleft/OE
/bullet/bullet/bullet/bullet/quoteleft/quoteright/quotedblleft
/quotedblright/bullet/endash/emdash/tilde/trademark/scaron
/guilsinglright/oe/bullet/bullet/Ydieresis/space/exclamdown/cent/sterling
/currency/yen/brokenbar/section/dieresis/copyright/ordfeminine
/guillemotleft/logicalnot/hyphen/registered/macron/degree/plusminus
/twosuperior/threesuperior/acute/mu/paragraph/periodcentered/cedilla
/onesuperior/ordmasculine/guillemotright/onequarter/onehalf/threequarters
/questiondown/Agrave/Aacute/Acircumflex/Atilde/Adieresis/Aring/AE/Ccedilla
/Egrave/Eacute/Ecircumflex/Edieresis/Igrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis
/Eth/Ntilde/Ograve/Oacute/Ocircumflex/Otilde/Odieresis/multiply/Oslash
/Ugrave/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Udieresis/Yacute/Thorn/germandbls/agrave
/aacute/acircumflex/atilde/adieresis/aring/ae/ccedilla/egrave/eacute
/ecircumflex/edieresis/igrave/iacute/icircumflex/idieresis/eth/ntilde
/ograve/oacute/ocircumflex/otilde/odieresis/divide/oslash/ugrave/uacute
/ucircumflex/udieresis/yacute/thorn/ydieresis
1 TE
end
currentdict readonly pop
end end
/currentpacking where {pop setpacking}if
PDFVars/InitAll{[PDF PDFText]{/initialize get exec}forall initgs 0 Tr}put
PDFVars/TermAll{[PDFText PDF]{/terminate get exec}forall}put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
/N93 <<
/SA false 
/OP false 
>> /ExtGState defineRes pop
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N92/Times-Roman -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N91/Times-Bold -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N94/Times-Italic -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N95/Courier -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[/N96/Symbol -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[/N97/Times-Roman -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N98/Courier-Bold -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N133/Helvetica -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
% Begin encoding-delta
[ 39 /quotesingle 96 /grave 127 /.notdef/Adieresis/Aring/Ccedilla
/Eacute/Ntilde/Odieresis/Udieresis/aacute/agrave
/acircumflex/adieresis/atilde/aring/ccedilla/eacute
/egrave/ecircumflex/edieresis/iacute/igrave/icircumflex
/idieresis/ntilde/oacute/ograve/ocircumflex/odieresis
/otilde/uacute/ugrave/ucircumflex/udieresis/dagger
/.notdef/cent/sterling/section/bullet/paragraph
/germandbls/registered/copyright/trademark/acute/dieresis
/.notdef/AE/Oslash/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/yen/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef/.notdef
/.notdef/.notdef/ordfeminine/ordmasculine/.notdef/ae
/oslash/questiondown/exclamdown/logicalnot/.notdef/florin
/.notdef/.notdef/guillemotleft/guillemotright/ellipsis/.notdef
/Agrave/Atilde/Otilde/OE/oe/endash
/emdash/quotedblleft/quotedblright/quoteleft/quoteright/.notdef
/.notdef/ydieresis/Ydieresis/fraction/currency/guilsinglleft
/guilsinglright/fi/fl/daggerdbl/periodcentered/quotesinglbase
/quotedblbase/perthousand/Acircumflex/Ecircumflex/Aacute/Edieresis
/Egrave/Iacute/Icircumflex/Idieresis/Igrave/Oacute
/Ocircumflex/.notdef/Ograve/Uacute/Ucircumflex/Ugrave
/dotlessi/circumflex/tilde/macron/breve/dotaccent
/ring/cedilla/hungarumlaut/ogonek/caron
/N130/Helvetica-Bold -1 TZ
% End encoding-delta
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end

%%EndSetup
%%Page: 1 1
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
/N134 <<
/SA false 
/OP false 
>> /ExtGState defineRes pop
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N134 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N130 1 Tf
18 0 0 18 341.69 636 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
[(An Ef\336cient Meta-loc)20 (k f)20 (o)0 (r)]TJ
-8.0106 -1.1111 TD
[(Implementing Ubiquitous Sync)10 (hr)20 (onization)]TJ
/N133 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 319.9 562 Tm
[( Ole Agesen, Da)21 (vid Detlefs)15 (, Ale)30 (x Gar)-40 (thw)15 (aite)15 (,)]TJ
-2.7992 -1.0833 TD
[(Ross Knippel, Y)140 (.)0 ( S)21 (.)0 ( Ramakr)-15 (ishna, and Derek White)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 2 2
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
/N141 <<
/SA true 
/OP false 
>> /ExtGState defineRes pop
/N142 <<
/SA false 
/OP false 
>> /ExtGState defineRes pop
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N142 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
0 g
/N141 /ExtGState findRes gs
168.891 99.828 m
168.891 99.172 168.383 98.66 167.723 98.66 c
167.063 98.66 166.554 99.172 166.554 99.828 c
166.554 100.485 167.063 100.997 167.723 100.997 c
168.383 100.997 168.891 100.485 168.891 99.828 c
h
166.737 99.828 m
166.737 99.269 167.158 98.826 167.723 98.826 c
168.288 98.826 168.709 99.269 168.709 99.828 c
168.709 100.387 168.288 100.83 167.723 100.83 c
167.158 100.83 166.737 100.387 166.737 99.828 c
h
167.465 99.153 m
167.299 99.153 l
167.299 100.503 l
167.817 100.503 l
168.122 100.503 168.257 100.371 168.257 100.13 c
168.257 99.891 168.1 99.784 167.918 99.753 c
168.32 99.153 l
168.125 99.153 l
167.745 99.753 l
167.465 99.753 l
167.465 99.153 l
h
167.685 99.894 m
167.889 99.894 168.09 99.9 168.09 100.13 c
168.09 100.318 167.933 100.362 167.77 100.362 c
167.465 100.362 l
167.465 99.894 l
167.685 99.894 l
f 
122.149 116.628 m
122.042 111.155 128.194 108.58 128.087 103.787 c
128.087 102.463 127.086 99.029 123.58 99.101 c
121.827 99.137 120.146 100.317 120.181 103.357 c
120.181 105.504 l
120.146 105.682 120.146 105.897 120.003 106.076 c
119.895 106.183 119.681 106.255 119.502 106.183 c
119.18 106.004 119.108 105.647 118.965 105.36 c
118.786 104.43 118.572 103.465 118.393 102.535 c
118.357 102.463 118.465 102.463 118.393 102.463 c
118.25 101.784 118.143 101.068 118.107 100.388 c
118.071 99.959 118.357 99.602 118.715 99.387 c
120.038 98.672 121.72 98.171 123.58 98.135 c
128.123 98.064 131.843 102.034 131.915 105.897 c
131.95 109.009 130.198 110.797 128.266 113.122 c
127.3 114.338 125.368 116.02 125.44 118.237 c
125.44 120.026 126.907 122.029 129.59 121.993 c
133.203 121.922 132.63 118.094 132.702 116.341 c
132.702 116.163 132.702 115.984 132.845 115.912 c
132.988 115.769 133.203 115.733 133.382 115.805 c
133.489 115.912 133.56 115.984 133.596 116.091 c
134.49 119.453 l
134.634 120.061 134.92 120.67 134.92 121.385 c
134.92 121.564 134.777 121.743 134.598 121.886 c
132.702 122.887 131.557 123.03 129.804 123.066 c
125.368 123.138 122.185 119.99 122.149 116.628 c
h
132.959 109.975 m
132.959 109.796 133.103 109.617 133.317 109.617 c
133.782 109.617 134.033 110.547 135.177 112.085 c
135.821 113.051 136.644 113.802 137.073 113.802 c
137.395 113.802 137.431 113.552 137.431 113.337 c
137.431 112.264 133.353 103.679 133.353 100.317 c
133.353 99.28 133.782 98.278 135.106 98.278 c
138.254 98.278 141.652 102.249 144.085 105.825 c
144.192 105.933 144.263 105.933 144.228 105.754 c
143.727 104.287 143.011 101.497 143.011 99.78 c
143.011 99.065 143.155 98.207 144.299 98.207 c
147.089 98.207 150.703 103.679 150.703 104.967 c
150.703 105.182 150.631 105.396 150.381 105.396 c
149.951 105.396 149.808 104.681 149.343 103.894 c
148.484 102.535 147.089 100.746 146.41 100.746 c
146.159 100.746 146.159 101.032 146.159 101.247 c
146.159 103.071 150.524 114.982 150.524 115.34 c
150.524 115.626 150.488 115.805 150.059 115.805 c
149.773 115.805 149.307 115.841 148.663 115.841 c
147.483 115.841 147.411 115.662 147.304 115.447 c
146.732 114.338 145.873 110.797 144.156 107.685 c
141.831 103.644 138.683 100.46 137.359 100.46 c
136.894 100.46 136.608 100.818 136.608 101.354 c
136.608 103.143 140.937 112.407 140.937 114.66 c
140.937 115.197 140.65 116.27 139.363 116.27 c
135.893 116.27 132.959 110.618 132.959 109.975 c
h
165.701 116.234 m
162.231 116.234 158.546 110.726 157.294 108.866 c
157.223 108.687 157.187 108.758 157.223 108.901 c
157.831 111.119 158.546 113.087 158.546 114.553 c
158.546 115.447 158.117 116.341 156.972 116.341 c
154.54 116.341 150.998 111.548 150.998 110.368 c
150.998 110.118 151.07 109.939 151.249 109.939 c
151.678 109.939 152.036 110.762 152.68 111.62 c
153.503 112.622 154.504 113.909 155.112 113.909 c
155.22 113.909 155.327 113.838 155.327 113.48 c
155.327 111.978 152.25 103.5 150.963 99.28 c
150.819 98.815 151.106 98.707 152.465 98.707 c
153.431 98.707 153.896 98.564 154.075 99.315 c
154.862 102.141 156.328 105.289 157.938 108.043 c
159.405 110.618 162.553 114.338 164.306 114.338 c
164.699 114.338 164.95 114.052 164.95 113.444 c
164.95 111.656 160.371 103.107 160.514 99.852 c
160.55 98.922 160.872 98.242 162.052 98.242 c
164.771 98.242 167.167 102.034 168.276 104.037 c
168.455 104.359 168.741 104.717 168.491 105.11 c
168.42 105.253 168.276 105.325 168.098 105.325 c
167.99 105.325 167.883 105.217 167.811 105.11 c
167.06 103.787 165.415 100.889 164.306 100.818 c
164.091 100.818 163.984 101.032 163.984 101.211 c
163.984 102.499 167.99 110.833 167.99 113.659 c
167.99 115.555 166.953 116.234 165.701 116.234 c
f 
90.144 108.471 m
89.113 107.44 87.442 107.441 86.411 108.471 c
85.381 109.502 85.381 111.174 86.411 112.205 c
92.524 118.316 l
94.159 116.681 l
88.003 110.527 l
88.465 110.065 l
94.621 116.219 l
96.257 114.584 l
90.144 108.471 l
f 
94.904 112.271 m
95.934 113.301 97.605 113.301 98.636 112.271 c
99.667 111.24 99.667 109.568 98.636 108.537 c
92.524 102.426 l
90.888 104.06 l
97.044 110.215 l
96.582 110.677 l
90.427 104.522 l
88.79 106.158 l
94.904 112.271 l
f 
102.829 99.589 m
103.86 98.559 103.86 96.888 102.829 95.857 c
101.798 94.827 100.126 94.827 99.095 95.857 c
92.983 101.969 l
94.618 103.604 l
100.773 97.449 l
101.235 97.911 l
95.08 104.066 l
96.716 105.702 l
102.829 99.589 l
f 
99.029 104.349 m
97.998 105.379 97.998 107.05 99.029 108.081 c
100.06 109.111 101.732 109.111 102.763 108.081 c
108.875 101.969 l
107.24 100.334 l
101.085 106.489 l
100.623 106.027 l
106.778 99.872 l
105.142 98.236 l
99.029 104.349 l
f 
106.957 108.474 m
105.926 107.443 104.255 107.443 103.225 108.474 c
102.194 109.505 102.194 111.177 103.225 112.207 c
109.337 118.319 l
110.972 116.684 l
104.816 110.529 l
105.278 110.067 l
111.434 116.222 l
113.07 114.586 l
106.957 108.474 l
f 
111.717 112.273 m
112.747 113.304 114.418 113.304 115.449 112.273 c
116.48 111.242 116.48 109.57 115.449 108.54 c
109.337 102.428 l
107.702 104.063 l
113.857 110.218 l
113.395 110.68 l
107.24 104.525 l
105.603 106.161 l
111.717 112.273 l
f 
102.829 116.398 m
103.86 115.368 103.86 113.697 102.829 112.666 c
101.798 111.636 100.126 111.635 99.095 112.666 c
92.983 118.778 l
94.618 120.413 l
100.773 114.258 l
101.235 114.72 l
95.08 120.875 l
96.716 122.511 l
102.829 116.398 l
f 
99.029 121.158 m
97.998 122.188 97.998 123.859 99.029 124.889 c
100.06 125.92 101.732 125.92 102.763 124.89 c
108.875 118.778 l
107.24 117.143 l
101.085 123.298 l
100.623 122.836 l
106.778 116.681 l
105.142 115.045 l
99.029 121.158 l
f 
124.334 91.075 m
124.334 93.452 l
124.334 93.966 124.211 94.294 123.712 94.294 c
123.168 94.294 122.646 93.735 122.646 92.841 c
122.646 91.075 l
121.963 91.075 l
121.963 93.46 l
121.963 93.921 121.863 94.294 121.341 94.294 c
120.757 94.294 120.274 93.69 120.274 92.841 c
120.274 91.075 l
119.583 91.075 l
119.583 94.778 l
120.251 94.778 l
120.251 94.562 120.236 94.227 120.189 94.003 c
120.205 93.996 l
120.427 94.518 120.919 94.853 121.533 94.853 c
122.339 94.853 122.553 94.309 122.584 94.011 c
122.745 94.361 123.152 94.853 123.889 94.853 c
124.611 94.853 125.025 94.473 125.025 93.638 c
125.025 91.075 l
124.334 91.075 l
f 
130.241 91.023 m
129.328 91.023 128.568 91.44 128.568 92.804 c
128.568 93.996 129.197 94.838 130.472 94.838 c
130.771 94.838 131.07 94.793 131.339 94.719 c
131.262 94.13 l
131.024 94.219 130.74 94.286 130.441 94.286 c
129.673 94.286 129.297 93.735 129.297 92.893 c
129.297 92.171 129.543 91.597 130.387 91.597 c
130.709 91.597 131.047 91.671 131.293 91.798 c
131.347 91.217 l
131.093 91.12 130.686 91.023 130.241 91.023 c
f 
134.271 94.19 m
133.465 94.324 133.081 93.75 133.081 92.565 c
133.081 91.075 l
132.39 91.075 l
132.39 94.778 l
133.058 94.778 l
133.058 94.547 133.035 94.205 132.974 93.899 c
132.989 93.899 l
133.15 94.413 133.542 94.927 134.302 94.845 c
134.271 94.19 l
f 
136.617 91.008 m
135.581 91.008 134.906 91.589 134.906 92.893 c
134.906 93.981 135.612 94.845 136.763 94.845 c
137.738 94.845 138.483 94.324 138.483 92.99 c
138.483 91.873 137.746 91.008 136.617 91.008 c
h
136.702 94.286 m
136.149 94.286 135.627 93.877 135.627 92.96 c
135.627 92.066 136.003 91.575 136.702 91.575 c
137.27 91.575 137.761 92.007 137.761 92.953 c
137.761 93.795 137.408 94.286 136.702 94.286 c
f 
140.27 91.008 m
139.986 91.008 139.702 91.031 139.464 91.075 c
139.487 91.671 l
139.725 91.597 140.032 91.545 140.324 91.545 c
140.83 91.545 141.176 91.768 141.176 92.111 c
141.176 92.938 139.403 92.431 139.403 93.735 c
139.403 94.361 139.932 94.845 140.93 94.845 c
141.16 94.845 141.429 94.815 141.659 94.771 c
141.644 94.212 l
141.406 94.286 141.13 94.331 140.877 94.331 c
140.37 94.331 140.117 94.123 140.117 93.802 c
140.117 92.99 141.897 93.43 141.897 92.186 c
141.897 91.515 141.283 91.008 140.27 91.008 c
f 
144.388 90.703 m
143.943 89.556 143.583 89.183 142.738 89.183 c
142.592 89.183 142.393 89.205 142.239 89.228 c
142.301 89.831 l
142.462 89.779 142.615 89.757 142.792 89.757 c
143.214 89.757 143.437 89.943 143.705 90.658 c
143.866 91.075 l
142.424 94.778 l
143.206 94.778 l
143.928 92.856 l
144.051 92.521 144.135 92.23 144.22 91.94 c
144.235 91.94 l
144.304 92.2 144.465 92.67 144.611 93.08 c
145.225 94.778 l
145.977 94.778 l
144.388 90.703 l
f 
147.397 91.008 m
147.113 91.008 146.829 91.031 146.591 91.075 c
146.614 91.671 l
146.852 91.597 147.159 91.545 147.45 91.545 c
147.957 91.545 148.302 91.768 148.302 92.111 c
148.302 92.938 146.529 92.431 146.529 93.735 c
146.529 94.361 147.059 94.845 148.057 94.845 c
148.287 94.845 148.556 94.815 148.786 94.771 c
148.77 94.212 l
148.533 94.286 148.256 94.331 148.003 94.331 c
147.496 94.331 147.243 94.123 147.243 93.802 c
147.243 92.99 149.024 93.43 149.024 92.186 c
149.024 91.515 148.41 91.008 147.397 91.008 c
f 
151.329 91.016 m
150.546 91.016 150.308 91.329 150.308 92.126 c
150.308 94.257 l
149.525 94.257 l
149.525 94.778 l
150.308 94.778 l
150.308 95.978 l
150.999 96.164 l
150.999 94.778 l
152.066 94.778 l
152.066 94.257 l
150.999 94.257 l
150.999 92.364 l
150.999 91.753 151.114 91.589 151.544 91.589 c
151.72 91.589 151.912 91.619 152.066 91.657 c
152.066 91.09 l
151.851 91.046 151.574 91.016 151.329 91.016 c
f 
156.044 92.968 m
153.549 92.968 l
153.519 91.977 153.941 91.552 154.754 91.552 c
155.146 91.552 155.56 91.642 155.867 91.783 c
155.929 91.239 l
155.56 91.09 155.115 91.008 154.639 91.008 c
153.465 91.008 152.836 91.604 152.836 92.908 c
152.836 94.018 153.457 94.845 154.54 94.845 c
155.614 94.845 156.067 94.137 156.067 93.288 c
156.067 93.199 156.059 93.094 156.044 92.968 c
h
154.509 94.354 m
154.01 94.354 153.657 93.989 153.58 93.445 c
155.361 93.445 l
155.376 93.989 155.046 94.354 154.509 94.354 c
f 
161.845 91.075 m
161.845 93.452 l
161.845 93.966 161.722 94.294 161.223 94.294 c
160.678 94.294 160.156 93.735 160.156 92.841 c
160.156 91.075 l
159.473 91.075 l
159.473 93.46 l
159.473 93.921 159.373 94.294 158.851 94.294 c
158.268 94.294 157.784 93.69 157.784 92.841 c
157.784 91.075 l
157.093 91.075 l
157.093 94.778 l
157.761 94.778 l
157.761 94.562 157.746 94.227 157.7 94.003 c
157.715 93.996 l
157.938 94.518 158.429 94.853 159.043 94.853 c
159.849 94.853 160.064 94.309 160.095 94.011 c
160.256 94.361 160.663 94.853 161.399 94.853 c
162.121 94.853 162.535 94.473 162.535 93.638 c
162.535 91.075 l
161.845 91.075 l
f 
164.433 91.008 m
164.149 91.008 163.865 91.031 163.627 91.075 c
163.65 91.671 l
163.888 91.597 164.195 91.545 164.487 91.545 c
164.994 91.545 165.339 91.768 165.339 92.111 c
165.339 92.938 163.566 92.431 163.566 93.735 c
163.566 94.361 164.096 94.845 165.093 94.845 c
165.324 94.845 165.592 94.815 165.823 94.771 c
165.807 94.212 l
165.569 94.286 165.293 94.331 165.04 94.331 c
164.533 94.331 164.28 94.123 164.28 93.802 c
164.28 92.99 166.061 93.43 166.061 92.186 c
166.061 91.515 165.447 91.008 164.433 91.008 c
f 
126.966 95.389 m
127.219 95.389 127.426 95.59 127.426 95.829 c
127.426 96.075 127.219 96.261 126.966 96.261 c
126.713 96.261 126.505 96.067 126.505 95.829 c
126.505 95.583 126.713 95.389 126.966 95.389 c
f 
126.062 94.787 m
126.062 94.265 l
126.62 94.265 l
126.62 91.075 l
127.311 91.075 l
127.311 94.778 l
126.062 94.787 l
f 
168.659 79.658 m
168.659 79.388 l
168.309 79.388 l
168.309 78.062 l
167.99 78.062 l
167.99 79.388 l
167.64 79.388 l
167.64 79.658 l
168.659 79.658 l
f 
170.491 78.062 m
170.153 78.062 l
170.146 78.478 170.134 78.892 170.099 79.32 c
170.094 79.32 l
169.734 78.062 l
169.496 78.062 l
169.148 79.32 l
169.143 79.32 l
169.108 78.892 169.096 78.478 169.089 78.062 c
168.786 78.062 l
168.8 78.594 168.838 79.128 168.89 79.658 c
169.361 79.658 l
169.647 78.627 l
169.652 78.627 l
169.947 79.658 l
170.387 79.658 l
170.439 79.128 170.477 78.594 170.491 78.062 c
f 
89.088 79.647 m
89.088 78.949 l
88.181 78.949 l
88.181 75.513 l
87.354 75.513 l
87.354 78.949 l
86.448 78.949 l
86.448 79.647 l
89.088 79.647 l
f 
90.342 79.647 m
90.342 78.018 l
91.745 78.018 l
91.745 79.647 l
92.571 79.647 l
92.571 75.513 l
91.745 75.513 l
91.745 77.369 l
90.342 77.369 l
90.342 75.513 l
89.515 75.513 l
89.515 79.647 l
90.342 79.647 l
f 
95.322 79.647 m
95.322 78.961 l
94.018 78.961 l
94.018 77.944 l
95.102 77.944 l
95.102 77.295 l
94.018 77.295 l
94.018 76.211 l
95.347 76.211 l
95.347 75.513 l
93.191 75.513 l
93.191 79.647 l
95.322 79.647 l
f 
98.582 79.647 m
99.905 76.977 l
99.905 79.647 l
100.615 79.647 l
100.615 75.513 l
99.709 75.513 l
98.208 78.581 l
98.208 75.513 l
97.498 75.513 l
97.498 79.647 l
98.582 79.647 l
f 
103.366 79.647 m
103.366 78.961 l
102.062 78.961 l
102.062 77.944 l
103.146 77.944 l
103.146 77.295 l
102.062 77.295 l
102.062 76.211 l
103.391 76.211 l
103.391 75.513 l
101.235 75.513 l
101.235 79.647 l
103.366 79.647 l
f 
106.394 79.647 m
106.394 78.949 l
105.488 78.949 l
105.488 75.513 l
104.661 75.513 l
104.661 78.949 l
103.755 78.949 l
103.755 79.647 l
106.394 79.647 l
f 
108.215 76.683 m
108.888 79.647 l
109.623 79.647 l
110.297 76.683 l
110.309 76.683 l
110.536 77.681 110.738 78.704 110.866 79.647 c
111.613 79.647 l
111.399 78.257 111.081 76.842 110.658 75.513 c
109.825 75.513 l
109.201 78.201 l
109.188 78.201 l
108.551 75.513 l
107.682 75.513 l
107.278 76.885 106.971 78.269 106.775 79.647 c
107.657 79.647 l
107.768 78.808 107.976 77.785 108.202 76.683 c
108.215 76.683 l
f 
115.201 77.687 m
115.201 75.973 114.325 75.452 113.486 75.452 c
112.457 75.452 111.821 76.095 111.821 77.522 c
111.821 78.973 112.549 79.702 113.548 79.702 c
114.552 79.702 115.201 79.028 115.201 77.687 c
h
112.696 77.687 m
112.696 76.518 113.039 76.132 113.535 76.132 c
113.97 76.132 114.325 76.493 114.325 77.516 c
114.325 78.624 113.964 79.022 113.474 79.022 c
113.052 79.022 112.696 78.655 112.696 77.687 c
f 
117.056 79.665 m
118.06 79.665 118.52 79.193 118.52 78.489 c
118.52 77.975 118.213 77.54 117.638 77.326 c
118.673 75.513 l
117.687 75.513 l
116.842 77.191 l
116.658 77.191 l
116.658 75.513 l
115.831 75.513 l
115.831 79.647 l
116.266 79.659 116.67 79.665 117.056 79.665 c
h
116.658 77.846 m
116.793 77.834 116.909 77.834 117.019 77.834 c
117.399 77.834 117.662 78.091 117.662 78.41 c
117.662 78.777 117.485 79.01 116.97 79.01 c
116.872 79.01 116.762 79.004 116.658 78.998 c
116.658 77.846 l
f 
120.025 79.647 m
120.025 77.914 l
121.103 79.647 l
122.046 79.647 l
120.699 77.803 l
122.12 75.513 l
121.091 75.513 l
120.025 77.399 l
120.025 75.513 l
119.199 75.513 l
119.199 79.647 l
120.025 79.647 l
f 
123.818 79.647 0.827 -4.133 re
f 
127.487 78.857 m
127.278 78.961 126.984 79.059 126.721 79.059 c
126.36 79.059 126.151 78.838 126.151 78.575 c
126.151 77.785 127.891 77.999 127.891 76.695 c
127.891 76.021 127.401 75.44 126.409 75.44 c
125.98 75.44 125.582 75.574 125.196 75.844 c
125.435 76.322 l
125.655 76.217 125.962 76.101 126.305 76.101 c
126.782 76.101 126.972 76.315 126.972 76.585 c
126.972 77.369 125.294 77.099 125.294 78.477 c
125.294 79.175 125.796 79.696 126.611 79.696 c
127.052 79.696 127.419 79.555 127.713 79.31 c
127.487 78.857 l
f 
142.943 76.23 m
142.637 75.752 142.214 75.458 141.688 75.458 c
140.769 75.458 140.144 76.107 140.144 77.491 c
140.144 78.838 140.818 79.69 141.749 79.69 c
142.269 79.69 142.667 79.383 142.882 78.924 c
142.514 78.593 l
142.288 78.844 142.104 78.967 141.804 78.967 c
141.381 78.967 141.026 78.434 141.026 77.589 c
141.026 76.542 141.4 76.187 141.877 76.187 c
142.104 76.187 142.343 76.328 142.569 76.56 c
142.943 76.23 l
f 
146.646 77.687 m
146.646 75.973 145.77 75.452 144.931 75.452 c
143.902 75.452 143.265 76.095 143.265 77.522 c
143.265 78.973 143.994 79.702 144.992 79.702 c
145.997 79.702 146.646 79.028 146.646 77.687 c
h
144.141 77.687 m
144.141 76.518 144.484 76.132 144.98 76.132 c
145.415 76.132 145.77 76.493 145.77 77.516 c
145.77 78.624 145.409 79.022 144.919 79.022 c
144.496 79.022 144.141 78.655 144.141 77.687 c
f 
151.521 75.513 m
150.646 75.513 l
150.627 76.591 150.597 77.663 150.505 78.771 c
150.493 78.771 l
149.562 75.513 l
148.943 75.513 l
148.043 78.771 l
148.031 78.771 l
147.939 77.663 147.908 76.591 147.89 75.513 c
147.106 75.513 l
147.143 76.891 147.241 78.275 147.375 79.647 c
148.594 79.647 l
149.335 76.977 l
149.347 76.977 l
150.113 79.647 l
151.252 79.647 l
151.387 78.275 151.485 76.891 151.521 75.513 c
f 
153.268 79.659 m
154.376 79.659 154.891 79.132 154.891 78.385 c
154.891 77.577 154.321 76.971 153.115 76.971 c
152.998 76.971 l
152.998 75.513 l
152.172 75.513 l
152.172 79.647 l
152.57 79.647 152.919 79.659 153.268 79.659 c
h
152.998 77.601 m
153.188 77.601 l
153.721 77.601 154.009 77.828 154.009 78.293 c
154.009 78.746 153.77 79.004 153.157 79.004 c
152.998 79.004 l
152.998 77.601 l
f 
156.207 79.647 m
156.207 77.044 l
156.207 76.346 156.537 76.113 156.929 76.113 c
157.352 76.113 157.64 76.364 157.64 77.007 c
157.64 79.647 l
158.442 79.647 l
158.442 77.063 l
158.442 75.856 157.732 75.452 156.838 75.452 c
155.894 75.452 155.38 75.887 155.38 76.983 c
155.38 79.647 l
156.207 79.647 l
f 
161.492 79.647 m
161.492 78.949 l
160.585 78.949 l
160.585 75.513 l
159.758 75.513 l
159.758 78.949 l
158.852 78.949 l
158.852 79.647 l
161.492 79.647 l
f 
164.051 79.647 m
164.051 78.961 l
162.746 78.961 l
162.746 77.944 l
163.83 77.944 l
163.83 77.295 l
162.746 77.295 l
162.746 76.211 l
164.075 76.211 l
164.075 75.513 l
161.919 75.513 l
161.919 79.647 l
164.051 79.647 l
f 
165.856 79.665 m
166.86 79.665 167.32 79.193 167.32 78.489 c
167.32 77.975 167.013 77.54 166.438 77.326 c
167.473 75.513 l
166.487 75.513 l
165.642 77.191 l
165.458 77.191 l
165.458 75.513 l
164.631 75.513 l
164.631 79.647 l
165.066 79.659 165.47 79.665 165.856 79.665 c
h
165.458 77.846 m
165.593 77.834 165.709 77.834 165.819 77.834 c
166.199 77.834 166.462 78.091 166.462 78.41 c
166.462 78.777 166.285 79.01 165.77 79.01 c
165.672 79.01 165.562 79.004 165.458 78.998 c
165.458 77.846 l
f 
131.944 79.647 m
131.944 78.949 l
131.037 78.949 l
131.037 75.513 l
130.211 75.513 l
130.211 78.949 l
129.304 78.949 l
129.304 79.647 l
131.944 79.647 l
f 
133.198 79.647 m
133.198 78.018 l
134.601 78.018 l
134.601 79.647 l
135.428 79.647 l
135.428 75.513 l
134.601 75.513 l
134.601 77.369 l
133.198 77.369 l
133.198 75.513 l
132.372 75.513 l
132.372 79.647 l
133.198 79.647 l
f 
138.178 79.647 m
138.178 78.961 l
136.874 78.961 l
136.874 77.944 l
137.958 77.944 l
137.958 77.295 l
136.874 77.295 l
136.874 76.211 l
138.203 76.211 l
138.203 75.513 l
136.047 75.513 l
136.047 79.647 l
138.178 79.647 l
f 
1 g
/N142 /ExtGState findRes gs
85.5 83.15 85.71 -19.48 re
f* 
118.5 81.5 104.5 -34.25 re
f* 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 118.5 75.5 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(M/S MTV29-01)Tj
0 -1 TD
(901 San Antonio Road)Tj
T*
[(P)15 (alo Alto, CA 94303-4900)]TJ
/N130 1 Tf
18 0 0 18 85 672 Tm
[(An Ef\336cient Meta-loc)20 (k f)20 (o)0 (r)]TJ
0 -1.1111 TD
[(Implementing Ubiquitous Sync)10 (hr)20 (onization)]TJ
/N133 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 85 606 Tm
[(Ole Agesen, Da)20 (vid Detlefs)16 (, Ale)29 (x Gar)-40 (thw)15 (aite)15 (,)]TJ
0 -1.3333 TD
[(Ross Knippel, Y)140 (.)0 ( S)21 (.)0 ( Ramakr)-15 (ishna, and Derek White)]TJ
9 0 0 9 85 533 Tm
[(SMLI TR-99-76)-9165 (Apr)-15 (il 1999)]TJ
/N130 1 Tf
11 0 0 11 85 480.67 Tm
(Abstract:)Tj
/N133 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 85 458.33 Tm
[(Prog)10 (r)10 (ams)-431 (wr)-15 (itten)-431 (in)-431 (concurrent)-431 (object-or)-15 (iented)-431 (languages)15 (,)-431 (especially)-431 (ones)-432 (that)-431 (emplo)30 (y)-431 (threadsaf)30 (e)]TJ
0 -1.2 TD
[(reusab)20 (le)-277 (class)-277 (libr)10 (ar)-15 (ies)15 (,)-277 (can)-278 (e)31 (x)30 (ecute)-278 (synchronization)-277 (oper)10 (ations)-277 (\(loc)20 (k,)-277 (notify)100 (,)-277 (etc.\))-277 (at)-277 (an)-277 (amazing)-278 (r)10 (ate)15 (.)]TJ
T*
[(Unless)-365 (implemented)-364 (with)-365 (utmost)-364 (care)15 (,)-365 (synchronization)-365 (can)-364 (become)-365 (a)-364 (perf)30 (or)-25 (mance)-365 (bottlenec)20 (k.)-365 (Fur-)]TJ
T*
[(ther)-25 (more)15 (,)-431 (i)0 (n)-432 (languages)-431 (where)-432 (e)30 (v)25 (er)-30 (y)-431 (object)-432 (ma)30 (y)-431 (h)0 (a)20 (v)25 (e)-432 (its)-431 (o)15 (w)0 (n)-431 (monitor)50 (,)-432 (per-object)-431 (space)-432 (o)15 (v)25 (erhead)]TJ
T*
[(m)10 (ust)-275 (be)-275 (minimiz)15 (ed.)-275 (T)120 (o)-274 (address)-275 (these)-275 (concer)-25 (ns)15 (,)-275 (w)10 (e)-275 (h)0 (a)20 (v)25 (e)-275 (d)0 (e)30 (v)25 (eloped)-274 (a)-275 (meta-loc)20 (k)-275 (t)0 (o)-275 (mediate)-275 (access)-275 (to)]TJ
T*
[(synchronization)-256 (data.)-257 (The)-256 (meta-loc)20 (k)-256 (i)0 (s)-256 (f)30 (ast)-257 (\(loc)20 (k)-256 (+)-256 (unloc)20 (k)-256 (e)30 (x)30 (ecutes)-257 (in)-256 (11)-256 (SP)120 (ARC\252)-256 (instr)-15 (uctions\),)-257 (com-)]TJ
T*
[(pact)-288 (\(uses)-288 (only)-288 (tw)10 (o)-288 (bits)-288 (of)-288 (space\),)-288 (rob)20 (ust)-288 (under)-288 (contention)-288 (\(no)-288 (b)19 (usy-w)15 (aiting\),)-287 (and)-289 (\337e)30 (xib)20 (le)-288 (\(suppor)-40 (ts)-288 (a)]TJ
T*
[(v)25 (a)0 (r)-15 (iety)-394 (of)-393 (higher-le)30 (v)25 (e)0 (l)-393 (synchronization)-394 (oper)10 (ations\).)-393 (W)30 (e)-394 (ha)20 (v)25 (e)-393 (v)25 (alidated)-394 (the)-393 (meta-loc)20 (k)-394 (with)-393 (an)-394 (imple-)]TJ
T*
[(mentation)-501 (of)-501 (the)-501 (synchronization)-500 (oper)9 (ations)-500 (in)-501 (a)-501 (high-perf)30 (or)-25 (mance)-501 (product-quality)-501 (J)20 (a)20 (v)25 (a\252)-501 (vir)-40 (tual)]TJ
T*
[(machine and repor)-40 (t perf)30 (or)-25 (mance data f)30 (or se)30 (v)25 (e)0 (r)10 (al large prog)10 (r)10 (ams)15 (.)]TJ
ET
1 g
441 117 112.71 -67.5 re
f* 
BT
/N91 1 Tf
8 0 0 8 441 111.67 Tm
0 g
[(email addr)18 (ess:)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
0 -1.25 TD
(ole.agesen@sun.com)Tj
0 -1.125 TD
[(da)20 (vid.detlefs@sun.com)]TJ
T*
[(ale)15 (x.garthw)11 (aite@sun.com)]TJ
T*
(ross.knippel@sun.com)Tj
T*
[(y)65 (.s.ramakrishna@sun.com)]TJ
T*
(derek.white@sun.com)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 3 3
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
/N9 <<
/SA false 
/OP false 
>> /ExtGState defineRes pop
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N9 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
72 243 468 -207 re
f* 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
8 0 0 8 72 237.67 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
[(\251)-328 (1999)-328 (Sun)-328 (Microsystems,)-328 (Inc.)-328 (All)-327 (rights)-328 (reserv)15 (ed.)-327 (The)-328 (SML)-328 (T)70 (echnical)-328 (Report)-327 (Series)-329 (is)-327 (published)-329 (by)-328 (Sun)-328 (Microsystems)-327 (Laboratories,)-329 (of)-327 (Sun)]TJ
0 -1.25 TD
0 Tw
(Microsystems, Inc. Printed in U.S.A.)Tj
0 -2.5 TD
[(Unlimited)-238 (cop)10 (ying)-237 (without)-237 (fee)-238 (is)-237 (permitted)-237 (pro)14 (vided)-237 (that)-238 (the)-237 (copies)-238 (are)-238 (not)-237 (made)-237 (nor)-237 (distrib)20 (uted)-238 (for)-237 (direct)-237 (commercial)-238 (adv)25 (antage,)-238 (and)-237 (credit)-237 (to)-237 (the)]TJ
0 -1.25 TD
[(source)-263 (is)-263 (gi)25 (v)15 (en.)-262 (Otherwise,)-263 (no)-263 (part)-263 (of)-263 (this)-263 (w)11 (ork)-263 (co)15 (v)15 (ered)-263 (by)-263 (cop)10 (yright)-262 (hereon)-263 (may)-262 (be)-264 (reproduced)-262 (in)-262 (an)14 (y)-262 (form)-262 (or)-262 (by)-263 (an)15 (y)-263 (means)-263 (graphic,)-264 (electronic,)]TJ
T*
[(or)-238 (mechanical,)-240 (including)-238 (photocop)9 (ying,)-238 (recording,)-239 (taping,)-239 (or)-240 (storage)-238 (in)-240 (an)-239 (information)-239 (retrie)25 (v)25 (a)0 (l)-239 (system,)-238 (without)-239 (the)-239 (prior)-239 (written)-238 (permission)-240 (of)-238 (t)]TJ
57.5555 0 TD
(he)Tj
-57.5555 -1.25 TD
[(cop)10 (yright o)25 (wner)54 (.)]TJ
0 -2.5 TD
(TRADEMARKS)Tj
0 -1.25 TD
[(Sun,)-347 (Sun)-345 (Microsystems,)-347 (the)-346 (Sun)-347 (logo,)-346 (Solaris,)-346 (Ja)19 (v)25 (a)0 (,)-346 (JDK,)-346 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-346 (W)80 (e)0 (b)-346 (Serv)14 (er)41 (,)-346 (and)-346 (Ja)19 (v)25 (a)-346 (HotSpot)-346 (are)-345 (trademarks)-346 (or)-347 (re)16 (gistered)-347 (trademarks)-346 (of)-346 (Sun)]TJ
T*
[(Microsystems,)-279 (Inc.)-281 (in)-280 (the)-279 (U.S.)-280 (and)-279 (other)-280 (countries.)-280 (All)-278 (SP)92 (ARC)-280 (trademarks)-280 (are)-279 (used)-280 (under)-279 (license)-279 (and)-280 (are)-280 (trademarks)-280 (or)-280 (re)16 (gistered)-280 (trademarks)-280 (of)]TJ
T*
[(SP)92 (ARC)-277 (International,)-278 (Inc.)-277 (in)-277 (the)-277 (U.S.)-277 (and)-277 (other)-276 (countries.)-277 (Products)-278 (bearing)-277 (SP)92 (ARC)-277 (trademarks)-277 (are)-277 (based)-277 (upon)-278 (an)-277 (architecture)-276 (de)25 (v)15 (eloped)-278 (by)-276 (Sun)]TJ
T*
(Microsystems, Inc.)Tj
0 -2.5 TD
[(F)15 (or information re)16 (garding the SML T)69 (echnical Report Series, contact Jeanie T)36 (reichel, Editor)20 (-in-Chief <jeanie.treichel@eng.sun.co)]TJ
51.9535 0 TD
(m>.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 4 4
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(1)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
18 0 0 18 204.99 664 Tm
[(An Ef\336cient Meta-lock f)24 (o)0 (r)]TJ
-3.4917 -1.2222 TD
[(Implementing Ubiquitous Synchr)18 (onization)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 170.78 582.67 Tm
(Ole Agesen)Tj
11.2 0 0 11.2 236.48 588.27 Tm
(*)Tj
14 0 0 14 242.08 582.67 Tm
[(, Da)20 (vid Detlefs)]TJ
11.2 0 0 11.2 326.95 588.27 Tm
(*)Tj
14 0 0 14 332.55 582.67 Tm
[(, Ale)15 (x Garthw)10 (aite)]TJ
11.2 0 0 11.2 432.12 588.27 Tm
(*)Tj
14 0 0 14 437.72 582.67 Tm
(,)Tj
-19.425 -1.2857 TD
(Ross Knippel)Tj
11.2 0 0 11.2 241.61 570.27 Tm
(+)Tj
14 0 0 14 247.93 564.67 Tm
[(, Y)129 (.S. Ramakrishna)]TJ
11.2 0 0 11.2 355.39 570.27 Tm
(+)Tj
14 0 0 14 361.71 564.67 Tm
(, Derek White)Tj
11.2 0 0 11.2 440.63 570.27 Tm
(*)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 413.33 Tm
[(1  Intr)18 (oduction)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 390 Tm
[(Shared-memory)-394 (multi-processor)-393 (systems)-394 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-394 (become)-394 (mainstream,)-394 (e)25 (v)15 (en)-394 (in)-394 (the)-394 (personal)-394 (com-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(puter)-337 (mark)10 (et.)-337 (Simultaneously)65 (,)-337 (the)-338 (concurrent)-337 (object-oriented)-336 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)0 (\252)-337 (programming)-337 (language)-337 ([2])]TJ
T*
[(has)-253 (e)16 (xperienced)-253 (e)16 (xplosi)25 (v)15 (e)-253 (gro)25 (wth.)-252 (As)-253 (a)-252 (result,)-252 (signi\336cant)-253 (ef)25 (fort)-253 (is)-252 (being)-252 (de)25 (v)20 (oted)-252 (to)-253 (implementing)]TJ
T*
[(both)-380 (the)-381 (sequential)-380 (and)-381 (parallel)-380 (features)-381 (of)-380 (this)-381 (language,)-381 (e.g.,)-380 ([3,)-381 (13,)-381 (14,)-380 (21,)-381 (25].)-381 (This)-380 (paper)]TJ
T*
[(focuses)-242 (on)-242 (the)-242 (latter)-242 (area,)-242 (proposing)-241 (a)-242 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-241 (implementation)-242 (of)-242 (synchronization)-241 (operations)-242 (that,)-242 (we)]TJ
T*
[(belie)25 (v)15 (e)0 (,)-305 (possesses)-306 (an)-306 (attracti)25 (v)15 (e)-306 (set)-306 (of)-305 (trade-of)25 (fs)-305 (between)-305 (space,)-306 (time,)-306 (and)-305 (assumptions)-306 (about)-306 (the)]TJ
T*
[(underlying)-331 (hardw)10 (are.)-331 (Implementors)-331 (of)-331 (the)-331 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-331 (language\325)55 (s)-331 (synchronization)-331 (operations)-331 (are)-331 (chal-)]TJ
T*
[(lenged on tw)10 (o fronts:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 72 272 Tm
( \245)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 85.75 272 Tm
[(F)55 (r)37 (equency)55 (.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.7092 0 TD
[(Most)-330 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-330 (programs)-330 (synchronize)-329 (e)15 (xtremely)-330 (frequently)65 (.)-331 (This)-330 (occurs)-330 (because)-330 (stan-)]TJ
-4.7092 -1.1667 TD
[(dard)-227 (class)-227 (libraries,)-227 (including)-227 (commonly)-227 (used)-227 (data)-227 (types)-227 (such)-227 (as)-227 (v)15 (ectors)-227 (and)-227 (b)20 (u)0 (f)25 (fers,)-227 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-227 (been)]TJ
T*
[(designed)-333 (for)-333 (the)-333 (general)-334 (multi-threaded)-333 (case.)-333 (T)80 (o)-333 (gi)26 (v)15 (e)-334 (just)-333 (one)-333 (e)15 (xample,)-333 (we)-333 (measured)-333 (on)-333 (the)]TJ
T*
[(SPECjvm98)-343 (v)15 (ersion)-343 (of)-343 (ja)20 (v)25 (a)0 (c)-344 ([26],)-343 (a)-343 (source-to-bytecode)-342 (compiler)40 (,)-343 (and)-343 (found)-343 (that)-343 (on)-342 (a)-344 (high-)]TJ
T*
[(performance)-360 (virtual)-361 (machine,)-359 (EVM)]TJ
9.6 0 0 9.6 261.01 220.8 Tm
(1)Tj
12 0 0 12 265.81 216 Tm
[(,)-360 (this)-360 (program)-360 (e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-360 (765,000)-360 (synchronization)-360 (opera-)]TJ
-15.005 -1.1667 TD
(tions per second.)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 72 182 Tm
( \245)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 85.75 182 Tm
[(Ubiquity)56 (.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.0467 0 TD
[(The)-352 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-352 (language,)-352 (unlik)10 (e)-352 (most)-352 (concurrent)-351 (languages,)-352 (does)-352 (not)-352 (de\336ne)-352 (a)-352 (particular)]TJ
-4.0467 -1.1667 TD
[(type)-270 (of)-270 (synchronizable)-271 (object)-270 (such)-270 (as)-270 (a)-271 (monitor)-270 (or)-270 (a)-270 (mute)15 (x.)-271 (Instead,)-270 (an)15 (y)-270 (object,)-271 (including,)-270 (for)]TJ
T*
[(e)15 (xample,)-323 (strings)-324 (and)-323 (arrays,)-324 (can)-324 (be)-324 (synchronized)-323 (upon.)-324 (This)-324 (design)-324 (of)26 (fers)-323 (the)-324 (programmer)-323 (a)]TJ
T*
[(simpler)-247 (and)-246 (more)-246 (re)15 (gular)-246 (language,)-246 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-246 (presents)-246 (an)-246 (obstacle)-246 (to)-246 (the)-246 (language)-246 (implementor:)-247 (syn-)]TJ
T*
[(chronization)-247 (must)-248 (be)-248 (implemented)-248 (at)-248 (a)-248 (l)0 (o)25 (w)-247 (per)20 (-object)-248 (space)-247 (cost.)-248 (More)-247 (precisely)65 (,)-248 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
34.2725 0 TD
(ability)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.8033 0 TD
(to)Tj
ET
0 G
2 J
0 j
0.36 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
204 98 m
72 98 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 72 83.33 Tm
[(1.)-699 (EVM,)-350 (the)-350 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-350 (virtual)-349 (machine)-350 (kno)25 (wn)-350 (pre)25 (viously)-350 (as)-349 (ExactVM,)-350 (is)-350 (embedded)-349 (in)-350 (Sun\325)55 (s)-350 (J)0 (a)20 (v)25 (a)-349 (2)-350 (SDK)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
42.345 0 TD
[(Pr)45 (oduction)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
-42.345 -1.2 TD
[(Release, a)20 (v)25 (ailable at http://www)65 (.sun.com/solaris/ja)20 (v)25 (a/.)]TJ
11.2 0 0 11.2 118.23 536.77 Tm
(*)Tj
14 0 0 14 126.07 531.17 Tm
(Sun Microsystems Laboratories)Tj
0 -1.2143 TD
[(One Netw)10 (ork Dri)25 (v)15 (e)]TJ
T*
(Burlington, MA 01803-0902)Tj
11.2 0 0 11.2 330.9 536.77 Tm
(+)Tj
14 0 0 14 340.57 531.17 Tm
(Sun Microsystems, Inc.)Tj
T*
(901 San Antonio Road)Tj
T*
[(P)15 (alo Alto, CA 94303-4900)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 5 5
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(2)Tj
-18.1042 56.4858 TD
[(synchronize)-325 (must)-326 (be)-326 (pro)16 (vided)-325 (at)-326 (a)-325 (l)0 (o)25 (w)-325 (space)-326 (cost;)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
20.9425 0 TD
(actual)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.8258 0 TD
[(synchronization)-325 (can)-326 (use)-325 (additional)]TJ
-23.7683 -1.1667 TD
[(space)-376 (since,)-377 (in)-376 (practice,)-376 (programs)-376 (synchronize)-376 (on)-377 (a)-376 (small)-376 (fraction)-377 (of)-376 (objects.)-376 (F)15 (o)0 (r)-376 (e)15 (xample,)]TJ
T*
[(ja)20 (v)25 (ac, discussed abo)15 (v)15 (e, synchronizes on about 6% of allocated objects.)]TJ
-1.1458 -1.75 TD
[(Frequenc)15 (y)-244 (demands)-244 (time-ef)26 (\336cienc)14 (y)-243 (while)-245 (ubiquity)-243 (demands)-244 (space-ef)25 (\336cienc)15 (y)65 (.)-244 (This)-244 (paper)-244 (presents)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(a)-289 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-290 (synchronization)-289 (scheme)-289 (that,)-290 (we)-289 (belie)25 (v)15 (e)0 (,)-289 (attains)-290 (good)-289 (all-around)-290 (performance:)-290 (synchroni-)]TJ
T*
[(zation)-295 (e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-295 (at)-295 (close)-295 (to)-295 (the)-295 (speed)-295 (of)-295 (the)-295 (hardw)10 (are)-295 (operations)-295 (while)-295 (reserving)-295 (only)-295 (tw)10 (o)-295 (bits)-295 (in)]TJ
T*
[(each)-296 (object.)-297 (Our)-296 (algorithm,)-297 (in)-296 (its)-297 (basic)-296 (form,)-297 (uses)-296 (a)-296 (t)0 (w)10 (o-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-296 (\(\322meta\323\))-297 (locking)-296 (scheme,)-297 (with)-296 (an)]TJ
T*
[(optional e)16 (xtension that fuses the tw)10 (o le)25 (v)15 (els for higher performance in uncontended cases.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(W)80 (e)-276 (assume)-276 (the)-276 (arbitrary)-276 (interlea)21 (ving)-276 (implied)-276 (by)-276 (preempti)25 (v)15 (e)-276 (thread)-276 (scheduling:)-276 (no)-276 (other)-276 (assump-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(tion)-336 (mak)10 (es)-337 (sense)-336 (on)-337 (multiprocessors,)-337 (and,)-337 (moreo)15 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-337 (e)25 (v)15 (en)-337 (on)-337 (uniprocessors)-337 (lack)-336 (of)-337 (preemption)]TJ
T*
[(can)-344 (lead)-344 (to)-344 (unf)10 (air)-344 (\(and)-344 (unintuiti)25 (v)15 (e)0 (\))-345 (thread)-344 (scheduling.)-343 (It)-344 (may)-345 (seem)-344 (that)-344 (synchronization)-343 (opera-)]TJ
T*
[(tions)-226 (could)-225 (be)-225 (elided)-225 (for)-226 (man)15 (y)-225 (programs)-225 (with)-225 (only)-226 (a)-225 (single)-225 (thread.)-226 (In)-225 (reality)65 (,)-226 (h)0 (o)25 (w)0 (e)25 (v)15 (er)40 (,)-226 (n)0 (o)-225 (program)]TJ
T*
[(written)-333 (in)-334 (the)-333 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-333 (language)-332 (is)-334 (single-threaded,)-332 (since,)-333 (in)-333 (addition)-333 (to)-334 (the)-333 (main)-332 (thread)-333 (created)-333 (by)]TJ
T*
[(user)-373 (code,)-374 (the)-374 (class)-373 (libraries)-374 (create)-373 (special)-374 (threads)-374 (to)-373 (handle)-374 (\336nalization)-373 (and)-373 (v)25 (arious)-373 (forms)-373 (of)]TJ
T*
[(weak)-275 (references)-274 ([27].)-275 (More)-274 (signi\336cantly)65 (,)-275 (perhaps,)-275 (commonly)-274 (used)-274 (graphics)-274 (libraries,)-274 (such)-274 (as)-275 (the)]TJ
T*
[(Abstract W)41 (indo)25 (ws T)80 (oolkit \(A)90 (WT\), create threads.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-279 (rest)-278 (of)-279 (this)-279 (paper)-279 (is)-279 (or)18 (ganized)-279 (as)-279 (follo)26 (ws.)-279 (Section)-279 (2)-279 (informally)-279 (describes)-279 (the)-279 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-279 (language\325)56 (s)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(synchronization)-357 (operations,)-357 (at)-358 (both)-357 (the)-357 (source)-357 (and)-358 (bytecode)-356 (le)25 (v)15 (els.)-357 (Section)-357 (3)-357 (r)0 (e)25 (vie)25 (ws)-357 (pre)25 (vious)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ork)-338 (most)-337 (closely)-337 (related)-337 (to)-338 (our)-337 (synchronization)-337 (algorithm.)-337 (Section)-337 (4)-337 (describes)-337 (our)-338 (basic)-337 (tw)10 (o-)]TJ
T*
[(le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-228 (algorithm,)-227 (and)-228 (Section)-228 (5)-227 (g)0 (i)25 (v)15 (es)-228 (an)-228 (informal)-227 (correctness)-228 (proof.)-227 (Section)-228 (6)-228 (discusses)-228 (e)16 (xtensions,)]TJ
T*
[(including)-268 (a)-269 (f)10 (ast)-268 (path)-269 (that)-268 (fuses)-268 (the)-269 (primary)-268 (and)-268 (meta-lock)-268 (le)25 (v)15 (els,)-268 (and)-268 (other)-268 (optimizations)-268 (that)-269 (are)]TJ
T*
[(important)-269 (for)-269 (good)-269 (performance.)-269 (Section)-269 (7)-270 (presents)-269 (performance)-269 (data)-269 (to)-269 (quantify)-269 (the)-269 (beha)20 (vior)-269 (of)]TJ
T*
[(our algorithm. Section 8 of)26 (fers \336nal conclusions and some directions for further w)12 (ork.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 348.33 Tm
[(2  Backgr)18 (ound)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 325 Tm
[(Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-254 (virtual)-254 (machines)-254 (\(JVMs\))-254 (do)-254 (not)-254 (e)16 (x)15 (ecute)-255 (source)-254 (code)-254 (directly)65 (.)-254 (Instead,)-253 (the)15 (y)-254 (e)15 (x)15 (ecute)-254 (bytecode)]TJ
T*
[(obtained)-232 (from)-233 (binary)-233 (class-\336les)-232 (that)-233 (are)-232 (produced)-233 (by)-232 (a)-233 (source-to-bytecode)-232 (compiler)-233 (such)-233 (as)-233 (ja)20 (v)25 (ac.)]TJ
T*
[(Thus,)-292 (JVMs)-292 (must)-292 (implement)-292 (the)-292 (bytecode-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-291 (synchronization)-292 (operations,)-291 (not)-292 (the)-292 (source-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)]TJ
T*
[(synchronization)-384 (operations.)-385 (The)-385 (distinction)-384 (is)-385 (important)-384 (because)-385 (the)-385 (bytecode-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-385 (operations)]TJ
T*
[(are more general than the source-le)25 (v)15 (el operations.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 236.67 Tm
[(2.1  Sour)18 (ce-le)15 (v)10 (el synchr)17 (onization)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 212 Tm
[(The)-304 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-304 (language)-304 (pro)15 (vides)-304 (mutual)-304 (e)16 (xclusion)-304 (in)-304 (tw)10 (o)-304 (syntactic)-304 (forms.)-304 (A)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
29.3975 0 TD
[(sync)15 (hr)45 (onized)-304 (method)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
8.7692 0 TD
(of)Tj
-38.1667 -1.1667 TD
[(an)-251 (object)-251 (obtains)-250 (a)-251 (lock)-251 (on)-251 (the)-250 (object,)-251 (e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-251 (the)-250 (method,)-251 (and)-251 (releases)-251 (the)-251 (lock.)-250 (A)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
33.7825 0 TD
[(sync)15 (hr)45 (onized)]TJ
-33.7825 -1.1667 TD
(statement)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8333 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.9967 0 TD
[(synchronize)-600 (\(exp\))-600 ({)-600 (...actions...)-600 (})]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
21 0 TD
[(,)-747 (e)25 (v)25 (aluates)-746 (the)-747 (e)15 (xpression)-746 (to)]TJ
-25.83 -1.1667 TD
[(obtain an object that is lock)11 (ed for the duration of the speci\336ed actions.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-246 (synchronization)-246 (operations)-246 (in)-246 (the)-245 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-246 (language)-246 (are)-246 (reentrant)-246 (\(recursi)25 (v)15 (e\):)-246 (synchronized)-246 (state-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(ments)-320 (on)-320 (the)-320 (same)-320 (object)-320 (can)-320 (nest,)-320 (synchronized)-319 (methods)-320 (can)-320 (in)41 (v)20 (o)0 (k)10 (e)-320 (other)-320 (synchronized)-319 (meth-)]TJ
T*
[(ods,)-260 (and)-259 (the)-260 (tw)10 (o)-260 (can)-259 (be)-260 (mix)15 (ed.)-260 (Consequently)65 (,)-260 (the)-260 (underlying)-260 (lock)-260 (and)-260 (unlock)-260 (operations)-260 (must)-260 (do)]TJ
T*
[(some)-298 (form)-298 (of)-299 (counting.)-297 (Both)-298 (synchronized)-298 (methods)-298 (and)-298 (statements)-298 (are)-298 (\322block)-298 (structured,)70 (\323)-298 (forc-)]TJ
T*
[(ing)-324 (perfect)-324 (nesting)-324 (of)-324 (locking)-324 (operations.)-324 (At)-323 (the)-325 (source)-323 (le)25 (v)15 (el,)-324 (there)-323 (is)-324 (no)-324 (w)10 (a)0 (y)-323 (t)0 (o)-324 (e)15 (xpress)-324 (unbal-)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 6 6
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(3)Tj
-19.25 56.4858 TD
[(anced)-344 (locking)-343 (operations.)-343 (In)-344 (particular)40 (,)-343 (e)15 (xception-thro)26 (wing)-343 (and)-344 (returning)-343 (out)-344 (of)-344 (lock)10 (ed)-343 (re)15 (gions)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(unlocks as necessary)66 (. Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)0 ( as we shall see belo)25 (w)65 (,)0 ( the story is dif)25 (ferent at the bytecode le)25 (v)15 (el.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(T)80 (o)-410 (f)10 (acilitate)-410 (communication)-410 (between)-410 (threads,)-409 (the)-410 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-410 (language)-410 (de\336nes)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
30.3008 0 TD
(wait)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.66 0 TD
(notify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.535 0 TD
[(,)-410 (and)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-36.8958 -1.1667 TD
(notifyAll)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.6608 0 TD
[(operations.)-260 (Lik)10 (e)-260 (locking,)-261 (these)-261 (operations)-260 (are)-261 (performed)-260 (relati)25 (v)15 (e)-261 (to)-261 (an)-260 (object.)-261 (Prior)]TJ
-5.6608 -1.1667 TD
[(to)-415 (e)15 (x)15 (ecuting)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.4667 0 TD
(wait)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.8158 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.8592 0 TD
(notify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6 0 TD
([)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.3333 0 TD
(All)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(],)-415 (a)-415 (thread)-416 (must)-415 (\336rst)-416 (lock)-415 (the)-415 (tar)18 (get)-415 (object.)-416 (Informally)66 (,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-15.875 -1.1667 TD
(wait)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6775 0 TD
[(fully)-277 (releases)-277 (the)-277 (lock)-277 (and)-278 (suspends)-277 (the)-277 (current)-277 (thread.)-277 (This)-278 (allo)25 (ws)-277 (other)-277 (threads)-278 (to)-277 (obtain)]TJ
-2.6775 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-448 (lock.)-448 (The)-448 (w)10 (aiting)-449 (thread)-448 (becomes)-448 (eligible)-447 (to)-449 (run)-448 (ag)6 (ain)-449 (when)-447 (another)-448 (thread)-448 (performs)-447 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
T*
(notify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.9542 0 TD
[(operation)-354 (on)-354 (the)-355 (object,)-354 (a)-354 (speci\336ed)-354 (time)-354 (has)-354 (elapsed,)-354 (or)-354 (an)-353 (asynchronous)-355 (interrupt)-354 (is)]TJ
-3.9542 -1.1667 TD
[(deli)25 (v)15 (ered)-275 (to)-275 (the)-275 (thread.)-275 (The)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
11.36 0 TD
(notify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.875 0 TD
[(operation)-274 (w)9 (a)0 (k)10 (e)0 (s)-274 (one)-275 (w)10 (aiting)-275 (thread,)-275 (whereas)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
18.365 0 TD
(notifyAll)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-33.6 -1.1667 TD
[(w)10 (a)0 (k)10 (e)0 (s)-230 (all)-229 (w)9 (aiting)-229 (threads)-230 (\(when)-229 (no)-230 (threads)-230 (are)-230 (w)10 (aiting,)-230 (both)-229 (operations)-230 (are)-230 (no-ops\).)-230 (When)-229 (a)-230 (w)10 (ait-)]TJ
T*
[(ing)-252 (thread)-253 (w)10 (a)0 (k)10 (e)0 (s)-252 (up,)-252 (it)-252 (reacquires)-252 (the)-252 (lock)-252 (the)-252 (same)-252 (number)-251 (of)-253 (times)-252 (it)-252 (held)-252 (it)-252 (prior)-252 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
34.5425 0 TD
(wait)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-253 (The)]TJ
-36.9425 -1.1667 TD
[(lock)-342 (reacquisition)-342 (puts)-342 (the)-342 (thread)-342 (into)-342 (competition)-342 (with)-342 (other)-342 (threads)-342 (attempting)-342 (to)-342 (acquire)-343 (the)]TJ
T*
[(lock,)-365 (including)-366 (both)-365 (other)-366 (a)15 (w)10 (ak)10 (ened)-365 (w)9 (aiters)-366 (and)-365 (threads)-366 (attempting)-365 (to)-365 (e)15 (x)15 (ecute)-366 (a)-366 (synchronized)]TJ
T*
[(method)-346 (or)-345 (statement.)-346 (Once)-346 (a)-345 (w)10 (aiting)-345 (thread)-346 (has)-345 (reacquired)-346 (the)-345 (lock,)-346 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
30.0767 0 TD
(wait)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.7458 0 TD
[(operation)-345 (com-)]TJ
-32.8225 -1.1667 TD
[(pletes.)-239 (T)80 (o)-240 (simplify)-239 (matters,)-239 (in)-239 (this)-240 (paper)-239 (we)-240 (shall)-240 (not)-239 (discuss)-240 (interrupts)-239 (further)40 (,)-240 (e)16 (xcept)-240 (to)-239 (note)-240 (that)]TJ
T*
(in most of our implementation, an interrupt is handled similarly to a ti\
me-out.)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 462.67 Tm
[(2.2  Bytecode-le)15 (v)10 (el synchr)18 (onization)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 438 Tm
[(Ha)20 (ving)-269 (described)-268 (synchronization)-267 (at)-268 (the)-268 (source)-268 (le)25 (v)15 (el,)-268 (we)-268 (no)25 (w)-268 (turn)-268 (to)-268 (the)-268 (bytecode)-268 (le)25 (v)15 (el.)-269 (In)-268 (byte-)]TJ
T*
[(code,)-693 (method)-692 (synchronization)-692 (is)-693 (performed)-692 (as)-693 (part)-692 (of)-693 (the)-693 (call/return)-692 (sequence:)-693 (if)-693 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
T*
(acc_synchronized)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.8625 0 TD
[(attrib)20 (ute)-263 (is)-262 (set)-262 (on)-262 (a)-263 (method,)-262 (the)-262 (call)-263 (sequence)-262 (must)-262 (acquire)-263 (the)-262 (lock)-263 (\(one)]TJ
-9.8625 -1.1667 TD
[(more)-286 (time\))-286 (and)-286 (the)-286 (return)-285 (sequence)-286 (must)-286 (release)-286 (it)-286 (once.)-286 (Statement)-286 (synchronization)-286 (is)-285 (e)15 (xpressed)]TJ
T*
[(using)-368 (a)-368 (bytecode)-368 (pair)40 (,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.4592 0 TD
(monitorenter)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.5683 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.8125 0 TD
(monitorexit)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.6 0 TD
[(,)-368 (which)-368 (lock)-368 (and)-368 (unlock,)-369 (respec-)]TJ
-25.44 -1.1667 TD
[(ti)25 (v)15 (ely)65 (,)-322 (the)-323 (object)-322 (referenced)-322 (by)-322 (a)-323 (v)25 (alue)-322 (popped)-322 (from)-323 (the)-322 (JVM\325)55 (s)-322 (\322operand)-322 (stack.)70 (\323)-323 (Unfortunately)65 (,)]TJ
T*
[(while)-290 (the)-290 (bytecode)-290 (representation)-289 (of)-290 (synchronized)-289 (methods)-290 (is)-290 (inherently)-290 (well-nested,)-290 (there)-290 (is)-290 (no)]TJ
T*
[(such)-266 (guarantee)-266 (for)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7.685 0 TD
(monitorenter)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.4658 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.7108 0 TD
(monitorexit)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.6 0 TD
[(.)-266 (Nothing)-267 (pre)25 (v)15 (ents)-266 (bytecode)-266 (from)-267 (con-)]TJ
-23.4617 -1.1667 TD
[(taining)-290 (instruction)-290 (sequences)-291 (lik)10 (e)-290 (\322lock)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
16.2183 0 TD
(A)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.6108 0 TD
[(,)-291 (lock)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
2.5533 0 TD
(B)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.6108 0 TD
[(,)-290 (unlock)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
3.5525 0 TD
(A)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.6117 0 TD
[(,)-290 (unlock)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
3.5525 0 TD
(B)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.6108 0 TD
[(,)70 (\323)-291 (which)-290 (has)-290 (no)-291 (equi)25 (v)25 (alent)]TJ
-28.3208 -1.1667 TD
[(Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-264 (source)-264 (code.)-264 (The)-264 (loss)-264 (of)-264 (block)-264 (structure)-263 (at)-265 (the)-264 (bytecode)-264 (le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-264 (mak)10 (es)-264 (it)-264 (dif)25 (\336cult)-264 (to)-264 (stack)-263 (allo-)]TJ
T*
[(cate)-366 (locking-related)-365 (data)-365 (structures.)-365 (Consequently)64 (,)-365 (t)0 (o)-365 (handle)-366 (non-LIFO)-365 (locking)-366 (and)-365 (unlocking,)]TJ
T*
(our implementation uses a free-list allocator \(see Section 6.1\).)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(Concei)25 (v)25 (ably)65 (,)-319 (a)-319 (static)-320 (analysis)-319 (of)-319 (bytecode)-319 (could)-320 (conserv)25 (ati)25 (v)15 (ely)-319 (\322pair)-320 (up\323)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
30.0367 0 TD
(monitorenter)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.5192 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-37.5558 -1.1667 TD
(monitorexit)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.0375 0 TD
[(instructions)-437 (in)-438 (most)-437 (cases,)-437 (allo)25 (wing)-437 (subsequent)-437 (e)15 (x)15 (ecution)-437 (to)-438 (assume)-438 (perfect)]TJ
-7.0375 -1.1667 TD
[(nesting.)-335 (W)80 (e)-335 (w)10 (ould)-335 (e)16 (xpect)-336 (this)-335 (analysis)-334 (to)-335 (succeed)-335 (most)-335 (of)-335 (the)-335 (time)-335 (on)-335 (bytecode)-335 (resulting)-335 (from)]TJ
T*
[(translation)-274 (of)-274 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-274 (source)-274 (code.)-274 (In)-274 (general,)-274 (ho)26 (we)24 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-274 (the)-275 (problem)-274 (is)-275 (undecidable,)-274 (and)-274 (it)-274 (w)10 (ould)-274 (be)]TJ
T*
[(incorrect)-257 (to)-257 (reject)-258 (bytecode)-257 (for)-257 (which)-258 (the)-258 (analysis)-257 (f)10 (ails,)-257 (because)-258 (such)-257 (bytecode)-257 (is)-258 (still)-257 (le)15 (gal)-258 (i)0 (n)-258 (the)]TJ
T*
[(sense)-371 (that)-372 (it)-371 (passes)-371 (the)-371 (bytecode)-371 (v)15 (eri\336er)-371 ([18].)-371 (T)80 (o)-372 (further)-371 (complicate)-371 (the)-370 (picture,)-371 (JNI,)-371 (the)-371 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)]TJ
T*
[(Nati)25 (v)15 (e)-390 (Interf)10 (ace,)-390 (grants)-390 (nati)25 (v)15 (e)-389 (code)-390 (access)-390 (to)-389 (synchronization)-390 (in)-390 (the)-390 (form)-390 (of)-389 (lock)-390 (and)-390 (unlock)]TJ
T*
[(operations,)-314 (so)-313 (e)26 (v)15 (en)-314 (if)-313 (all)-313 (bytecode)-314 (can)-314 (be)-313 (sho)25 (wn)-313 (to)-314 (be)-313 (structured,)-313 (a)-313 (f)10 (all-back)-314 (mechanism)-313 (w)10 (ould)]TJ
T*
[(still be needed for synchronization by nati)26 (v)15 (e)0 ( code.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(Finally)65 (,)-361 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.9633 0 TD
(wait)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.7608 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.8058 0 TD
(notify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6 0 TD
([)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.3325 0 TD
(All)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(])-361 (operations)-361 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-361 (no)-361 (direct)-361 (representation)-361 (at)-361 (the)-361 (bytecode)]TJ
-15.2625 -1.1667 TD
[(le)25 (v)15 (el,)-1103 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-1103 (instead)-1103 (are)-1103 (implemented)-1102 (as)-1103 (nati)24 (v)16 (e)-1103 (methods)-1102 (of)-1103 (the)-1103 (top-most)-1102 (class)]TJ
T*
(\()Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.3333 0 TD
(java.lang.Object)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.6 0 TD
(\).)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 7 7
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(4)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 709.33 Tm
[(3  Related w)10 (ork)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 686 Tm
[(There)-309 (is)-308 (a)-309 (lar)18 (ge)-308 (general)-309 (literature)-308 (on)-309 (synchronization)-307 (primiti)25 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-309 (and)-308 (their)-309 (implementation.)-308 (Dijk-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(stra)-278 ([9])-277 (and)-278 (Lamport)-277 ([16])-278 (present)-279 (subtle)-278 (algorithms)-278 (that)-278 (achie)25 (v)15 (e)-278 (mutual)-278 (e)15 (xclusion)-277 (assuming)-278 (only)]TJ
T*
[(that)-289 (indi)25 (vidual)-290 (reads)-289 (and)-288 (writes)-289 (are)-290 (atomic.)-289 (F)15 (ortunately)65 (,)-290 (modern)-289 (architectures)-289 (pro)16 (vide)-290 (composite)]TJ
T*
[(instructions)-287 (such)-287 (as)-286 (compare-and-sw)10 (ap)-287 (that)-287 (read)-286 (and)-287 (write)-287 (a)-287 (memory)-287 (location)-286 (in)-287 (a)-288 (single)-287 (atomic)]TJ
T*
[(step,)-241 (greatly)-241 (simplifying)-241 (the)-241 (mutual)-241 (e)15 (xclusion)-242 (problem)-241 (and)-241 (eliminating)-241 (the)-241 (need)-241 (for)-241 (such)-242 (subtlety)65 (.)]TJ
T*
[(W)80 (e)-276 (shall)-277 (refer)-277 (to)-276 (the)-276 (composite)-277 (atomic)-276 (instructions)-276 (simply)-277 (as)-276 (\322atomic)-276 (instructions.)70 (\323)-277 (W)81 (eakly)-277 (con-)]TJ
T*
[(sistent)-245 (memory)-243 (models,)-244 (which)-245 (allo)25 (w)-244 (dif)24 (ferent)-244 (processors)-245 (to)-244 (observ)15 (e)-244 (memory)-244 (operations)-244 (as)-244 (occur-)]TJ
T*
[(ring)-501 (in)-500 (dif)25 (ferent)-500 (orders,)-500 (may)-500 (require)-500 (the)-500 (use)-500 (of)-500 (memory)-500 (barrier)-500 (instructions)-500 (to)-500 (reintroduce)]TJ
T*
[(consistenc)15 (y)65 (,)0 ( whether using indi)25 (vidual reads and writes or atomic instructions.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(In)-247 (its)-247 (broad)-246 (structure,)-247 (our)-247 (meta-lock)-246 (resembles)-247 (the)-247 (MCS-lock)-246 (of)-247 (Mellor)20 (-Crumme)15 (y)-247 (and)-247 (Scott)-246 ([20].)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(The)-261 (MCS-lock)-261 (uses)-261 (an)-261 (atomic)-261 (sw)10 (ap)-261 (for)-261 (lock)-261 (acquisition)-261 (and)-261 (an)-261 (atomic)-261 (compare-and-sw)10 (ap)-261 (\()]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36.8667 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
(\))Tj
-38.6667 -1.1667 TD
[(for)-251 (lock)-250 (release)-251 (in)-250 (much)-250 (the)-250 (same)-250 (w)10 (a)0 (y)-250 (a)0 (s)-250 (does)-250 (our)-249 (meta-lock)-251 (algorithm.)-250 (The)-250 (MCS-lock)-250 (has)-250 (man)15 (y)]TJ
T*
[(of)-377 (the)-377 (same)-377 (properties)-377 (as)-377 (our)-377 (meta-lock,)-377 (including)-377 (starv)25 (ation)-377 (freedom)-377 (and)-378 (FIFO)-377 (access)-377 (to)-378 (the)]TJ
T*
[(lock.)-245 (Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-244 (the)-245 (details)-245 (are)-244 (quite)-245 (dif)25 (ferent)-245 (and,)-244 (in)-244 (particular)40 (,)-244 (contention)-244 (results)-244 (in)-245 (b)20 (usy-w)11 (aiting.)]TJ
T*
[(Also,)-285 (space-ef)25 (\336cienc)15 (y)-285 (i)0 (s)-285 (not)-284 (as)-285 (e)15 (xtreme)-285 (a)-285 (concern)-285 (in)-284 (the)-285 (conte)15 (xt)-285 (of)-284 (their)-285 (w)10 (ork.)-285 (Magnusson)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
36.965 0 TD
[(et)-285 (al.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
-36.965 -1.1667 TD
[([19])-324 (surv)15 (e)15 (y)-324 (locking)-323 (schemes)-323 (related)-324 (to)-324 (MCS-locks,)-324 (and)-324 (describe)-324 (tw)10 (o)-323 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-324 (locking)-324 (schemes)-323 (that)]TJ
T*
[(of)25 (fer dif)25 (ferent performance trade-of)26 (fs.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(Brinch)-249 (Hansen)-248 ([11])-248 (and)-248 (Hoare)-249 ([12])-249 (coined)-248 (the)-249 (term)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
20.8983 0 TD
(monitor)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.1267 0 TD
[(,)-249 (and)-248 (pro)16 (vided)-249 (the)-248 (nomenclature)-248 (used)]TJ
-24.025 -1.1667 TD
[(by)-226 (the)-226 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-226 (language.)-226 (There)-225 (are)-226 (se)26 (v)15 (eral)-226 (w)9 (ays,)-225 (ho)25 (we)24 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-226 (in)-226 (which)-226 (the)-226 (monitors)-225 (in)-226 (the)-225 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-226 (language)]TJ
T*
[(dif)25 (fer)-355 (from)-354 (the)-354 (original:)-354 (an)15 (y)-355 (object)-354 (may)-354 (be)-355 (used)-354 (as)-354 (a)-355 (monitor)41 (,)-354 (monitors)-355 (may)-354 (be)-355 (entered)-354 (recur-)]TJ
T*
[(si)25 (v)15 (ely)65 (,)-382 (and)-383 (monitors)-383 (pro)15 (vide)-382 (a)-384 (single)-383 (implicit,)-383 (rather)-382 (than)-383 (possibly)-382 (se)25 (v)15 (eral)-383 (e)15 (xplicit,)-383 (\322condition)]TJ
T*
[(v)25 (ariables.)70 (\323)-379 (Birrell)-380 (gi)26 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-379 (a)0 (n)-380 (e)16 (xcellent)-380 (tutorial)-379 (on)-380 (programming)-379 (with)-379 (\322standard\323)-379 (synchronization)]TJ
T*
[(primiti)25 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-235 ([5].)-236 (As)-236 (we)-236 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-236 (discussed,)-235 (the)-236 (synchronization)-235 (primiti)25 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-236 (o)0 (f)-235 (the)-236 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-236 (platform)-236 (are)-236 (dif)25 (\336-)]TJ
T*
[(cult)-262 (to)-262 (implement)-262 (in)-262 (a)-262 (manner)-262 (that)-262 (is)-261 (both)-262 (time-)-262 (and)-262 (space-ef)25 (\336cient.)-262 (Scalability)-262 (to)-262 (multiprocessor)]TJ
T*
[(systems)-444 (is)-444 (another)-444 (important)-443 (concern.)-444 (W)80 (e)-444 (shall)-444 (no)25 (w)-444 (discuss)-443 (some)-444 (pre)25 (vious)-444 (implementations)]TJ
T*
[(focusing on the approach the)15 (y tak)10 (e to trading of)25 (f these concerns.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-342 (original)-343 (JDK\252)-342 (implementation)-342 (of)-343 (the)-343 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-343 (virtual)-343 (machine)-342 ([18])-343 (pro)16 (vides)-343 (a)-343 (space-ef)25 (\336cient)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(monitor)-374 (implementation,)-373 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-374 (one)-374 (that)-374 (is)-375 (not)-374 (particularly)-374 (time-ef)25 (\336cient)-374 (or)-374 (scalable.)-374 (This)-374 (design)]TJ
T*
[(requires)-260 (that)-260 (each)-260 (object)-260 (has)-260 (a)-260 (unique)-260 (identi\336er)-260 (v)25 (alid)-260 (o)14 (v)16 (er)-260 (its)-260 (lifetime.)-260 (The)-260 (actual)-260 (implementation)]TJ
T*
[(uses)-336 (an)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
3.3392 0 TD
[(object)-337 (table)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
5.1175 0 TD
[(whose)-337 (entries)-336 (are)-336 (called)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
10.1758 0 TD
(handles)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.1108 0 TD
[(,)-337 (pro)15 (viding)-336 (an)-337 (e)15 (xtra)-337 (le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-336 (o)0 (f)-337 (indirection)-336 (to)]TJ
-21.7433 -1.1667 TD
[(f)10 (acilitate)-251 (object)-252 (compaction.)-251 (The)-251 (handle)-251 (address)-251 (of)-251 (an)-252 (object)-251 (remains)-251 (constant)-251 (during)-251 (the)-251 (object\325)55 (s)]TJ
T*
[(lifetime,)-335 (and)-336 (can)-336 (therefore)-336 (serv)15 (e)-336 (a)0 (s)-335 (a)-336 (unique)-335 (identi\336er)55 (.)-336 (A)-335 (global)-336 (table)-336 (called)-336 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
33.18 0 TD
[(monitor)-336 (cac)16 (he)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
-33.18 -1.1667 TD
[(maps)-341 (object)-341 (handle)-341 (addresses)-341 (to)-341 (monitor)-341 (structures)-341 (that)-342 (can)-341 (be)-341 (used)-341 (to)-341 (perform)-341 (the)-341 (actual)-341 (syn-)]TJ
T*
[(chronization)-242 (operations.)-242 (When)-243 (a)-242 (thread)-243 (synchronizes)-242 (on)-242 (an)-243 (object,)-243 (it)-242 (\336rst)-242 (ensures)-243 (that)-242 (the)-243 (monitor)]TJ
T*
[(cache)-309 (maps)-309 (the)-309 (object)-309 (to)-309 (a)-309 (monitor)41 (,)-309 (creating)-309 (and)-309 (installing)-308 (the)-309 (monitor)-309 (in)-309 (the)-309 (table)-309 (if)-309 (necessary)66 (.)]TJ
T*
[(This)-275 (approach)-275 (has)-274 (no)-275 (\336x)15 (ed)-275 (per)20 (-object)-275 (space)-275 (cost,)-275 (using)-275 (only)-274 (space)-276 (proportional)-274 (to)-275 (the)-275 (number)-275 (of)]TJ
T*
[(entries)-399 (in)-399 (the)-399 (monitor)-399 (cache.)-399 (Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-398 (it)-399 (is)-399 (f)10 (airly)-399 (time-inef)25 (\336cient,)-399 (since)-398 (each)-399 (synchronization)]TJ
T*
[(operation)-311 (must)-311 (\336rst)-311 (do)-311 (\(at)-312 (least\))-311 (a)-311 (table)-311 (lookup)-311 (to)-311 (locate)-310 (the)-311 (monitor)-311 (associated)-311 (with)-311 (the)-310 (object.)]TJ
T*
[(Further)40 (,)-287 (i)0 (t)-288 (i)0 (s)-288 (not)-288 (v)15 (ery)-288 (scalable.)-288 (The)-288 (monitor)-288 (cache)-288 (is)-288 (a)-288 (global)-288 (data)-287 (structure)-288 (that)-287 (is)-288 (accessed)-288 (con-)]TJ
T*
[(currently)65 (.)-260 (T)79 (o)-260 (mak)10 (e)-260 (this)-261 (concurrent)-260 (access)-260 (safe,)-261 (the)-260 (monitor)-260 (cache)-260 (is)-260 (protected)-260 (by)-260 (a)-260 (lock.)-260 (Thus,)-260 (all)]TJ
T*
[(synchronization)-367 (operations)-367 (obtain)-367 (a)-368 (single)-367 (lock,)-368 (an)-367 (ob)15 (vious)-367 (source)-367 (of)-368 (contention.)-367 (The)-367 (monitor)]TJ
T*
(cache locking also adds some cost in the uncontended case.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 8 8
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(5)Tj
-19.25 56.4858 TD
(Bacon)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
2.8117 0 TD
[(et)-255 (al.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
2.2625 0 TD
[([3])-256 (propose)-256 (a)-256 (cle)24 (v)15 (e)0 (r)-256 (scheme)-256 (moti)25 (v)25 (ated)-256 (by)-257 (man)15 (y)-257 (o)0 (f)-256 (the)-256 (same)-256 (concerns)-257 (as)-256 (ours.)-256 (In)-256 (this)]TJ
-5.0742 -1.1667 TD
[(design,)-274 (24)-274 (bits)-274 (of)-274 (each)-274 (object)-274 (header)-274 (are)-274 (de)25 (v)20 (oted)-274 (to)-274 (locking.)-273 (One)-275 (bit)-274 (indicates)-274 (whether)-274 (the)-274 (object)]TJ
T*
[(has)-295 (a)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
2.3683 0 TD
(thin)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8517 0 TD
(or)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
1.1283 0 TD
(fat)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.3517 0 TD
[(lock.)-295 (If)-295 (it)-296 (has)-295 (a)-296 (thin)-296 (lock,)-295 (then)-295 (all)-295 (necessary)-295 (locking)-296 (information)-295 (is)-295 (contained)-295 (in)]TJ
-6.7 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-276 (remaining)-276 (23)-277 (bits.)-277 (If)-276 (it)-276 (has)-277 (a)-277 (f)10 (at)-277 (lock,)-276 (then)-276 (the)-277 (remaining)-276 (23)-277 (bits)-277 (are)-276 (an)-276 (inde)15 (x)-277 (into)-276 (an)-277 (array)-276 (of)]TJ
T*
[(pointers)-257 (to)-257 (f)10 (a)0 (t)-257 (lock)-257 (structures)-258 (that,)-257 (much)-257 (lik)9 (e)-257 (monitors,)-257 (hold)-257 (the)-258 (necessary)-257 (data)-257 (for)-256 (the)-258 (synchroni-)]TJ
T*
[(zation)-305 (operations.)-305 (Thin)-305 (locks)-305 (are)-305 (used)-304 (as)-305 (long)-304 (as)-305 (the)-305 (lock)-305 (is)-305 (uncontended,)-305 (and)-305 (is)-305 (not)-304 (recursi)24 (v)15 (ely)]TJ
T*
[(lock)10 (ed)-294 (more)-294 (times)-294 (than)-295 (can)-294 (be)-294 (represented)-293 (in)-294 (a)-293 (count)-295 (\336eld)-294 (of)-294 (the)-294 (thin)-294 (lock;)-294 (if)-294 (either)-294 (condition)-294 (is)]TJ
T*
[(violated,)-340 (the)-340 (lock)-340 (representation)-340 (is)-340 (\322in\337ated.)70 (\323)-340 (This)-340 (design)-340 (does)-340 (well)-340 (at)-340 (optimizing)-341 (the)-340 (e)15 (xpected)]TJ
T*
[(common)-233 (case)-233 (of)-234 (uncontended)-233 (locking)-233 (and)-233 (unlocking.)-233 (Locking)-233 (requires)-233 (a)-234 (small)-233 (number)-233 (of)-234 (instruc-)]TJ
T*
[(tions,)-264 (with)-264 (only)-264 (one)-263 (atomic)-264 (instruction)-263 (in)-264 (the)-265 (f)10 (ast)-264 (path,)-264 (and)-263 (unlocking)-264 (requires)-264 (no)-263 (atomic)-264 (instruc-)]TJ
T*
[(tion. Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)0 ( thin locks lea)20 (v)15 (e)0 ( some issues to be addressed:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 72 552 Tm
( \245)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 85.75 552 Tm
(Contention.)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.9383 0 TD
[(When)-243 (there)-243 (is)-243 (contention)-244 (on)-243 (a)-243 (lock)-244 (for)-243 (the)-243 (\336rst)-244 (time,)-243 (all)-243 (threads)-244 (that)-243 (do)-243 (not)-243 (acquire)]TJ
-4.9383 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-240 (lock)-240 (must)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
5.6075 0 TD
[(b)20 (usy-wait)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.1083 0 TD
[(\(a.k.a.)-240 (spin\))-239 (until)-239 (the)-240 (lock)-239 (is)-240 (released.)-240 (Unbounded)-239 (b)20 (usy-w)10 (aiting)-239 (is)-240 (gen-)]TJ
-9.7158 -1.1667 TD
[(erally)-303 (undesirable)-303 (b)20 (ut,)-304 (as)-303 (the)-304 (authors)-303 (point)-303 (out,)-304 (b)20 (usy-w)10 (aiting)-303 (is)-304 (done)-303 (at)-304 (most)-302 (once)-304 (in)-303 (the)-304 (life-)]TJ
T*
[(time)-309 (of)-308 (a)-308 (g)0 (i)25 (v)15 (en)-308 (object.)-308 (Still,)-309 (it)-308 (w)10 (ould)-309 (not)-308 (be)-308 (hard)-308 (to)-309 (construct)-308 (a)-308 (program)-308 (that)-308 (does)-309 (contended)]TJ
T*
[(locking on man)15 (y short-li)26 (v)15 (ed objects, causing a great deal of b)21 (usy-w)10 (aiting.)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 72 476 Tm
( \245)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 85.75 476 Tm
[(Lac)21 (k)-395 (o)0 (f)-395 (de\337ation.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
7.6367 0 TD
(Lock)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
2.45 0 TD
(de\337ation)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8958 0 TD
[(is)-395 (not)-395 (discussed;)-395 (once)-395 (a)-395 (lock)-395 (becomes)-395 (f)10 (at,)-395 (it)-396 (remains)-395 (f)10 (at.)]TJ
-13.9825 -1.1667 TD
[(While)-245 (this)-246 (is)-245 (not)-245 (an)-245 (issue)-245 (for)-246 (most)-245 (programs,)-245 (one)-245 (could)-245 (imagine)-245 (a)-245 (long-li)25 (v)15 (e)0 (d)-245 (program)-245 (in)-245 (which)]TJ
T*
[(man)15 (y)-368 (long-li)25 (v)14 (e)0 (d)-368 (objects)-368 (are)-368 (lock)10 (ed)-368 (with)-368 (contention)-368 (at)-368 (some)-368 (point)-368 (in)-368 (their)-368 (lifetimes.)-367 (Absent)]TJ
T*
[(some)-381 (form)-380 (of)-380 (de\337ation,)-380 (such)-380 (a)-380 (program)-380 (w)10 (ould)-380 (consume)-381 (a)-380 (lar)18 (ge)-380 (amount)-381 (of)-380 (memory)-379 (for)-381 (f)10 (a)0 (t)]TJ
T*
(locks.)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 72 400 Tm
( \245)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 85.75 400 Tm
[(Space)-359 (consumption.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
8.4683 0 TD
[(Thin)-359 (locks)-360 (use)-359 (24)-360 (bits.)-359 (This)-359 (is)-360 (a)-359 (signi\336cant)-359 (o)15 (v)15 (erhead)-359 (since)-360 (the)-360 (a)20 (v)15 (erage)]TJ
-8.4683 -1.1667 TD
(object size for most programs is quite small [8].)Tj
-1.1458 -1.75 TD
[(In)-452 (other)-451 (related)-451 (w)9 (ork,)-451 (monitor)-452 (implementations)-451 (ha)21 (v)15 (e)-452 (been)-452 (proposed)-451 (that)-451 (e)15 (xploit)-452 (cooperati)25 (v)15 (e)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(thread)-247 (scheduling)-247 ([14])-247 (or)-246 (mak)10 (e)-247 (special)-247 (pro)16 (vision)-247 (for)-246 (f)10 (aster)-247 (e)16 (x)15 (ecution)-247 (of)-247 (single-threaded)-247 (programs)]TJ
T*
[([21,)-252 (24].)-252 (As)-251 (we)-252 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-252 (already)-252 (noted,)-251 (we)-252 (assume)-252 (preempti)25 (v)15 (e)-252 (scheduling,)-252 (and)-252 (desire)-252 (algorithms)-252 (that)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ork)-309 (well)-309 (for)-309 (both)-309 (single-)-308 (and)-309 (multi-threaded)-308 (programs,)-308 (so)-309 (we)-308 (shall)-308 (not)-309 (discuss)-308 (these)-309 (restricted)]TJ
T*
[(schemes further)55 (.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(In)-242 ([4],)-241 (Bak)-242 (describes)-242 (ho)25 (w)-241 (a)0 (n)-242 (early)-242 (v)15 (ersion)-243 (of)-241 (Sun\325)55 (s)-242 (HotSpot\252)-242 (JVM)-242 (locks)-241 (objects)-242 (by)-242 (replacing)-241 (an)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(object)-252 (header)-252 (w)10 (ord)-253 (with)-252 (a)-252 (pointer)-252 (to)-252 (an)-253 (e)16 (xternal)-252 (lock)-252 (structure,)-252 (displacing)-251 (the)-252 (original)-252 (contents)-252 (of)]TJ
T*
[(the)-270 (header)-269 (w)10 (ord)-269 (into)-270 (the)-269 (lock)-270 (structure.)-269 (T)80 (w)10 (o)-270 (l)0 (o)26 (w-order)-270 (bits)-269 (in)-269 (the)-269 (header)-270 (w)10 (ord)-269 (encode)-269 (its)-270 (format.)]TJ
T*
[(HotSpot)-361 (stack)-361 (allocates)-361 (lock)-360 (structures)-360 (for)-361 (ef)25 (\336cienc)15 (y)65 (.)-361 (Furthermore,)-361 (this)-361 (stack)-361 (allocation)-361 (allo)25 (ws)]TJ
T*
[(f)10 (ast)-388 (recursi)25 (v)15 (e)-389 (locking)-389 (by)-388 (enabling)-388 (ef)25 (\336cient)-389 (v)15 (eri\336cation)-388 (that)-388 (an)-388 (object)-388 (is)-389 (lock)10 (ed)-388 (by)-388 (the)-389 (current)]TJ
T*
[(thread:)-305 (if)-306 (the)-305 (lock)-305 (structure)-306 (address)-306 (is)-306 (suf)25 (\336ciently)-306 (close)-306 (to)-305 (the)-306 (current)-305 (stack)-306 (pointer)-306 (to)-306 (guarantee)]TJ
T*
[(membership)-276 (in)-276 (the)-276 (same)-277 (thread)-276 (stack,)-277 (the)-276 (current)-276 (thread)-276 (must)-276 (be)-277 (the)-276 (lock)-276 (o)25 (wner)56 (.)-277 (I)0 (n)-276 (non-preemp-)]TJ
T*
[(ti)25 (v)15 (e)-293 (thread)-293 (systems,)-292 (locking)-292 (and)-292 (unlocking)-292 (can)-292 (be)-293 (implemented)-292 (straightforw)10 (ardly)65 (.)-292 (I)0 (n)-292 (preempti)25 (v)15 (e)]TJ
T*
[(systems,)-344 (a)-343 (more)-343 (complicated)-343 (test-and-set)-344 (protocol)-343 (on)-343 (one)-343 (of)-344 (the)-344 (bits)-344 (in)-344 (the)-343 (header)-344 (w)10 (ord)-344 (grants)]TJ
T*
[(e)15 (xclusi)25 (v)15 (e)0 ( access to at most one thread; other threads b)21 (usy-w)10 (ait for their turn.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(W)80 (e)-246 (borro)25 (w)-246 (HotSpot\325)55 (s)-246 (idea)-246 (of)-246 (displacing)-246 (a)-246 (header)-247 (w)10 (ord)-246 (and)-246 (using)-246 (some)-246 (bits)-247 (of)-246 (the)-246 (w)10 (ord)-246 (to)-247 (encode)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(its)-237 (format)-236 (and)-236 (the)-236 (lock)-236 (state.)-236 (W)80 (e)-236 (use)-236 (a)-236 (dif)24 (ferent)-235 (allocation)-237 (scheme)-236 (to)-236 (support)-237 (non-block-structured)]TJ
T*
[(synchronization and emplo)11 (y a b)20 (usy-w)10 (ait-free protocol to protect the header w)11 (ord.)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 9 9
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(6)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 709.33 Tm
(4  Our algorithm)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 686 Tm
[(In)-250 (an)15 (y)-251 (concurrent)-250 (en)40 (vironment,)-250 (there)-250 (must)-251 (be)-251 (some)-251 (protocol)-250 (observ)15 (ed)-251 (by)-251 (threads)-250 (as)-250 (the)15 (y)-250 (manipu-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(late)-317 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
3.3 0 TD
[(sync)15 (hr)45 (onization)-317 (data)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
8.7408 0 TD
[(of)-317 (objects,)-317 (that)-317 (is,)-317 (the)-316 (data)-317 (structures)-317 (that)-317 (manage)-317 (synchronization)]TJ
-12.0408 -1.1667 TD
[(operations.)-302 (T)80 (ypically)65 (,)-302 (the)-302 (protocol)-303 (speci\336es)-302 (when)-302 (a)-303 (thread)-303 (may)-302 (access)-302 (or)-303 (manipulate)-302 (an)-303 (object\325)55 (s)]TJ
T*
[(synchronization)-272 (data.)-273 (F)15 (o)0 (r)-273 (e)15 (xample,)-272 (the)-273 (thin-locks)-272 (approach)-272 (relies)-273 (on)-272 (an)-273 (in)41 (v)25 (ariant)-273 (whereby)-273 (only)-273 (a)]TJ
T*
[(thread)-492 (o)25 (wning)-492 (the)-491 (lock)-491 (on)-492 (an)-492 (object)-492 (may)-491 (modify)-492 (that)-492 (object\325)55 (s)-492 (synchronization)-491 (data.)-492 (Other)]TJ
T*
[(approaches,)-308 (lik)9 (e)-308 (ours,)-309 (allo)25 (w)-309 (a)0 (n)15 (y)-309 (thread)-308 (to)-309 (update)-309 (this)-308 (information.)-309 (The)-309 (k)10 (e)15 (y)-309 (t)0 (o)-309 (our)-309 (approach)-309 (is)-309 (a)]TJ
T*
[(time-)-296 (and)-297 (space-ef)25 (\336cient)-297 (meta-lock)-297 (associated)-296 (with)-297 (the)-296 (synchronization)-297 (data)-297 (of)-296 (each)-297 (object.)-297 (The)]TJ
T*
(typical pattern for synchronization operations in our system is:)Tj
1.1458 -1.6667 TD
[(1.)-228 (Obtain)-229 (the)-229 (object\325)55 (s)-229 (meta-lock)-228 (to)-229 (ensure)-228 (e)15 (xclusi)25 (v)15 (e)-229 (access)-228 (to)-229 (the)-229 (object\325)55 (s)-228 (synchronization)-228 (data.)]TJ
0 -1.4167 TD
[(2. Manipulate the synchronization data of that object. This operation sh\
ould be f)11 (ast.)]TJ
T*
[(3. Release or hand of)25 (f the object\325)55 (s meta-lock.)]TJ
-1.1458 -1.75 TD
[(Meta-locks)-462 (play)-463 (a)-463 (similar)-463 (role)-463 (as)-463 (the)-463 (auxiliary)-462 (spin-locks)-463 (seen)-463 (in)-463 (man)15 (y)-462 (implementations)-463 (of)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(POSIX)-372 (threads)-373 ([6,)-372 (17].)-372 (These)-372 (spin-locks)-372 (pro)15 (vide)-372 (brief)-372 (e)15 (xclusi)26 (v)15 (e)-373 (access)-372 (to)-372 (the)-372 (synchronization)]TJ
T*
[(state maintained in records representing programmer)21 (-le)25 (v)15 (el mute)15 (x)15 (es and condition v)25 (ariables.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(W)80 (e)-300 (shall)-299 (use)-300 (the)-300 (term)-300 (\322monitor)20 (-lock\323)-300 (to)-300 (denote)-300 (the)-300 (lock)-300 (abstraction)-299 (e)15 (xported)-300 (by)-300 (the)-300 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-300 (virtual)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(machine)-358 (to)-358 (a)20 (v)20 (oid)-358 (confusion)-357 (with)-358 (the)-358 (meta-lock)-357 (used)-358 (in)-358 (its)-357 (implementation.)-357 (Because)-358 (meta-lock)]TJ
T*
[(acquisition)-353 (occurs)-354 (in)-354 (FIFO)-354 (order)40 (,)-353 (the)-354 (abo)15 (v)15 (e)-354 (pattern)-354 (allo)25 (ws)-354 (a)-354 (number)-354 (of)-353 (f)10 (airness)-354 (policies)-354 (at)-354 (the)]TJ
T*
[(monitor)-306 (le)25 (v)15 (el.)-306 (The)-307 (rest)-307 (of)-306 (this)-307 (section)-307 (describes)-306 (our)-306 (algorithm)-307 (in)-307 (detail:)-306 (Section)-307 (4.1)-307 (presents)-307 (the)]TJ
T*
[(data)-298 (structures)-298 (in)40 (v)20 (olv)15 (ed,)-298 (Section)-298 (4.2)-298 (the)-298 (meta-lock)-298 (algorithm,)-297 (Section)-298 (4.3)-298 (the)-298 (implementation)-297 (of)]TJ
T*
[(the)-377 (monitor)20 (-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-377 (lock)-377 (and)-378 (unlock)-378 (operations,)-377 (and)-377 (Section)-377 (4.4)-377 (the)-378 (implementation)-377 (of)-378 (w)10 (ait)-377 (and)]TJ
T*
[(notify)65 (.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 347.67 Tm
[(4.1  Data structur)18 (es)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 323 Tm
[(Synchronization)-307 (in)40 (v)20 (olv)16 (es)-308 (three)-308 (entities:)-307 (threads,)-308 (objects,)-308 (and)-308 (lock)-307 (records.)-308 (W)80 (e)-308 (describe)-307 (the)-308 (rele-)]TJ
T*
[(v)25 (ant)-310 (parts)-311 (of)-310 (the)-310 (data)-311 (structures)-311 (that)-310 (implement)-311 (them)-311 (and)-310 (ho)25 (w)-311 (the)15 (y)-310 (interact)-311 (during)-311 (synchroniza-)]TJ
T*
(tion.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Thr)37 (eads)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
3.2408 0 TD
[(.)-246 (W)80 (e)-246 (call)-246 (the)-245 (data)-246 (structure)-246 (that)-246 (holds)-245 (thread-speci\336c)-246 (state)-245 (an)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
24.425 0 TD
[(e)20 (xecution)-246 (en)40 (vir)45 (onment)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
9.2183 0 TD
(\()Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.3325 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
(\).)Tj
-38.4167 -1.1667 TD
(Since)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.4683 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(s)-246 (and)-246 (threads)-246 (correspond)-246 (one)-246 (to)-246 (one,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.8025 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4467 0 TD
[(addresses)-245 (are)-246 (well-suited)-246 (as)-246 (unique)-246 (thread)-246 (iden-)]TJ
-19.9175 -1.1667 TD
[(ti\336ers.)-249 (Figure)-250 (1)-250 (sho)25 (ws)-250 (the)-250 (\336elds)-250 (in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.0292 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(s)-249 (that)-250 (the)-250 (synchronization)-249 (code)-249 (uses)-250 (as)-249 (well)-250 (as)-249 (an)-249 (initializa-)]TJ
-15.2292 -1.1667 TD
[(tion)-281 (function)-282 (that)-282 (sets)-282 (the)-282 (\336elds)-281 (to)-282 (their)-282 (steady-state)-281 (v)25 (alues.)-282 (The)-282 (mute)15 (x)16 (e)0 (s)-282 (and)-282 (condition)-282 (v)25 (ariables)]TJ
T*
[(in)-225 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.4508 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(s)-225 (are)-225 (used)-225 (to)-225 (a)20 (v)20 (oid)-225 (b)20 (usy-w)10 (aiting)-225 (when)-225 (contention)-225 (requires)-225 (threads)-225 (to)-224 (w)9 (ait)-225 (for)-226 (their)-225 (turn)-225 (to)]TJ
-3.6508 -1.1667 TD
[(lock)-227 (an)-227 (object,)-228 (while)-227 (other)-227 (\336elds)-227 (serv)15 (e)-228 (t)0 (o)-227 (e)15 (xchange)-227 (information)-227 (between)-227 (threads)-227 (synchronizing)-227 (on)]TJ
T*
(the same object.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
(Objects)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.055 0 TD
[(.)-265 (Figure)-250 (2)-265 (sho)25 (ws)-265 (the)-265 (object)-265 (layout)-265 (in)-264 (EVM.)-265 (Because)-264 (e)25 (v)15 (ery)-265 (object)-265 (may)-265 (potentially)-265 (be)-264 (used)]TJ
-3.055 -1.1667 TD
[(for)-350 (synchronization,)-349 (it)-350 (is)-350 (critical)-350 (to)-350 (minimize)-349 (the)-350 (per)20 (-object)-350 (space)-350 (o)15 (v)15 (erhead.)-349 (Objects)-350 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-349 (tw)10 (o-)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ord)-313 (headers.)-312 (The)-312 (\336rst)-312 (w)9 (ord)-312 (points)-312 (to)-313 (the)-312 (object\325)55 (s)-312 (class.)-313 (Only)-312 (the)-313 (second)-312 (w)9 (ord)-312 (is)-313 (used)-312 (for)-313 (syn-)]TJ
T*
[(chronization,)-284 (b)21 (u)0 (t)-284 (i)0 (t)-284 (serv)15 (es)-284 (other)-284 (purposes)-284 (as)-284 (well,)-284 (such)-284 (as)-284 (holding)-284 (a)-284 (hash)-284 (code)]TJ
9.6 0 0 9.6 450.48 131.8 Tm
(2)Tj
12 0 0 12 458.69 127 Tm
[(and)-283 (garbage-col-)]TJ
ET
0 G
2 J
0 j
0.36 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
204 86 m
72 86 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 72 71.33 Tm
[(2.  EVM uses a handle-less cop)9 (ying memory system, so object or handle addresses cannot be used as hash\
 codes.)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 10 10
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(7)Tj
-19.25 32.1942 TD
[(lector)-284 (age)-284 (information,)-283 (so)-284 (we)-283 (call)-283 (it)-284 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
16.1825 0 TD
(multi-use)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.0058 0 TD
[(w)10 (ord.)-284 (W)80 (e)-283 (emplo)10 (y)-284 (a)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
8.1717 0 TD
[(header)-283 (wor)37 (d)-284 (displacement)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
-28.36 -1.1667 TD
[(technique)-299 (in)41 (v)15 (ented)-299 (by)-299 (our)-299 (colleague)-299 (Lars)-299 (Bak)-299 ([4].)-299 (The)-299 (tw)10 (o)-299 (least)-299 (signi\336cant)-299 (bits)-299 (in)-299 (the)-299 (multi-use)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ord,)-389 (called)-389 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
7.0708 0 TD
[(loc)20 (k)-389 (bits)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
3.48 0 TD
[(,)-389 (hold)-389 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
4.4167 0 TD
[(loc)20 (k)-389 (state)10 (,)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.5525 0 TD
[(which)-388 (serv)15 (e)-389 (a)0 (s)-389 (a)-389 (format)-389 (indicator)-388 (and)-388 (simulta-)]TJ
-19.52 -1.1667 TD
[(neously)-255 (encode)-254 (meta-lock)-254 (information)-254 (for)-255 (the)-255 (object.)-254 (Figure)-250 (3)-254 (sho)25 (ws)-255 (the)-254 (four)-255 (possible)-254 (lock)-255 (states)]TJ
T*
[(and)-244 (their)-244 (formats.)-245 (Objects)-245 (are)-244 (created)-245 (in)-244 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
17.7017 0 TD
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.445 0 TD
[(state)-244 (\(in)-245 (f)11 (act,)-245 (the)-245 (majority)-244 (of)-245 (objects)-244 (ne)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)]TJ
-22.1467 -1.1667 TD
[(lea)20 (v)15 (e)-365 (this)-365 (state\),)-366 (remain)-365 (in)-365 (this)-365 (state)-365 (as)-364 (long)-365 (as)-365 (no)-365 (thread)-365 (synchronizes)-365 (on)-366 (them,)-365 (and)-365 (return)-364 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
T*
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.5758 0 TD
[(once)-376 (synchronization)-376 (ceases.)-376 (A)-376 (monitor)21 (-lock)10 (ed)-376 (object)-377 (is)-375 (in)-376 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
26.4342 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.9758 0 TD
[(state.)-376 (The)]TJ
-34.9858 -1.1667 TD
[(high)-404 (30)-404 (bits)-404 (of)-404 (the)-405 (multi-use)-404 (w)10 (ord)-404 (hold)-404 (a)-404 (pointer)-404 (to)-404 (synchronization)-404 (data)-405 (\(a)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
32.4258 0 TD
[(loc)20 (k)-404 (r)37 (ecor)37 (d)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.6425 0 TD
[(,)-404 (see)]TJ
-37.0683 -1.1667 TD
[(belo)25 (w\))-292 (that)-291 (indicates)-291 (which)-292 (thread)-291 (o)25 (wns)-291 (the)-291 (monitor)20 (-lock)-291 (and)-291 (also)-291 (stores)-291 (the)-290 (displaced)-291 (hash)-291 (and)]TJ
T*
[(age)-348 (information.)-348 (The)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.9583 0 TD
(WAITERS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.5483 0 TD
[(state)-348 (is)-347 (entered)-349 (when)-347 (a)-348 (thread)-348 (releases)-348 (the)-348 (monitor)21 (-lock)-348 (while)]TJ
-13.5067 -1.1667 TD
[(other)-348 (threads)-349 (are)-348 (w)10 (aiting)-348 (to)-349 (acquire)-349 (the)-348 (lock)-349 (or)-349 (to)-349 (be)-348 (noti\336ed:)-347 (the)-349 (object)-348 (is)-349 (no)-348 (longer)-348 (monitor)21 (-)]TJ
T*
[(lock)10 (ed,)-320 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-319 (the)-319 (state)-319 (must)-320 (be)-319 (distinguished)-319 (from)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.9417 0 TD
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.52 0 TD
[(because)-319 (the)-320 (remainder)-319 (of)-319 (the)-320 (multi-)]TJ
-24.4617 -1.1667 TD
[(use)-299 (w)10 (ord)-299 (still)-300 (points)-299 (to)-299 (synchronization)-299 (data.)-300 (The)-299 (fourth)-299 (and)-299 (\336nal)-299 (state,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
29.3033 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.2708 0 TD
[(,)-300 (indicates)-299 (that)-300 (the)]TJ
-31.5742 -1.1667 TD
[(object)-365 (is)-366 (meta-lock)11 (ed.)-366 (In)-365 (this)-366 (case,)-365 (the)-365 (high)-366 (part)-365 (of)-366 (the)-365 (multi-use)-366 (w)10 (ord)-365 (contains)-366 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
35.0142 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.565 0 TD
[(of)-366 (the)]TJ
-36.5792 -1.1667 TD
[(thread)-253 (that)-252 (has)-254 (the)-253 (meta-lock)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
11.8192 0 TD
(or)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.1417 0 TD
(the)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.475 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4533 0 TD
[(of)-254 (a)-253 (thread)-253 (attempting)-253 (to)-254 (acquire)-253 (the)-253 (meta-lock,)-253 (as)-253 (will)-253 (be)]TJ
-15.8892 -1.1667 TD
[(e)15 (xplained)-227 (in)-227 (Section)-227 (4.2.)-227 (A)-227 (minimum)-227 (of)-228 (tw)10 (o)-228 (lock)-227 (bits)-227 (are)-227 (required)-227 (since)-227 (we)-227 (must)-227 (distinguish)-227 (three)]TJ
T*
[(states:)-329 (is)-329 (the)-329 (object)-329 (meta-lock)10 (ed)-328 (or)-329 (not,)-329 (and,)-329 (if)-329 (not,)-329 (whether)-329 (the)-329 (remaining)-329 (bits)-329 (of)-329 (the)-329 (multi-use)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ord)-247 (contain)-246 (their)-246 (original)-246 (contents)-246 (or)-246 (a)-246 (pointer)-246 (to)-246 (a)-247 (data)-246 (structure)-247 (into)-246 (which)-247 (those)-246 (contents)-246 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)]TJ
T*
[(been)-304 (displaced.)-304 (Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-304 (while)-304 (the)-305 (minimum)-304 (is)-305 (three)-303 (states,)-305 (ef)25 (\336cienc)15 (y)-304 (f)10 (a)20 (v)20 (ors)-304 (use)-304 (of)-304 (all)-303 (four)-305 (bit)]TJ
T*
[(patterns,)-347 (allo)25 (wing)-347 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.1558 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.9475 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.7917 0 TD
(WAITERS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.5475 0 TD
[(states)-347 (to)-348 (be)-348 (distinguished)-347 (in)-347 (the)-348 (lock)-348 (bits)-347 (rather)]TJ
-19.4425 -1.1667 TD
(than by a bit in the synchronization data.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Loc)20 (k)-382 (r)36 (ecor)37 (ds.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
5.9192 0 TD
[(Most)-381 (synchronization)-382 (data)-382 (is)-382 (k)10 (ept)-382 (not)-382 (in)-382 (objects)-382 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-382 (i)0 (n)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
23.2342 0 TD
(LockRecord)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6 0 TD
[(s.)-382 (A)-382 (lock)]TJ
-35.1533 -1.1667 TD
[(record)-411 (represents)-411 (a)-411 (thread)-411 (for)-411 (the)-411 (purpose)-410 (of)-411 (synchronization)-411 (on)-411 (a)-411 (particular)-411 (object.)-411 (Figure)-250 (4)]TJ
T*
[(sho)25 (ws)-258 (the)-259 (\336elds)-258 (of)-259 (a)-258 (lock)-258 (record:)-258 (the)-259 (o)25 (wner)-258 (thread,)-258 (the)-258 (number)-258 (of)-259 (times)-258 (the)-259 (thread)-258 (has)-258 (lock)10 (ed)-258 (the)]TJ
T*
[(object)-247 (\(recall)-247 (that)-247 (monitor)21 (-locks)-247 (are)-247 (recursi)25 (v)15 (e\),)-247 (a)-247 (\336eld)-247 (for)-247 (the)-247 (displaced)-246 (hash)-247 (and)-248 (age)-247 (information,)]TJ
4.2008 33.375 TD
[(Figure 1. Per)21 (-thread \(e)15 (x)15 (ecution en)40 (vironment\) \336elds used for synchronization)]TJ
9.66 -1 TD
[(and their steady-state v)25 (alues)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8 0 0 8 126 710.17 Tm
(typedef struct execenv {)Tj
2.4 -1.25 TD
[(Thread)-4200 (thread;)-9600 (/* ExecEnv is a subtype of Thread.     */)]TJ
T*
[(mutex_t)-3600 (metaLockMutex;)-5400 (/* Used by slow-path meta-lock/unlock. */)]TJ
T*
[(condvar_t)-2400 (metaLockCondvar;)-4200 (/* To wait for meta-lock hand-off.)-3000 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(bool_t)-4200 (gotMetaLockSlow;)-4200 (/* Wait for predecessor to give bits.)-1200 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(bool_t)-4200 (bitsForGrab;)-6600 (/* Wait for successor to grab bits.)-2400 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(BitField)-3000 (metaLockBits;)-6000 (/* Space to get/give releaseBits.)-3600 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(ExecEnv)-3000 (*succEE;)-9600 (/* Next thread to get the meta-lock.)-1800 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(mutex_t)-3600 (monitorLockMutex;)-3600 (/* Used by slow-path lock/unlock.)-3000 ( */)]TJ
T*
[(condvar_t)-2400 (monitorLockCondvar;)-2400 (/* To wait for monitor acquisition.)-2400 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(bool_t)-4200 (isWaitingForNotify;)-2400 (/* Am waiting for notification.)-4800 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(...)-600 (other fields ...)]TJ
-2.4 -1.25 TD
(} ExecEnv;)Tj
0 -2.5 TD
(void initializeEE\(ExecEnv *ee\) {)Tj
2.4 -1.25 TD
[(ee->gotMetaLockSlow)-2400 (= FALSE;)]TJ
-2.4 -1.25 TD
[(    ee->bitsForGrab)-4800 (= FALSE;)]TJ
2.4 -1.25 TD
(ee->isWaitingForNotify = FALSE;)Tj
T*
[(ee->succEE)-7800 (= NULL;)]TJ
T*
(... initialize other fields ...)Tj
-2.4 -1.25 TD
(})Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 11 11
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(8)Tj
-19.25 27.2358 TD
[(a)-291 (queue)-291 (\336eld)-291 (for)-291 (linking)-291 (the)-291 (lock)-291 (records)-291 (of)-291 (all)-292 (threads)-291 (that)-291 (synchronize)-291 (on)-291 (a)-292 (g)0 (i)26 (v)15 (en)-292 (object,)-291 (and)-291 (a)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(free-list)-346 (\336eld)-347 (for)-346 (linking)-347 (lock)-347 (records)-347 (when)-346 (the)15 (y)-348 (are)-346 (not)-347 (in)-346 (use)-347 (\(see)-347 (Section)-347 (6.1\).)-346 (Figure)-251 (4)-347 (also)]TJ
T*
[(sho)25 (ws)-289 (an)-289 (object)-289 (with)-289 (three)-289 (lock)-290 (records)-289 (on)-289 (its)-289 (lock)-289 (queue.)-289 (In)-289 (this)-290 (e)16 (xample,)-289 (the)-290 (state)-289 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
35.15 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6 0 TD
(,)Tj
-38.75 -1.1667 TD
[(so)-255 (one)-255 (of)-254 (the)-255 (lock)-255 (records)-255 (belongs)-255 (to)-254 (a)-255 (thread)-255 (that)-255 (holds)-255 (the)-255 (monitor)21 (-lock.)-255 (In)-255 (our)-254 (implementation,)]TJ
T*
[(ne)25 (w)-253 (lock)-254 (records)-254 (are)-253 (appended)-254 (to)-254 (the)-253 (end)-253 (of)-254 (the)-254 (queue)-253 (\(FIFO)-254 (order\))-253 (and)-253 (stay)-254 (in)-254 (order)40 (,)-253 (e)15 (xcept)-253 (that)]TJ
T*
[(when)-261 (a)-261 (thread)-261 (acquires)-260 (the)-260 (monitor)20 (-lock,)-261 (it)-261 (mo)16 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-261 (its)-261 (lock)-260 (record)-261 (to)-260 (the)-261 (front)-260 (so)-261 (that)-261 (the)-260 (\336rst)-261 (lock)]TJ
T*
[(record of a lock)10 (ed object al)10 (w)10 (ays belongs to the thread that holds the monitor)21 (-lock.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(An)-360 (object\325)55 (s)-359 (meta-lock)-359 (protects)-359 (its)-359 (synchronization)-359 (data,)-360 (which)-359 (we)-359 (can)-359 (no)25 (w)-359 (de\336ne)-359 (precisely)-359 (as)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(comprising)-262 (the)-262 (multi-use)-262 (w)10 (ord,)-262 (including)-262 (the)-262 (lock)-262 (queue)-262 (pointer)-263 (\(when)-262 (there)-262 (is)-262 (one\))-262 (and)-263 (the)-262 (lock)]TJ
T*
[(records)-230 (in)-231 (that)-231 (queue.)-230 (F)14 (o)0 (r)-230 (e)15 (xample,)-231 (if)-231 (a)-230 (thread)-231 (w)9 (ants)-231 (to)-230 (place)-231 (a)-231 (lock)-230 (record)-231 (in)-230 (the)-231 (queue)-230 (to)-231 (w)10 (ait)-231 (for)]TJ
T*
[(its)-252 (turn)-252 (to)-251 (acquire)-252 (the)-252 (monitor)21 (-lock,)-252 (it)-251 (meta-locks)-252 (the)-252 (object)-252 (to)-252 (gain)-251 (e)15 (xclusi)25 (v)15 (e)-252 (access)-252 (to)-252 (the)-251 (queue,)]TJ
T*
[(appends)-263 (its)-263 (lock)-263 (record,)-263 (and)-263 (then)-263 (releases)-263 (the)-263 (meta-lock.)-263 (Similarly)65 (,)-263 (t)0 (o)-263 (read)-263 (or)-264 (write)-263 (the)-263 (hash)-263 (code)]TJ
T*
[(of)-354 (an)-354 (object,)-353 (meta-locking)-354 (must)-354 (be)-353 (done)-354 (\(though)-353 (it)-354 (is)-354 (possible)-354 (to)-354 (optimize)-354 (reads)-353 (of)-354 (immutable)]TJ
T*
[(\336elds, lik)10 (e the hash code, most of the time\).)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 139.67 Tm
[(4.2  Meta-locking: exclusi)10 (v)10 (e)0 ( access to synchr)18 (onization data)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 115 Tm
[(Figure)-250 (5)-293 (sho)26 (ws)-293 (the)-293 (non-contention)-292 (\(f)10 (ast-path\))-293 (code)-293 (for)-292 (obtaining)-293 (and)-293 (releasing)-293 (an)-293 (object\325)55 (s)-293 (meta-)]TJ
T*
[(lock.)-322 (A)-323 (thread)-323 (attempts)-322 (to)-323 (gain)-322 (the)-323 (meta-lock)-322 (by)-322 (using)-322 (an)-323 (atomic)-322 (sw)10 (ap)-323 (operation)-322 (to)-323 (replace)-323 (the)]TJ
T*
[(object\325)55 (s)-238 (multi-use)-237 (w)10 (ord)-237 (with)-237 (a)-238 (w)10 (ord)-238 (consisting)-237 (of)-237 (a)-238 (reference)-237 (to)-238 (the)-237 (thread\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
30.5042 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4375 0 TD
[(and)-237 (the)-237 (lo)25 (w-order)]TJ
-31.9417 -1.1667 TD
[(bits)-257 (representing)-258 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.3833 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6575 0 TD
[(state.)-258 (If)-258 (the)-257 (w)9 (ord)-258 (returned)-257 (by)-258 (the)-257 (sw)9 (ap)-258 (operation)-257 (has)-258 (lo)25 (w-order)-257 (bits)-257 (in)]TJ
ET
0 G
2 J
0 j
0.6 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
295.26 712.67 72 -90 re
367.26 694.67 m
295.26 694.67 l
367.26 676.67 m
295.26 676.67 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 300.26 701.17 Tm
(class ptr)Tj
0 -1.8 TD
[(multi-use w)10 (ord)]TJ
0 -3.6 TD
[(user)20 (-de\336ned)]TJ
0 -1 TD
(\336elds)Tj
ET
394.26 694.67 m
376.26 703.67 l
394.26 694.67 m
376.26 685.67 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 396.51 692.09 Tm
[(header w)10 (ords)]TJ
-23.625 -0.325 TD
(all synchronization)Tj
0 -1 TD
(is done on this \336eld)Tj
ET
0 J
1.08 w
275.23 683.03 m
284.45 685.67 l
275.23 688.31 l
275.23 685.67 l
s 
275.23 683.03 m
284.45 685.67 l
275.23 688.31 l
275.23 685.67 l
f* 
2 J
0.6 w
274.73 685.67 m
241.26 685.67 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 295.26 613.67 Tm
(object)Tj
12 0 0 12 229.34 591.17 Tm
(Figure 2. Object layout in EVM)Tj
ET
1 g
1.08 w
81 526.67 219 -18.5 re
B* 
207.5 508.67 m
207.5 526.67 l
252.5 508.67 m
252.5 526.67 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 123.07 514.34 Tm
0 g
(hash code)Tj
9.793 0.083 TD
[(age)-2112 (Lock \(00\))]TJ
-9.15 -1.8 TD
(25 bits)Tj
9.05 0.05 TD
[(5 bits)-2155 (2 bits)]TJ
ET
1 g
312.86 464.17 215.71 -18.5 re
B* 
481.78 446.17 m
481.78 464.17 l
S 
BT
9.85 0 0 10 342.41 452.67 Tm
0 g
[(Ex)16 (ecution en)39 (vironment \(EE\))-3057 (Lock \(11\))]TJ
4.1492 -1.85 TD
(30 bits)Tj
11.1005 0.1 TD
(2 bits)Tj
ET
1 g
312 527.17 219 -18.5 re
B* 
483.5 509.17 m
483.5 527.17 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 342 515.67 Tm
0 g
[(LockRecord \(LR\))-7363 (Lock \(10\))]TJ
4.15 -1.85 TD
(30 bits)Tj
11.1 0.1 TD
(2 bits)Tj
ET
1 g
81 464.17 219 -18.5 re
B* 
252.5 446.17 m
252.5 464.17 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 111 452.67 Tm
0 g
[(LockRecord \(LR\))-7363 (Lock \(01\))]TJ
4.15 -1.85 TD
(30 bits)Tj
11.1 0.1 TD
(2 bits)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-18.25 3.44 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 172.73 406 Tm
[(Figure 3.  Possible states for an object\325)56 (s multi-use w)10 (ord)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 315 469.57 Tm
(BUSY)Tj
-23.4 6.3 TD
[(NEUTRAL)-19200 (WAITERS)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 12 12
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 303 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
0 Tw
(9)Tj
-19.25 31.0417 TD
[(an)15 (y)-314 (state)-315 (other)-314 (than)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.2975 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.2708 0 TD
[(,)-315 (the)-315 (thread)-314 (has)-315 (acquired)-314 (the)-315 (meta-lock)-314 (and)-315 (may)-315 (proceed.)-314 (Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-315 (if)]TJ
-10.5683 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-305 (returned)-305 (w)10 (ord\325)55 (s)-305 (l)0 (o)25 (w-order)-305 (bits)-305 (indicate)-305 (the)-305 (object)-305 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
22.8733 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.2708 0 TD
[(,)-305 (then)-305 (some)-305 (other)-305 (thread)-305 (holds)-305 (the)]TJ
-25.1442 -1.1667 TD
[(meta-lock,)-307 (so)-307 (the)-307 (current)-306 (thread)-307 (in)40 (v)20 (o)0 (k)10 (e)0 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.5733 0 TD
(getMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
[(.)-307 (I)0 (n)-307 (this)-307 (case,)-306 (the)-307 (threads)-307 (con-)]TJ
-26.7733 -1.1667 TD
[(tending)-237 (for)-236 (the)-236 (meta-lock)-236 (are)-236 (totally)-236 (ordered)-236 (by)-237 (the)-236 (order)-237 (in)-236 (which)-236 (the)-237 (sw)10 (ap)-236 (instructions)-236 (occurred.)]TJ
T*
[(The)-232 (\336rst)-231 (thread)-232 (in)-231 (this)-232 (order)-231 (kno)25 (ws,)-231 (since)-232 (it)-231 (acquired)-231 (the)-231 (meta-lock,)-231 (that)-232 (it)-231 (has)-231 (no)-232 (predecessor)40 (,)-231 (and)]TJ
T*
[(e)25 (v)15 (ery other thread kno)26 (ws its predecessor from the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
20.1517 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[( in the w)10 (ord read by the sw)11 (ap.)]TJ
-21.3517 -1.75 TD
[(A)-328 (thread)-328 (acquires)-328 (the)-328 (meta-lock)-327 (to)-329 (perform)-327 (some)-328 (operation)-328 (on)-327 (the)-328 (synchronization)-327 (data.)-328 (At)-328 (the)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(end)-248 (of)-248 (this)-247 (operation,)-248 (it)-247 (releases)-247 (the)-248 (meta-lock)-247 (and)-248 (sets)-247 (the)-248 (multi-use)-247 (w)9 (ord)-248 (of)-247 (the)-248 (object)-248 (to)-248 (a)-248 (v)25 (alue)]TJ
T*
[(appropriate)-315 (to)-314 (the)-315 (ne)25 (w)-315 (state)-315 (of)-314 (the)-315 (synchronization)-314 (data.)-315 (This)-315 (ne)25 (w)-315 (v)25 (alue)-315 (may)-315 (be)-314 (an)15 (y)-315 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36.6 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-36.6 -1.1667 TD
[(v)25 (alue;)-295 (the)-295 (operation)-295 (might)-295 (release)-296 (the)-295 (lock)-295 (and)-295 (restore)-296 (the)-295 (displaced)-295 (multi-use)-295 (w)10 (ord)-295 (bits)-295 (and)-296 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
T*
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.555 0 TD
[(lock)-355 (state,)-354 (or)-354 (it)-355 (might)-355 (change)-355 (the)-355 (queue)-354 (pointer)-354 (to)-355 (point)-354 (to)-355 (a)-354 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-355 (lock)-355 (record,)-355 (or)-354 (it)]TJ
-4.555 -1.1667 TD
[(might)-334 (lea)20 (v)15 (e)-334 (the)-335 (multi-use)-334 (w)10 (ord)-334 (unchanged.)-334 (In)-334 (an)15 (y)-334 (case,)-335 (call)-334 (this)-334 (ne)25 (w)-334 (multi-use)-334 (w)10 (ord)-334 (v)25 (alue)-335 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
T*
[(r)37 (elease)-293 (bits)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.8833 0 TD
[(of)-294 (the)-293 (operation.)-294 (T)80 (o)-293 (accomplish)-294 (the)-293 (meta-lock)-293 (release,)-294 (a)-293 (thread)-293 (uses)-293 (an)-293 (atomic)-294 (com-)]TJ
-4.8833 -1.1667 TD
[(pare-and-sw)11 (ap)-287 (\()]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.4958 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(\))-286 (operation)-287 (to)-286 (atomically)-287 (compare)-286 (the)-287 (current)-286 (contents)-287 (of)-286 (the)-287 (object\325)55 (s)-287 (multi-)]TJ
-8.2958 -1.1667 TD
[(use)-254 (w)10 (ord)-254 (with)-254 (what)-253 (it)-254 (had)-253 (written)-254 (there)-253 (\(i.e.,)-254 (its)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.22 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4542 0 TD
[(and)-253 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.1733 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6542 0 TD
[(state\))-253 (and,)-254 (if)-253 (it)-254 (is)-254 (still)-254 (the)-254 (same,)]TJ
-26.5017 -1.1667 TD
[(write)-286 (the)-285 (release)-286 (bits.)-286 (If)-286 (the)-286 (comparison)-285 (f)11 (ails,)-286 (then)-285 (some)-286 (other)-286 (thread)-286 (has)-286 (attempted)-285 (to)-286 (obtain)-286 (the)]TJ
T*
[(meta-lock)-347 (and)-348 (is)-346 (no)25 (w)-347 (w)9 (aiting)-347 (for)-346 (its)-347 (turn.)-347 (In)-347 (this)-347 (case,)-347 (the)-347 (releasing)-346 (thread)-347 (will)-347 (\322hand)-347 (of)25 (f\323)-347 (the)]TJ
T*
[(meta-lock)-287 (to)-288 (the)-287 (ne)15 (xt)-288 (thread)-288 (in)-287 (the)-288 (order)-287 (induced)-287 (by)-287 (the)-288 (sw)10 (ap)-288 (operations,)-287 (by)-288 (calling)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
34.2 0 TD
(release-)Tj
-34.2 -1.1667 TD
(MetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.4 0 TD
[(.)-290 (The)-289 (aim)-290 (is)-290 (to)-290 (reach)-289 (the)-290 (state)-289 (that)-290 (w)10 (ould)-290 (ha)21 (v)15 (e)-290 (been)-289 (reached)-290 (if)-290 (the)-290 (releasing)]TJ
-8.4 -1.1667 TD
[(thread)-281 (had)-282 (completed)-281 (its)-282 (meta-lock)-281 (release,)-281 (writing)-282 (out)-281 (its)-282 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
25.5567 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6817 0 TD
[(release)-281 (bits,)-282 (before)-281 (its)-282 (suc-)]TJ
-28.2383 -1.1667 TD
[(cessor)-429 (performed)-430 (its)-430 (atomic)-430 (sw)10 (ap)-430 (operation,)-429 (causing)-430 (that)-429 (operation)-429 (to)-430 (read)-430 (the)-430 (predecessor\325)56 (s)]TJ
T*
(release bits.)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-242 (main)-242 (complication)-241 (in)-241 (the)-241 (slo)25 (w-path)-241 (meta-lock)-241 (hand-of)25 (f)-242 (i)0 (s)-241 (that)-242 (each)-241 (thread)-241 (in)-242 (the)-241 (atomic)-241 (sw)10 (ap)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(total)-304 (order)-304 (kno)25 (ws)-304 (the)-305 (identity)-304 (of)-304 (its)-304 (predecessor)40 (,)-304 (b)20 (ut)-304 (not)-304 (of)-304 (its)-304 (successor)56 (.)-305 (\(Note)-304 (that)-304 (the)-305 (changed)]TJ
3.8617 44.6525 TD
[(Figure)-241 (4.)-241 (A)-241 (lock)-241 (record)-242 (and)-241 (ho)25 (w)-241 (the)15 (y)-241 (are)-241 (chained)-242 (out)-241 (of)-241 (the)-241 (multi-use)-241 (w)10 (ord)-241 (of)]TJ
13.8192 -1 TD
(an object)Tj
ET
0 G
2 J
0 j
0.6 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
315 711 54 -72 re
369 693 m
315 693 l
369 675 m
315 675 l
S 
BT
/N95 1 Tf
7 0 0 7 81 706.33 Tm
(typedef struct LockRecord_s LockRecord;)Tj
0 -1.1428 TD
(struct LockRecord_s {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
[(ExecEnv *owner;)-4200 (/* Owner thread.)-3600 (*/)]TJ
T*
[(int)-3600 (lockCount;)-1800 (/* # recursive locks. */)]TJ
T*
[(BitField storedBits;)-1200 (/* Hash and age.)-3000 ( */)]TJ
T*
[(LockRecord *queue;)-2400 (/* Lock queue on obj. */)]TJ
T*
[(LockRecord *nextFree; /* Free-list.)-5400 (*/)]TJ
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(};)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 323 700.17 Tm
(class ptr)Tj
-0.8 -7.017 TD
[(lock)10 (ed object)]TJ
ET
0 J
1.08 w
395.12 696.43 m
403.26 701.5 l
393.66 701.51 l
394.39 698.97 l
s 
395.12 696.43 m
403.26 701.5 l
393.66 701.51 l
394.39 698.97 l
f* 
2 J
0.6 w
393.91 698.83 m
342 684 l
353.5 675 m
353.5 693 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 357.5 680.5 Tm
(01)Tj
ET
405 711 27 -27 re
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 405.46 675.67 Tm
(lock)Tj
ET
0 J
1.08 w
440.88 695.24 m
448.33 701.29 l
438.81 700.11 l
439.85 697.68 l
s 
440.88 695.24 m
448.33 701.29 l
438.81 700.11 l
439.85 697.68 l
f* 
2 J
0.6 w
439.39 697.48 m
423 690.5 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 405.46 665.67 Tm
(record)Tj
ET
450 711 27 -27 re
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 450.46 675.67 Tm
(lock)Tj
ET
0 J
1.08 w
485.88 695.24 m
493.33 701.29 l
483.81 700.11 l
484.85 697.68 l
s 
485.88 695.24 m
493.33 701.29 l
483.81 700.11 l
484.85 697.68 l
f* 
2 J
0.6 w
484.39 697.48 m
468 690.5 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 450.46 665.67 Tm
(record)Tj
ET
495 711 27 -27 re
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 495.46 675.67 Tm
(lock)Tj
0 -1 TD
(record)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
7 0 0 7 84.5 537.95 Tm
(BitField getMetaLock\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj\) {)Tj
1.2 -2.2857 TD
(BitField busyBits = ee | BUSY;)Tj
0 -1.1429 TD
(BitField lockBits =)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(SWAP\(busyBits, multiUseWordAddr\(obj\)\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(return getLockState\(lockBits\) != BUSY ?)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(lockBits : getMetaLockSlow\(ee, lockBits\);)Tj
-2.4 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
31.9486 8 TD
(void releaseMetaLock\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj,)Tj
12.6 -1.1429 TD
(BitField releaseBits\) {)Tj
-11.4 -1.1428 TD
(BitField busyBits = ee | BUSY;)Tj
T*
(BitField lockBits = CAS\(releaseBits, busyBits,)Tj
14.4 -1.1429 TD
(multiUseWordAddr\(obj\)\);)Tj
-14.4 -1.1429 TD
(if \(lockBits != busyBits\))Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(releaseMetaLockSlow\(ee, releaseBits\);)Tj
-2.4 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 195.77 458.33 Tm
[(Figure 5. F)16 (ast paths for meta-lock operations)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 13 13
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(10)Tj
-19 56.4858 TD
[(multi-use)-242 (w)10 (ord)-242 (v)25 (alue)-242 (that)-242 (causes)-242 (the)-242 (f)10 (ast)-242 (path)-242 (of)-242 (meta-lock)-242 (release)-242 (to)-242 (f)11 (ail)-242 (is)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
30.2192 0 TD
(not)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.52 0 TD
[(necessarily)-243 (that)-242 (of)]TJ
-31.7392 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-410 (releasing)-411 (thread\325)55 (s)-410 (successor;)-411 (se)25 (v)15 (eral)-411 (threads)-410 (may)-410 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-411 (performed)-411 (sw)10 (aps)-410 (since)-411 (the)-411 (current)]TJ
T*
[(thread)-316 (acquired)-316 (the)-315 (meta-lock,)-316 (and)-316 (the)-316 (v)25 (alue)-316 (present)-316 (will)-316 (re\337ect)-316 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
27.8608 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5158 0 TD
[(of)-316 (the)-316 (last)-316 (such)-316 (thread.\))]TJ
-29.3767 -1.1667 TD
[(Because)-313 (of)-313 (this)-313 (asymmetry)65 (,)-313 (the)-313 (hand-of)25 (f)-313 (from)-313 (a)-313 (predecessor)-313 (to)-313 (its)-313 (successor)-313 (synchronizes)-312 (using)]TJ
T*
[(state)-332 (in)-331 (the)-332 (predecessor\325)56 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.5467 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(.)-332 (A)0 (s)-331 (w)0 (e)-332 (s)0 (a)16 (w)-332 (in)-331 (Figure)-250 (1,)-332 (that)-332 (state)-331 (includes)-332 (a)-331 (mute)14 (x)-332 (and)-331 (condition)]TJ
-11.7467 -1.1667 TD
[(v)25 (ariable)-279 (pair)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.3092 0 TD
(metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.8 0 TD
0 Tw
(/)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.2783 0 TD
(metaLockCondvar)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.96 0 TD
[(,)-279 (a)-279 (\336eld)-279 (to)-279 (record)-279 (the)-279 (successor\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
13.4792 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-279 (and)]TJ
-37.0267 -1.1667 TD
[(se)25 (v)15 (eral)-252 (booleans)-251 (used)-252 (to)-252 (coordinate)-251 (the)-252 (transfer)-252 (of)-252 (the)-252 (v)25 (alue)-252 (of)-251 (the)-252 (release)-252 (bits.)-252 (The)-252 (mute)15 (x)-253 (i)0 (s)-251 (used)]TJ
T*
[(to)-271 (ensure)-271 (that)-272 (the)-270 (threads)-271 (participating)-271 (in)-271 (the)-270 (hand-of)25 (f)-271 (update)-271 (the)-271 (other)-271 (\336elds)-271 (in)-271 (the)-270 (correct)-271 (order)55 (.)]TJ
T*
[(The)-310 (condition)-310 (v)25 (ariable)-310 (is)-310 (used)-310 (to)-309 (block)-310 (whiche)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)-310 (thread)-310 (enters)-310 (the)-310 (hand-of)25 (f)-310 (\336rst)-311 (until)-309 (the)-310 (other)]TJ
T*
(thread is ready to complete the transaction.)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-247 (hand-of)25 (f)-248 (protocol)-248 (proceeds)-247 (in)-248 (one)-248 (of)-248 (tw)10 (o)-247 (w)9 (ays,)-248 (as)-248 (sho)25 (wn)-248 (in)-248 (Figure)-250 (6.)-247 (The)-248 (predecessor)-247 (thread)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(releasing)-238 (the)-239 (meta-lock)-239 (and)-238 (the)-239 (successor)-239 (thread)-238 (attempting)-239 (to)-239 (acquire)-239 (it)-238 (\322race\323)-239 (to)-239 (acquire)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36 0 TD
(meta-)Tj
-36 -1.1667 TD
(LockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.63 0 TD
[(in)-230 (the)-230 (predecessor)-231 (thread\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.8075 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(.)-231 (I)0 (f)-230 (the)-230 (predecessor)-231 (thread)-230 (wins)-230 (the)-230 (race,)-231 (it)-230 (will)-231 (set)-231 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-17.6375 -1.1667 TD
(bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.8858 0 TD
[(\336eld)-286 (in)-285 (its)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.3583 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4858 0 TD
(to)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.0642 0 TD
(TRUE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-286 (I)0 (f)-286 (the)-286 (successor)-285 (thread)-286 (wins)-286 (the)-285 (race,)-287 (it)-286 (will)-286 (change)-286 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-16.1942 -1.1667 TD
(succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.9225 0 TD
[(\336eld)-322 (of)-322 (its)-322 (predecessor\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.2308 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5225 0 TD
[(from)-322 (the)-322 (def)10 (ault)-322 (v)25 (alue)-322 (of)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.5175 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.7217 0 TD
[(to)-323 (the)-321 (address)-323 (of)-322 (its)-322 (o)25 (w)0 (n)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-28.915 -1.1667 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(.)-303 (Thus,)-302 (each)-303 (thread)-303 (may)-303 (determine)-302 (whether)-302 (it)-302 (w)9 (o)0 (n)-302 (the)-303 (race)-302 (by)-302 (noting)-302 (whether)-303 (the)-302 (competitor)]TJ
-1.2 -1.1667 TD
(has made the corresponding change.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Case)-238 (1:)-239 (successor)-238 (\(acquiring\))-238 (thr)37 (ead)-238 (wins)-238 (r)16 (ace)15 (.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
19.35 0 TD
[(When)-239 (the)-238 (successor)-239 (thread)-238 (obtains)-238 (the)-238 (mute)15 (x)-238 (and)]TJ
-19.35 -1.1667 TD
[(its)-228 (predecessor\325)56 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.7883 0 TD
(bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.8283 0 TD
[(\336eld)-228 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.9017 0 TD
(FALSE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3 0 TD
[(,)-227 (i)0 (t)-229 (kno)25 (ws)-228 (it)-228 (acquired)-228 (the)-228 (mute)15 (x)-228 (before)-228 (the)-228 (prede-)]TJ
-19.5183 -1.1667 TD
[(cessor)55 (.)-247 (I)0 (n)-247 (this)-247 (e)25 (v)15 (ent,)-247 (it)-247 (updates)-247 (the)-247 (predecessors\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.9342 0 TD
(succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6 0 TD
[(,)-247 (and)-248 (w)10 (aits)-248 (for)-246 (the)-247 (predecessor)-247 (to)-247 (com-)]TJ
-23.5342 -1.1667 TD
[(plete)-241 (the)-240 (transaction.)-240 (When)-241 (the)-240 (predecessor)-241 (acquires)-240 (the)-240 (mute)15 (x,)-241 (it)-241 (notes)-241 (from)-241 (the)-240 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
34.2183 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6408 0 TD
[(v)25 (alue)]TJ
-36.8592 -1.1667 TD
[(in)-274 (its)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.2725 0 TD
(succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.875 0 TD
[(\336eld)-274 (that)-275 (the)-275 (successor)-274 (went)-274 (\336rst,)-275 (and)-275 (therefore)-275 (completes)-274 (the)-275 (meta-lock)-274 (hand-of)25 (f)]TJ
-6.1475 -1.1667 TD
[(by)-317 (setting)-318 (the)-318 (successor\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.6592 0 TD
(metaLockBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.5175 0 TD
[(to)-318 (the)-318 (release)-318 (bits,)-317 (setting)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.7275 0 TD
(gotMetaLockSlow)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.3175 0 TD
(to)Tj
-38.2217 -1.1667 TD
[(indicate)-313 (that)-313 (those)-313 (bits)-313 (are)-314 (v)25 (alid,)-313 (and)-313 (w)10 (aking)-313 (the)-314 (successor)-313 (by)-313 (signalling)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
29.805 0 TD
(metaLockCondvar)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.945 0 TD
(.)Tj
-38.75 -1.1667 TD
[(Finally)65 (,)-314 (the)-314 (predecessor)-315 (releases)-314 (the)-314 (mute)15 (x,)-314 (allo)25 (wing)-314 (the)-315 (successor)-314 (to)-314 (continue,)-314 (ha)20 (ving)-314 (acquired)]TJ
T*
(the meta-lock.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Case)-292 (2:)-291 (pr)37 (edecessor)-292 (\(r)37 (eleasing\))-290 (thr)37 (ead)-292 (wins)-291 (r)15 (ace)15 (.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
20.4233 0 TD
[(Here)-292 (the)-291 (predecessor)-291 (thread)-292 (determines)-291 (that)-292 (it)]TJ
-20.4233 -1.1667 TD
[(acquired)-272 (the)-272 (mute)14 (x)-272 (\336rst)-272 (by)-272 (noting)-272 (that)-272 (its)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.885 0 TD
(succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8725 0 TD
[(\336eld)-272 (is)-272 (still)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.7625 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-272 (I)0 (t)-272 (does)-272 (not)-273 (kno)25 (w)-272 (the)-272 (iden-)]TJ
-27.92 -1.1667 TD
[(tity)-329 (of)-329 (its)-329 (successor)41 (,)-329 (b)20 (ut)-329 (it)-329 (kno)25 (ws)-329 (that)-329 (the)-329 (successor)-329 (kno)25 (ws)-329 (its)-329 (identity)65 (.)-329 (Thus,)-328 (it)-329 (sets)-329 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36 0 TD
(meta-)Tj
-36 -1.1667 TD
(LockBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.1058 0 TD
[(\336eld)-307 (of)-306 (its)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.475 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5067 0 TD
[(to)-306 (the)-306 (proper)-306 (release)-306 (bits)-306 (v)25 (alue,)-306 (and)-306 (sets)-307 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
18.1442 0 TD
(bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.9058 0 TD
[(\336eld)-306 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-36.1375 -1.1667 TD
(TRUE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.625 0 TD
[(to)-226 (indicate)-225 (that)-226 (those)-226 (bits)-225 (are)-226 (v)25 (alid,)-226 (and)-225 (w)10 (aits)-225 (for)-226 (the)-225 (successor)-225 (to)-225 (read)-226 (the)-225 (bits)-225 (\(releasing)-226 (the)]TJ
-2.625 -1.1667 TD
[(mute)15 (x)-264 (i)0 (n)-264 (the)-265 (process\).)-264 (The)-264 (successor)-264 (thread)-264 (obtains)-265 (the)-264 (mute)15 (x,)-265 (sees)-264 (that)-265 (its)-264 (predecessor\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36 0 TD
(bits-)Tj
-36 -1.1667 TD
(ForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.5008 0 TD
(is)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.9675 0 TD
(TRUE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(,)-301 (and)-300 (thus)-300 (realizes)-301 (that)-301 (it)-301 (has)-300 (acquired)-300 (the)-300 (mute)15 (x)-301 (second,)-300 (and)-301 (that)-301 (the)-300 (release)]TJ
-7.8683 -1.1667 TD
[(bits)-243 (are)-243 (a)20 (v)25 (ailable)-243 (in)-244 (its)-242 (predecessor\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.8008 0 TD
(metaLockBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.4433 0 TD
[(\336eld.)-243 (It)-243 (copies)-243 (those)-244 (bits,)-242 (resets)-244 (the)-243 (prede-)]TJ
-22.2442 -1.1667 TD
[(cessor\325)55 (s)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.4392 0 TD
(bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.8733 0 TD
[(to)-274 (the)-273 (def)10 (ault)-273 (v)25 (alue)-273 (of)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.1075 0 TD
(FALSE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.2733 0 TD
[(to)-273 (indicate)-274 (that)-272 (the)-274 (hand-of)25 (f)-273 (i)0 (s)-274 (complete,)]TJ
-22.6933 -1.1667 TD
[(signals)-426 (its)-426 (predecessor\325)55 (s)-426 (condition)-426 (v)25 (ariable)-426 (to)-426 (inform)-425 (it)-426 (of)-426 (that)-426 (f)10 (act,)-426 (and,)-426 (\336nally)65 (,)-426 (releases)-426 (the)]TJ
T*
[(mute)15 (x.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-317 (meta-lock)-317 (protocol)-317 (guarantees)-316 (that)-317 (threads)-316 (obtain)-317 (the)-316 (meta-lock)-317 (in)-317 (the)-317 (order)-317 (determined)-317 (by)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-240 (e)16 (x)15 (ecution)-239 (of)-239 (the)-240 (atomic)-239 (sw)9 (ap)-239 (operations.)-239 (A)-240 (thread)-239 (need)-239 (only)-239 (w)9 (ait)-239 (for)-239 (threads)-239 (ahead)-240 (of)-239 (it)-240 (in)-239 (the)]TJ
T*
[(sw)10 (ap)-254 (order)40 (,)-253 (s)0 (o)-254 (i)0 (f)-254 (n)0 (o)-253 (thread)-254 (blocks)-253 (inde\336nitely)-254 (while)-254 (holding)-254 (the)-254 (meta-lock,)-254 (all)-253 (threads)-254 (attempting)]TJ
T*
[(to acquire the meta-lock will e)26 (v)15 (entually succeed.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(Armed)-300 (with)-299 (this)-299 (meta-lock,)-299 (we)-299 (no)25 (w)-300 (proceed)-299 (to)-299 (implement)-298 (the)-300 (monitor)-299 (operations:)-299 (lock,)-300 (unlock,)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(w)10 (ait,)-445 (and)-444 (notify)65 (.)-444 (Because)-444 (the)-445 (meta-lock)-444 (arbitrates)-445 (access)-444 (among)-445 (contending)-444 (threads,)-444 (we)-444 (can)]TJ
T*
[(implement)-323 (monitor)-323 (operations)-323 (using)-324 (a)-324 (number)-323 (of)-323 (dif)25 (ferent)-324 (data)-323 (structures)-323 (and)-323 (of)25 (fer)-323 (a)-323 (v)25 (ariety)-323 (of)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 14 14
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(11)Tj
-19 29.6525 TD
[(semantics)-329 ([7].)-329 (W)80 (e)-329 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-329 (chosen)-329 (an)-329 (implementation)-328 (that)-329 (uses)-329 (a)-329 (simple)-329 (link)9 (ed)-328 (list)-329 (of)-329 (lock)-329 (records)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
0 Tw
[(and gi)25 (v)15 (es equal preference to a)16 (w)10 (ak)10 (ened w)10 (aiters and ne)26 (wly arri)25 (v)15 (ed threads.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 343.67 Tm
(4.3  Locking and unlocking objects)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 319 Tm
[(Acquiring)-379 (and)-379 (releasing)-379 (the)-380 (monitor)21 (-lock)-379 (of)-379 (an)-379 (object)-378 (corresponds)-379 (to)-379 (entering)-379 (and)-379 (e)15 (xiting)-379 (the)]TJ
T*
[(object\325)55 (s)-359 (monitor)55 (.)-359 (Figure)-250 (7)-360 (sho)25 (ws)-359 (the)-360 (f)10 (ast-path)-359 (implementation)-359 (for)-360 (these)-359 (operations.)-359 (Most)-360 (com-)]TJ
T*
[(monly)65 (,)-279 (the)-279 (object)-279 (being)-279 (monitor)21 (-lock)10 (ed)-279 (is)-279 (either)-279 (unlock)10 (ed\321in)-279 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
26.0975 0 TD
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.4783 0 TD
(or)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.1125 0 TD
(WAITERS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.4783 0 TD
(state\321)Tj
-36.1667 -1.1667 TD
[(or)-349 (being)-350 (lock)10 (ed)-350 (recursi)25 (v)15 (ely)65 (.)-350 (I)0 (n)-350 (these)-350 (cases,)-350 (the)-350 (locking)-350 (thread)-350 (simply)-349 (updates)-350 (the)-350 (object\325)55 (s)-350 (syn-)]TJ
T*
[(chronization)-360 (data;)-360 (it)-360 (need)-359 (not)-360 (interact)-360 (with)-359 (other)-360 (threads.)-360 (Lik)10 (e)25 (wise,)-359 (when)-360 (unlocking)-360 (an)-360 (object,)]TJ
T*
[(there)-269 (are)-269 (tw)10 (o)-269 (cases)-269 (that)-269 (in)40 (v)20 (olv)16 (e)-269 (n)0 (o)-269 (interaction)-269 (with)-269 (other)-269 (threads:)-270 (the)-269 (unlocking)-269 (thread)-269 (has)-269 (recur-)]TJ
T*
[(si)25 (v)15 (ely)-280 (lock)10 (ed)-279 (the)-280 (object,)-279 (in)-279 (which)-279 (case)-279 (it)-280 (simply)-279 (decrements)-279 (the)-280 (lock)-280 (count;)-279 (or)-279 (there)-279 (are)-280 (no)-279 (other)]TJ
T*
[(threads)-272 (attempting)-272 (to)-273 (acquire)-272 (a)-272 (singly-held)-272 (lock,)-272 (in)-272 (which)-273 (case)-272 (it)-272 (restores)-271 (the)-272 (displaced)-272 (multi-use)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ord v)25 (alue, which has the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.685 0 TD
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.2 0 TD
( lock state.)Tj
-14.885 -1.75 TD
[(The)-332 (remaining)-332 (cases)-332 (in)40 (v)20 (olv)16 (e)-333 (threads)-333 (contending)-332 (for)-332 (the)-332 (monitor)20 (-lock;)-332 (see)-333 (Figure)-250 (8.)-332 (Much)-333 (as)-332 (in)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(meta-lock)-244 (hand-of)25 (f,)-244 (we)-245 (use)-244 (a)-244 (per)20 (-thread)-245 (mute)15 (x)-244 (and)-244 (condition)-244 (v)25 (ariable)-245 (to)-244 (coordinate)-244 (acquiring)-244 (and)]TJ
T*
[(releasing)-356 (threads.)-355 (When)-355 (a)-355 (thread)-356 (attempts)-355 (to)-356 (acquire)-355 (a)-355 (monitor)20 (-lock)-355 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-356 (\336nds)-355 (it)-356 (lock)10 (ed,)-355 (it)-356 (sus-)]TJ
T*
[(pends)-232 (on)-232 (a)-232 (condition)-233 (v)25 (ariable)-232 (in)-232 (its)-232 (o)25 (w)0 (n)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.0292 0 TD
(EE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-232 (w)10 (aiting)-232 (to)-232 (be)-233 (signalled)-232 (by)-232 (a)-233 (lock-releasing)-232 (thread)-232 (that)]TJ
-17.2292 -1.1667 TD
[(it)-285 (should)-285 (re-attempt)-285 (the)-285 (acquisition.)-285 (When)-284 (the)-285 (acquiring)-284 (thread)-285 (recei)25 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-284 (this)-285 (signal,)-285 (it)-285 (repeats)-285 (the)]TJ
T*
[(lock-acquisition)-250 (slo)25 (w)-250 (path:)-250 (it)-251 (acquires)-249 (the)-250 (object\325)55 (s)-250 (meta-lock)-250 (and)-250 (checks)-250 (the)-250 (object\325)55 (s)-250 (lock)-250 (state.)-250 (If)]TJ
T*
[(the)-384 (state)-384 (is)-385 (no)25 (w)-384 (dif)25 (ferent)-384 (from)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
13.0842 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6 0 TD
[(,)-384 (i)0 (t)-384 (adjusts)-384 (the)-384 (synchronization)-383 (data)-384 (to)-384 (indicate)-384 (that)-384 (it)]TJ
-16.6842 -1.1667 TD
[(holds)-267 (the)-267 (monitor)20 (-lock)-267 (and)-267 (releases)-267 (the)-267 (meta-lock;)-267 (if)-267 (the)-268 (state)-267 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
25.9725 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6 0 TD
[(,)-268 (the)-267 (thread)-268 (releases)-267 (the)]TJ
-29.5725 -1.1667 TD
[(meta-lock and w)10 (aits again.)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8 0 0 8 309 705.67 Tm
(void releaseMetaLockSlow\(ExecEnv *ee,)Tj
15 -1.25 TD
[(BitField)-544 (releaseBits\))-544 ({)]TJ
-13.8 -1.25 TD
(/* We are in a race with our successor to)Tj
1.8 -1.25 TD
(lock ee->metaLockMutex; the winner of)Tj
T*
(the race waits for the loser. */)Tj
-1.8 -1.25 TD
(mutexLock\(&ee->metaLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(if \(ee->succEE\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.25 TD
(/* Lost the race: */)Tj
T*
(assert\(!ee->succEE->bitsForGrab\);)Tj
T*
(assert\(!ee->bitsForGrab\);)Tj
T*
(assert\(!ee->succEE->gotMetaLockSlow\);)Tj
T*
[(ee->succEE->metaLockBits)-2400 (= releaseBits;)]TJ
T*
(ee->succEE->gotMetaLockSlow = TRUE;)Tj
T*
(ee->succEE = NULL;)Tj
T*
(condvarSignal\(&ee->metaLockCondvar\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.25 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.25 TD
(/* Won the race: */)Tj
T*
(ee->metaLockBits = releaseBits;)Tj
T*
[(ee->bitsForGrab)-1200 (= TRUE;)]TJ
T*
(do {)Tj
1.2 -1.25 TD
(condvarWait\(&ee->metaLockCondvar,)Tj
7.2 -1.25 TD
(&ee->metaLockMutex\);)Tj
-8.4 -1.25 TD
(} while \(ee->bitsForGrab\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.25 TD
(})Tj
T*
(mutexUnlock\(&ee->metaLockMutex\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.25 TD
(})Tj
-29.125 31.25 TD
(BitField getMetaLockSlow\(ExecEnv *ee,)Tj
15 -1.25 TD
(BitField predBits\) {)Tj
-13.8 -1.25 TD
(BitField bits;)Tj
T*
(ExecEnv *predEE = busyEE\(predBits\);)Tj
T*
(assert\(getLockState\(predBits\) == BUSY\);)Tj
T*
(mutexLock\(&predEE->metaLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(if \(!predEE->bitsForGrab\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.25 TD
(/* Won the race: */)Tj
T*
(predEE->succEE = ee;)Tj
T*
(do {)Tj
1.2 -1.25 TD
(condvarWait\(&predEE->metaLockCondvar,)Tj
7.2 -1.25 TD
(&predEE->metaLockMutex\);)Tj
-8.4 -1.25 TD
(} while \(!ee->gotMetaLockSlow\);)Tj
T*
(ee->gotMetaLockSlow = FALSE;)Tj
T*
(bits = ee->metaLockBits;)Tj
-1.2 -1.25 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.25 TD
(/* Lost the race: */)Tj
T*
(bits = predEE->metaLockBits;)Tj
T*
(predEE->bitsForGrab = FALSE;)Tj
T*
(condvarSignal\(&predEE->metaLockCondvar\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.25 TD
(})Tj
T*
(mutexUnlock\(&predEE->metaLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(return bits;)Tj
-1.2 -1.25 TD
(})Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 196 433.67 Tm
[(Figure 6. Slo)25 (w paths for meta-lock operations)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 15 15
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(12)Tj
-19 12.5967 TD
[(T)80 (o)-248 (release)-247 (a)-248 (contended)-248 (monitor)21 (-lock,)-247 (a)-248 (thread)-248 (\336rst)-247 (obtains)-248 (the)-248 (meta-lock.)-247 (Then)-248 (it)-247 (remo)15 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-248 (its)-248 (o)25 (w)0 (n)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(lock)-341 (record)-342 (from)-342 (the)-341 (queue.)-342 (Subsequently)66 (,)-342 (i)0 (t)-341 (calls)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
20.7758 0 TD
(wakeupEE\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.3417 0 TD
[(to)-341 (\336nd)-341 (the)-342 (\336rst)-341 (thread)-342 (on)-342 (the)]TJ
-27.1175 -1.1667 TD
[(lock)-308 (queue)-308 (that)-307 (is)-308 (w)10 (aiting)-308 (to)-309 (acquire)-307 (the)-308 (lock.)-308 (If)-308 (there)-308 (is)-308 (such)-308 (a)-308 (thread,)-308 (it)-308 (is)-308 (signalled.)-307 (Then,)-308 (the)]TJ
T*
[(releasing)-330 (thread)-330 (performs)-331 (a)-330 (meta-lock)-330 (release)-331 (to)-329 (write)-331 (out)-330 (the)-330 (shortened)-330 (lock)-330 (queue)-330 (and)-330 (set)-331 (the)]TJ
T*
[(lock)-280 (state)-280 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.175 0 TD
(WAITERS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.2 0 TD
[(.)-280 (\()0 (W)80 (e)-280 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-280 (elided)-281 (code)-280 (that)-281 (optimizes)-280 (a)15 (w)10 (ay)-280 (redundant)-281 (signalling)-280 (on)-281 (w)10 (ait-)]TJ
-9.375 -1.1667 TD
[(ing)-245 (threads.\))-245 (Thus,)-245 (at)-245 (the)-245 (monitor)20 (-lock)-245 (le)25 (v)15 (el,)-245 (unlik)10 (e)-245 (the)-245 (meta-lock)-245 (le)25 (v)15 (el,)-245 (we)-245 (do)-245 (not)-245 (use)-244 (a)-245 (hand-of)25 (f:)]TJ
T*
[(the)-238 (releasing)-238 (thread)-238 (does)-238 (not)-239 (gi)26 (v)14 (e)-238 (the)-238 (monitor)20 (-lock)-238 (to)-238 (a)-238 (w)10 (aiting)-239 (thread)-238 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-238 (merely)-238 (in)40 (vites)-238 (the)-238 (w)10 (ait-)]TJ
T*
0 Tw
(ing thread to re-attempt the acquisition.)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
7 0 0 7 80.71 710.55 Tm
(bool_t monitorEnter\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
[(BitField)-1201 (r)-3000 (=)0 ( getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)]TJ
T*
(LockState state = lockState\(r\);)Tj
T*
(if \(state == NEUTRAL\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(/* Establish locking by this thread. */)Tj
T*
(LockRecord *lr = allocLockRecord\(ee\);)Tj
T*
(lr->storedBits = r;)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, lr | LOCKED\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1428 TD
(} else if \(state == LOCKED\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(LockRecord *ownerLR = lockRecord\(r\);)Tj
T*
(if \(ownerLR->owner == ee\) {)Tj
1.2014 -1.1429 TD
(/* Recursive locking. */)Tj
T*
(ownerLR->lockCount++;)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
-1.2014 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2014 -1.1429 TD
(LockRecord *lr = allocLockRecord\(ee\);)Tj
T*
(ownerLR->queue = appendToQueue\(ownerLR->queue,)Tj
18.6 -1.1428 TD
(lr\);)Tj
-18.6 -1.1429 TD
(monitorEnterSlow\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
-1.2014 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(} else if \(state == WAITERS\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(/* obj is unlocked but has threads waiting)Tj
1.8 -1.1429 TD
(for notification. */)Tj
-1.8 -1.1429 TD
(LockRecord *lr = allocLockRecord\(ee\);)Tj
T*
(LockRecord *firstWaiterLR = lockRecord\(r\);)Tj
T*
[(lr->queue)-3600 (= firstWaiterLR;)]TJ
T*
(lr->storedBits = firstWaiterLR->storedBits;)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, lr | LOCKED\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
T*
(return TRUE;)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
33.47 34.3871 TD
(bool_t monitorExit\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
[(BitField)-2400 (r)-4200 (=)0 ( getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)]TJ
T*
(LockRecord *ownerLR = lockRecord\(r\);)Tj
T*
[(LockState)-1800 (state)-1800 (= lockState\(r\);)]TJ
T*
(if \(state == LOCKED && ownerLR->owner == ee\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(assert\(ownerLR->lockCount >= 1\);)Tj
T*
(if \(ownerLR->lockCount == 1\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(/* Last release: will not have lock)Tj
1.8 -1.1429 TD
(after this operation. */)Tj
-1.8 -1.1429 TD
(if \(ownerLR->queue == NULL\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(/* No-one waiting. */)Tj
T*
(assert\(lockState\(ownerLR->storedBits\))Tj
4.8 -1.1429 TD
(== NEUTRAL\);)Tj
-4.8 -1.1429 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj,)Tj
9.6 -1.1429 TD
(ownerLR->storedBits\);)Tj
-10.8 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(/* There is a queue. Release)Tj
1.8 -1.1429 TD
(with wakeup call. */)Tj
-1.8 -1.1429 TD
(ownerLR->queue->storedBits =)Tj
12 -1.1429 TD
(ownerLR->storedBits;)Tj
-12 -1.1429 TD
(monitorExitSlow\(ee, obj, ownerLR->queue\);)Tj
T*
(ownerLR->queue = NULL;)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
T*
(recycleLockRecord\(ee, ownerLR\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(/* Still has lock after this. */)Tj
T*
(ownerLR->lockCount--;)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
T*
(throwIllegalMonitorStateException\(\);)Tj
T*
(return FALSE;)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
T*
(return TRUE;)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 191.05 413.5 Tm
[(Figure 7. F)15 (ast paths for monitor)20 (-lock operations)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7 0 0 7 81 368.43 Tm
(void monitorEnterSlow\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj,)Tj
13.2 -1.1429 TD
(BitField r\) {)Tj
-12 -1.1429 TD
(LockRecord *lr;)Tj
T*
(while \(lockState\(r\) == LOCKED\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(mutexLock\(&ee->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
T*
(condvarWait\(&ee->monitorLockCondvar,)Tj
7.2 -1.1429 TD
(&ee->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
-7.2 -1.1429 TD
(mutexUnlock\(&ee->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(r = getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
T*
(assert\(lockState\(r\) == WAITERS\);)Tj
T*
(lr = moveMyLRToFront\(ee, lockRecord\(r\)\);)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, lr | LOCKED\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
33.4286 15.9386 TD
(void monitorExitSlow\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj,)Tj
12.6 -1.1429 TD
(LockRecord *lr\) {)Tj
-11.4 -1.1429 TD
(ExecEnv *wakeEE = wakeupEE\(lr\);)Tj
T*
(if \(wakeEE\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(mutexLock\(&wakeEE->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, lr | WAITERS\);)Tj
T*
(condvarSignal\(&wakeEE->monitorLockCondvar\);)Tj
T*
(mutexUnlock\(&wakeEE->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, lr | WAITERS\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 188.78 239.67 Tm
[(Figure 8. Slo)25 (ws path for monitor)21 (-lock operations)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 16 16
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(13)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 406.17 Tm
0 Tw
[(4.4  W)65 (aiting and notifying)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 381.5 Tm
[(Figure)-250 (9)-248 (sho)25 (ws)-247 (the)-247 (remaining)-247 (tw)10 (o)-247 (monitor)-248 (operations:)-247 (w)9 (ait)-247 (and)-248 (notify)65 (.)-248 (The)-247 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-247 (language)-247 (speci\336-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(cation)-230 (requires)-230 (that)-231 (the)-230 (thread)-230 (performing)-231 (them)-230 (must)-231 (hold)-230 (the)-230 (object\325)55 (s)-230 (monitor)20 (-lock,)-230 (otherwise)-231 (the)]TJ
T*
[(operations)-292 (thro)25 (w)-292 (a)0 (n)-293 (e)15 (xception.)-292 (A)-292 (thread)-293 (w)10 (aits)-293 (by)-292 (acquiring)-292 (the)-292 (meta-lock,)-292 (setting)-292 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
34.8 0 TD
(isWait-)Tj
-34.8 -1.1667 TD
(ingForNotify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.5242 0 TD
[(\336eld)-324 (in)-324 (its)-323 (EE,)-325 (and)-323 (releasing)-324 (the)-324 (monitor)20 (-lock)-323 (and)-324 (meta-lock)-324 (\(i.e.,)-323 (setting)-325 (the)]TJ
-7.5242 -1.1667 TD
[(lock)-269 (state)-268 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.1383 0 TD
(WAITERS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.2 0 TD
[(\).)-269 (It)-268 (then)-268 (w)10 (aits)-268 (until)-268 (a)-269 (noti\336cation)-268 (operation)-268 (mak)10 (es)-269 (it)-268 (a)-269 (potential)-268 (lock)-268 (con-)]TJ
-9.3383 -1.1667 TD
[(tender)-239 (again,)-239 (and)-239 (some)-239 (monitor)21 (-lock)-239 (release)-239 (operation)-239 (signals)-239 (it)-240 (to)-239 (acti)25 (v)15 (ely)-239 (contend,)-239 (or)-239 (until)-239 (some)]TJ
T*
[(amount)-285 (of)-284 (time)-284 (speci\336ed)-285 (in)-284 (the)-285 (w)10 (ait)-285 (operation)-284 (has)-284 (elapsed.)-285 (A)-285 (notifying)-284 (thread)-285 (similarly)-285 (acquires)]TJ
T*
[(the)-309 (meta-lock.)-309 (Then)-309 (it)-310 (w)10 (alks)-309 (the)-310 (queue)-309 (of)-309 (lock)-309 (records,)-309 (looking)-309 (for)-310 (threads)-309 (w)9 (aiting)-309 (for)-309 (noti\336ca-)]TJ
T*
[(tion\321ones)-324 (whose)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7.5933 0 TD
(isWaitingForNotify)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.1242 0 TD
[(\336eld)-324 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.0942 0 TD
(TRUE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(\321and)-324 (resetting)-324 (this)-325 (boolean)-324 (to)-324 (indi-)]TJ
-24.2117 -1.1667 TD
[(cate)-282 (that)-282 (the)15 (y)-282 (h)0 (a)20 (v)15 (e)-282 (been)-282 (noti\336ed.)-281 (The)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.3917 0 TD
(notify\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.0825 0 TD
[(operation)-281 (\336nds)-282 (the)-281 (\336rst)-282 (such)-282 (thread)-282 (and)-282 (resets)]TJ
-20.4742 -1.1667 TD
[(its)-255 (boolean;)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.8992 0 TD
(notifyAll\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.855 0 TD
[(tra)20 (v)15 (erses)-255 (the)-255 (entire)-255 (lock)-255 (queue.)-255 (Finally)65 (,)-255 (the)-255 (notifying)-254 (thread)-255 (releases)]TJ
-11.7542 -1.1667 TD
(the meta-lock.)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(Since)-405 (some)-406 (styles)-405 (of)-405 (concurrent)-405 (programming)-405 (result)-405 (in)-406 (a)-405 (high)-405 (frequenc)16 (y)-406 (o)0 (f)-405 (noti\336cations,)-405 (our)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(implementation)-331 (has)-331 (further)-331 (optimized)-331 (the)-330 (notify)-332 (code)-331 (\(the)-331 (optimization)-331 (is)-331 (not)-331 (sho)25 (wn)-331 (in)-331 (the)-331 (\336g-)]TJ
T*
[(ure\).)-242 (The)-242 (idea)-243 (is)-242 (that)-242 (a)-243 (simple)-242 (read)-242 (of)-242 (the)-243 (multi-use)-242 (w)10 (ord)-243 (most)-242 (of)-243 (the)-242 (time)-242 (suf)25 (\336ces)-242 (to)-242 (grab)-243 (the)-242 (root)]TJ
T*
[(of)-253 (the)-252 (lock)-252 (queue.)-253 (If)-252 (the)-253 (read)-252 (fetches)-252 (a)-253 (w)10 (ord)-253 (in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
18.9008 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8525 0 TD
[(state,)-252 (the)-253 (notifying)-252 (thread)-253 (can)-252 (v)15 (erify)-253 (that)]TJ
-22.7533 -1.1667 TD
[(it)-314 (holds)-314 (the)-314 (monitor)20 (-lock)-314 (and)-313 (w)10 (alk)-314 (the)-314 (queue)-314 (without)-314 (holding)-314 (the)-315 (meta-lock.)-313 (The)-314 (correctness)-313 (of)]TJ
T*
[(this)-292 (optimization)-291 (relies)-291 (on)-292 (tw)10 (o)-292 (properties:)-291 (a)-291 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-291 (thread)-291 (w)9 (aiting)-291 (for)-291 (a)-291 (notify)-292 (cannot)-291 (appear)-291 (in)-292 (the)]TJ
T*
[(queue)-249 (\(because)-250 (the)-250 (notifying)-250 (thread)-249 (holds)-250 (the)-250 (monitor)21 (-lock\),)-250 (and)-250 (other)-250 (threads)-249 (that)-250 (join)-250 (the)-250 (queue)]TJ
T*
[(do)-391 (so)-391 (at)-390 (the)-390 (end)-391 (\(so)-390 (the)-391 (queue)-390 (is)-390 (ne)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)-391 (disconnected\).)-390 (See)-391 (also)-391 (Section)-391 (6.3)-391 (for)-391 (an)-391 (alternati)26 (v)15 (e)]TJ
T*
[(implementation in which notify does no queue w)11 (alking.)]TJ
13.4017 31.5417 TD
[(Figure 9. W)80 (ait and notify code)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7 0 0 7 77.5 711.33 Tm
(void monitorWait\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj,)Tj
10.2 -1.1429 TD
(java_long millis\) {)Tj
-9 -1.1429 TD
[(BitField)-2400 (r)-4200 (=)0 ( getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)]TJ
T*
(LockRecord *ownerLR = lockRecord\(r\);)Tj
T*
[(LockState)-1800 (state)-1800 (= lockState\(r\);)]TJ
T*
(if \(state == LOCKED && ownerLR->owner == ee\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1428 TD
(mutexLock\(&ee->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(ee->isWaitingForNotify = TRUE;)Tj
T*
(monitorExitSlow\(ee, obj, ownerLR\);)Tj
T*
(if \(millis == TIMEOUT_INFINITY\))Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(condvarWait\(&ee->monitorLockCondvar,)Tj
7.2 -1.1429 TD
(&ee->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
-8.4 -1.1429 TD
(else)Tj
1.2 -1.1428 TD
(condvarTimedWait\(&ee->monitorLockCondvar,)Tj
7.2 -1.1429 TD
(&ee->monitorLockMutex, millis\);)Tj
-8.4 -1.1429 TD
(ee->isWaitingForNotify = FALSE;)Tj
T*
(mutexUnlock\(&ee->monitorLockMutex\);)Tj
T*
(r = getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)Tj
T*
(monitorEnterSlow\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
T*
(throwIllegalMonitorStateException\(\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1428 TD
(})Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
33.9086 26.2857 TD
(void notifyOneOrAll\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj,)Tj
12 -1.1429 TD
(bool_t one\) {)Tj
-10.8 -1.1429 TD
[(BitField)-2400 (r)-4200 (=)0 ( getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)]TJ
T*
(LockRecord *ownerLR = lockRecord\(r\);)Tj
T*
[(LockState)-1800 (state)-1800 (= lockState\(r\);)]TJ
T*
(if \(state == LOCKED && ownerLR->owner == ee\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1428 TD
(LockRecord *q = ownerLR->queue;)Tj
T*
(while \(q\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(if \(q->owner->isWaitingForNotify\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(q->owner->isWaitingForNotify = FALSE;)Tj
T*
(if \(one\) break;)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
T*
(q = q->queue;)Tj
-1.2 -1.1428 TD
(})Tj
T*
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(} else {)Tj
1.2 -1.1428 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, r\);)Tj
T*
(throwIllegalMonitorStateException\(\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
0 -2.2857 TD
(void monitorNotify\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1428 TD
(notifyOneOrAll\(ee, obj, TRUE\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
0 -2.2857 TD
(void monitorNotifyAll\(ExecEnv *ee, Object *obj\) {)Tj
1.2 -1.1429 TD
(notifyOneOrAll\(ee, obj, FALSE\);)Tj
-1.2 -1.1429 TD
(})Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 17 17
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(14)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 709.33 Tm
0 Tw
[(5  Corr)18 (ectness)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 686 Tm
[(Belo)25 (w)65 (,)-250 (we)-251 (will)-250 (informally)-249 (ar)18 (gue)-250 (the)-250 (correctness)-250 (of)-250 (the)-250 (meta-lock)-250 (protocol)-250 (by)-250 (sho)25 (wing,)-250 (operation-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(ally)65 (,)-247 (that)-246 (it)-246 (guarantees)-246 (mutual)-247 (e)16 (xclusion)-247 (and)-246 (freedom)-247 (from)-246 (lock)10 (out.)-247 (W)40 (ithout)-246 (loss)-246 (of)-246 (generality)65 (,)-247 (w)0 (e)]TJ
T*
[(can)-276 (focus)-276 (our)-277 (attention)-276 (on)-277 (a)-276 (single)-277 (object)-276 (that)-277 (is)-276 (subject)-276 (to)-277 (locking)-276 (by)-277 (the)-276 (meta-lock)-277 (protocol.)-276 (\(A)]TJ
T*
[(formal)-408 (proof)-407 (that)-407 (the)-408 (meta-lock)-407 (guarantees)-408 (mutual)-408 (e)16 (xclusion)-407 (and)-408 (freedom)-408 (from)-408 (lock)10 (out)-408 (uses,)]TJ
T*
[(respecti)25 (v)15 (ely)65 (,)-378 (Lamport\325)55 (s)-379 (method)-378 (of)-379 (inducti)26 (v)15 (e)-379 (assertions)-378 (as)-379 (e)16 (x)14 (empli\336ed)-378 (in)-379 ([15])-378 (and)-378 (the)-379 (Owicki-)]TJ
T*
(Lamport technique of [23].\))Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 583.67 Tm
(5.1  Mutual exclusion)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 559 Tm
[(Assume)-319 (that)-318 (a)-319 (thread)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.94 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5183 0 TD
[(attempts)-318 (to)-319 (obtain)-319 (the)-319 (meta-lock)-318 (by)-318 (calling)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
17.8408 0 TD
(getMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.8 0 TD
[(.)-319 (There)]TJ
-36.0992 -1.1667 TD
[(are)-291 (tw)9 (o)-292 (cases)-292 (to)-292 (consider)-292 (according)-292 (to)-292 (whether)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.2642 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4925 0 TD
[(reads)-292 (a)-292 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.9708 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6917 0 TD
[(or)-292 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
1.8608 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6925 0 TD
[(status)-292 (from)-292 (the)]TJ
-32.9725 -1.1667 TD
[(atomic sw)10 (ap in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.295 0 TD
(getMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.8 0 TD
(.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
-14.095 -1.75 TD
[(Case)-295 (1:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 113.08 510 Tm
(T1)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 131.02 510 Tm
[(r)37 (eads)-294 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 182.78 510 Tm
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 210.03 510 Tm
[(.)-295 (I)0 (n)-295 (this)-295 (case,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.68 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.495 0 TD
[(has)-295 (the)-295 (meta-lock,)-295 (and)-295 (we)-296 (need)-295 (only)-294 (sho)25 (w)-296 (that)-295 (no)]TJ
-18.6775 -1.1667 TD
[(other)-369 (thread)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.2925 0 TD
(T\325)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5692 0 TD
[(can)-369 (no)25 (w)-370 (obtain)-369 (the)-369 (meta-lock)-369 (before)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.5742 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5692 0 TD
[(has)-369 (released)-369 (the)-369 (meta-lock.)-369 (F)15 (o)0 (r)-369 (this,)]TJ
-24.005 -1.1667 TD
[(observ)15 (e)-269 (that,)-268 (follo)26 (wing)-268 (the)-268 (sw)9 (ap)-268 (by)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.585 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-268 (the)-268 (header)-268 (w)10 (ord)-269 (has)-268 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.5683 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6683 0 TD
[(status.)-268 (Thus,)-268 (an)15 (y)-268 (thread)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.7783 0 TD
(T\325)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-37.8 -1.1667 TD
[(that)-247 (tries)-248 (to)-248 (obtain)-248 (the)-247 (meta-lock)-247 (before)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.01 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4475 0 TD
[(has)-248 (released)-248 (the)-248 (meta-lock)-247 (will)-247 (read)-248 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.2858 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6475 0 TD
[(status.)-248 (In)]TJ
-35.3908 -1.1667 TD
[(particular)41 (,)-462 (the)-462 (\336rst)-461 (subsequent)-462 (thread)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.0733 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.6625 0 TD
[(to)-462 (attempt)-462 (to)-462 (obtain)-462 (the)-462 (meta-lock)-462 (will)-462 (read)-461 (<)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.8142 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-38.75 -1.1667 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(>.)-338 (In)-338 (this)-338 (case,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.4142 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5383 0 TD
[(will)-337 (need)-338 (to)-338 (e)15 (x)15 (ecute)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.5967 0 TD
(getMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.5383 0 TD
[(to)-338 (obtain)-337 (the)-338 (meta-lock)]TJ
-29.4875 -1.1667 TD
(from)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.2392 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-295 (its)-294 (predecessor)55 (.)-295 (W)80 (e)-295 (sho)26 (w)-295 (belo)25 (w)-295 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.4867 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.495 0 TD
[(will)-295 (be)-295 (unable)-295 (to)-294 (obtain)-295 (the)-295 (meta-lock)-295 (at)-295 (least)]TJ
-20.4208 -1.1667 TD
(until)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.1992 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.565 0 TD
[(e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-365 (the)-365 (meta-lock)-365 (release)-365 (code.)-365 (Similarly)65 (,)-365 (a)0 (n)15 (y)-365 (subsequent)-365 (attempts)-365 (to)-365 (obtain)-366 (the)]TJ
-3.7642 -1.1667 TD
[(meta-lock)-402 (\(while)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7.3592 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.6017 0 TD
[(is)-403 (in)-402 (possession)-403 (of)-402 (the)-402 (meta-lock\))-403 (will)-402 (stall)-402 (with)-403 (each)-402 (thread)-402 (w)9 (aiting)-402 (to)]TJ
-8.9608 -1.1667 TD
[(obtain)-425 (the)-425 (meta-lock)-425 (from)-426 (its)-425 (predecessor)-425 (in)-425 (the)-425 (sequence.)-425 (Thus,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
27.7483 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.625 0 TD
[(is)-425 (guaranteed)-425 (e)16 (xclusi)25 (v)15 (e)]TJ
-29.3733 -1.1667 TD
(access.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Case)-283 (2:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 112.79 349 Tm
(T1)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 130.59 349 Tm
[(r)36 (eads)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 160.21 349 Tm
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 187.46 349 Tm
[(.)-283 (Assume)-284 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.8217 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4833 0 TD
[(reads)-283 (<)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.9575 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.5333 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(>)-284 (from)-283 (the)-283 (header)-283 (w)10 (ord,)-283 (where)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12.8325 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4825 0 TD
(is)Tj
-38.3325 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-368 (thread)-368 (that)-368 (e)15 (x)15 (ecuted)-367 (the)-368 (atomic)-368 (sw)10 (ap)-368 (immediately)-368 (preceding)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
26.9883 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(.)-368 (I)0 (n)-368 (this)-367 (e)25 (v)15 (ent,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.3758 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5675 0 TD
[(will)-368 (be)]TJ
-36.1317 -1.1667 TD
[(forced)-256 (to)-256 (e)15 (x)15 (ecute)-256 (the)-255 (meta-lock)-256 (hand-of)25 (f)-256 (protocol)-256 (with)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
22.1542 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-256 (its)-256 (predecessor)55 (.)-256 (This)-256 (will)-256 (happen)-255 (only)]TJ
-23.3542 -1.1667 TD
(after)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.0942 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4617 0 TD
[(has)-262 (itself)-262 (obtained)-262 (the)-262 (meta-lock)-262 (and)-262 (subsequently)-262 (attempts)-262 (to)-262 (release)-262 (the)-261 (meta-lock.)-262 (No)]TJ
-3.5558 -1.1667 TD
[(thread)-362 (in)-362 (the)-361 (sequence)-362 (may)-361 (obtain)-362 (the)-361 (meta-lock)-362 (before)-362 (its)-362 (predecessor)-361 (has)-362 (released)-361 (the)-362 (meta-)]TJ
T*
[(lock,)-301 (and)-301 (we)-301 (are)-301 (guaranteed)-301 (mutual)-301 (e)15 (xclusion,)-301 (pro)16 (vided)-301 (the)-300 (meta-lock)-301 (hand-of)25 (f)-301 (w)9 (orks)-300 (correctly)65 (.)]TJ
T*
[(T)80 (o)-314 (complete)-314 (the)-313 (ar)18 (gument,)-314 (we)-314 (shall)-313 (sho)25 (w)-314 (that)-313 (the)-314 (meta-lock)-314 (hand-of)25 (f)-314 (protocol)-313 (does)-314 (not)-314 (allo)25 (w)-314 (a)]TJ
T*
[(successor)-279 (thread)-278 (to)-279 (obtain)-278 (the)-278 (meta-lock)-279 (before)-278 (its)-278 (predecessor)-278 (has)-279 (released)-278 (the)-279 (meta-lock.)-278 (Thus,)]TJ
T*
[(consider)-289 (threads)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.855 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4892 0 TD
[(\(the)-290 (predecessor\))-289 (and)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.9208 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.49 0 TD
[(\(the)-289 (successor\))-290 (from)-289 (Case)-289 (2)-290 (abo)16 (v)15 (e\321that)-289 (is)-290 (to)-289 (say)65 (,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-18.755 -1.1667 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4408 0 TD
[(immediately)-241 (preceded)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.09 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4408 0 TD
[(in)-240 (the)-240 (atomic)-240 (sw)9 (ap)-240 (in)-241 (its)-240 (attempt)-241 (to)-240 (obtain)-241 (the)-240 (meta-lock.)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
22.8858 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4408 0 TD
[(ha)21 (ving)]TJ
-36.2983 -1.1667 TD
[(read)-271 (<)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.5558 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.5208 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(>)-270 (i)0 (s)-270 (forced)-271 (do)25 (wn)-270 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.5567 0 TD
(getMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.4708 0 TD
[(path.)-270 (The)-271 (\336rst)-271 (thing)-271 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.9925 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.47 0 TD
(does)Tj
-37.1667 -1.1667 TD
[(is)-365 (obtain)-365 (a)-365 (lock)-365 (on)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.1583 0 TD
(T0->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
[(,)-366 (and)-365 (check)-365 (if)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.0983 0 TD
(T0->bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.365 0 TD
[(is)-365 (set.)-366 (In)-365 (the)]TJ
-33.8217 -1.1667 TD
[(case)-228 (where)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.6208 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4283 0 TD
[(is)-228 (not)-229 (yet)-228 (ready)-228 (to)-229 (release)-228 (the)-228 (meta-lock,)-228 (this)-228 (\336eld)-229 (will)-228 (be)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
22.8758 0 TD
(FALSE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3 0 TD
[(,)-228 (and)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.15 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4283 0 TD
[(will)-229 (w)10 (ait)]TJ
-35.5033 -1.1667 TD
[(to)-466 (be)-467 (signalled)-466 (on)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.1992 0 TD
(T0->metaLockCondvar)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.8667 0 TD
(with)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.2442 0 TD
(T1->gotMetaLockSlow)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.8667 0 TD
[(set.)-466 (W)80 (e)-467 (are)]TJ
-34.1767 -1.1667 TD
[(ensured)-248 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.1067 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4483 0 TD
[(will)-248 (not)-248 (be)-248 (able)-248 (to)-248 (proceed)-248 (further)-248 (until)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.9275 0 TD
(T0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4483 0 TD
[(is)-248 (ready)-248 (to)-249 (release)-248 (the)-248 (meta-lock,)-248 (thus)]TJ
-23.9308 -1.1667 TD
[(ensuring mutual e)16 (xclusion.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 106.67 Tm
[(5.2  Fr)18 (eedom fr)18 (om lock)15 (out)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 82 Tm
[(T)80 (o)-329 (sho)25 (w)-329 (l)0 (i)25 (v)15 (eness,)-329 (we)-330 (assume)-328 (that)-329 (each)-329 (thread)-329 (that)-329 (obtains)-329 (the)-329 (meta-lock)-329 (e)26 (v)15 (entually)-330 (attempts)-328 (to)]TJ
T*
(release the meta-lock.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 18 18
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(15)Tj
-19 56.4858 TD
[(Consider)-252 (\336rst)-252 (the)-252 (case)-252 (where)-253 (a)-252 (thread)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.2625 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4525 0 TD
[(attempting)-252 (to)-253 (release)-252 (the)-252 (meta-lock)-252 (e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-252 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.455 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.0517 0 TD
(in)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-38.2217 -1.1667 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.4608 0 TD
[(and)-262 (disco)15 (v)15 (ers)-261 (that)-262 (the)-261 (header)-261 (w)10 (ord)-261 (compares)-261 (with)-261 (what)-261 (it)-261 (had)-261 (sw)10 (apped)]TJ
-10.4608 -1.1667 TD
[(in)-247 (when)-246 (it)-246 (had)-247 (obtained)-247 (the)-246 (meta-lock,)-247 (i.e.)-246 (with)-247 (<)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.6425 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
0 Tw
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.4967 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(>.)-247 (This)-247 (means)-247 (that)-247 (no)-247 (other)-247 (thread)-246 (has)]TJ
-23.7392 -1.1667 TD
[(attempted)-276 (to)-275 (obtain)-275 (the)-275 (meta-lock)-276 (since)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.1517 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.475 0 TD
[(did)-276 (so.)-275 (The)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.7992 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.075 0 TD
[(completes)-276 (and)-275 (a)-276 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.6033 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.675 0 TD
[(status)-276 (is)]TJ
-35.7792 -1.1667 TD
[(written into the header w)10 (ord, thus releasing the meta-lock.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(Consider)-265 (no)25 (w)-265 (the)-265 (case)-265 (where)-265 (another)-265 (thread)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
18.0483 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.465 0 TD
[(has)-265 (attempted)-265 (to)-265 (acquire)-265 (the)-265 (meta-lock.)-266 (W)81 (e)-265 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)]TJ
-19.5133 -1.1667 TD
[(already)-268 (ar)18 (gued)-267 (abo)15 (v)15 (e)-268 (\(Case)-267 (2)-268 (i)0 (n)-267 (Section)-267 (5.1)-267 (abo)15 (v)15 (e)0 (\))-268 (that)-267 (in)-267 (this)-267 (case)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
27.4225 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4675 0 TD
[(is)-267 (forced)-268 (do)25 (wn)-268 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7.71 0 TD
(get-)Tj
-36.6 -1.1667 TD
(MetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.7008 0 TD
[(path.)-300 (No)25 (w)64 (,)-301 (when)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7.1442 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5008 0 TD
[(attempts)-300 (to)-301 (release)-301 (the)-300 (meta-lock,)-300 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.44 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.1008 0 TD
[(w)10 (ould)-300 (f)10 (ail)]TJ
-34.8867 -1.1667 TD
[(because)-397 (the)-397 (header)-397 (w)9 (ord)-397 (contents)-397 (w)9 (ould)-397 (be)-397 (dif)24 (ferent)-397 (from)-397 (<)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
25.365 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.6467 0 TD
(BUSY)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(>)-398 (written)-397 (by)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.5892 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
0.397 Tc
[(.A)397 (sa)]TJ
-36.4008 -1.1667 TD
0 Tc
(result,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.8558 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5842 0 TD
[(w)10 (ould)-384 (no)25 (w)-384 (b)0 (e)-384 (forced)-384 (do)25 (wn)-384 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
13.4083 0 TD
(releaseMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12.9842 0 TD
[(path.)-385 (There)-384 (are)-384 (tw)10 (o)]TJ
-30.8325 -1.1667 TD
[(cases)-367 (to)-367 (consider)-367 (according)-367 (to)-367 (whether)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.4208 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5675 0 TD
(or)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5675 0 TD
[(succeed)-367 (in)-367 (locking)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.0442 0 TD
(T0->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-28.8 -1.1667 TD
[(\336rst,)-277 (respecti)25 (v)14 (ely)65 (,)-278 (i)0 (n)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.3942 0 TD
(releaseMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12.8775 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.7217 0 TD
(getMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2008 0 TD
[(.)-277 (But)-277 (\336rst)-278 (note)]TJ
-33.1942 -1.1667 TD
[(that)-474 (the)-475 (initial)-474 (conditions)-474 (ensure)-475 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
16.18 0 TD
(T1->bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9 0 TD
(,)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.7242 0 TD
(T2->gotMetaLockSlow)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.875 0 TD
(are)Tj
-37.7792 -1.1667 TD
(both)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.0283 0 TD
(FALSE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3 0 TD
( initially and that)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
7.0558 0 TD
(T1->succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6 0 TD
( is)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.1667 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
(.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
-21.6508 -1.75 TD
[(Case)-301 (1:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 113.21 502 Tm
(T1)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 131.22 502 Tm
[(loc)20 (ks)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 159.24 502 Tm
(T1->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 285.25 502 Tm
[(\336r)10 (st)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
1.5458 0 TD
[(.)-301 (I)0 (n)-300 (this)-301 (case,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.7017 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5 0 TD
[(will)-301 (\336nd)-301 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.5142 0 TD
(T1->succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.3008 0 TD
(is)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-38.3333 -1.1667 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(,)-374 (s)0 (o)-374 (i)0 (t)-374 (will)-374 (tak)10 (e)-374 (the)-375 (else)-374 (branch)-374 (in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.5508 0 TD
(releaseMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12.6 0 TD
[(,)-374 (write)-374 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.6492 0 TD
(release-)Tj
-34.2 -1.1667 TD
(Bits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.61 0 TD
(into)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.7658 0 TD
(T1->metaLockBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.6 0 TD
[(,)-210 (set)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
1.7808 0 TD
(T1->bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.21 0 TD
(to)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.9875 0 TD
(TRUE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(,)-210 (and)-210 (w)10 (ait)-210 (on)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.2458 0 TD
(T1->meta-)Tj
-33.6 -1.1667 TD
(LockCondvar)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.0217 0 TD
(\(releasing)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
4.3642 0 TD
(T1->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
[(\))-421 (for)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.3408 0 TD
(T1->bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.4217 0 TD
[(to)-421 (be)-421 (reset)-421 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-33.3483 -1.1667 TD
(FALSE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3 0 TD
[(.)-295 (Subsequently)65 (,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
6.4133 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.495 0 TD
[(will)-295 (succeed)-295 (in)-294 (locking)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
9.6783 0 TD
(T1->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
[(,)-295 (and)-295 (will)-295 (tak)10 (e)-295 (the)-295 (if)]TJ
-30.7867 -1.1667 TD
[(branch)-692 (in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.8833 0 TD
(getMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.8925 0 TD
(since)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.7467 0 TD
(T1->bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.6925 0 TD
[(is)-692 (set;)-692 (it)-692 (will)-692 (cop)10 (y)-693 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-28.215 -1.1667 TD
(releaseBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.6 0 TD
[(,)-368 (reset)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.875 0 TD
(T1->bitsForGrab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9 0 TD
[(,)-368 (signal)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.3758 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5683 0 TD
[(to)-369 (w)9 (a)0 (k)11 (e)-368 (up,)-369 (and)-368 (release)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.1808 0 TD
(T1->meta-)Tj
-33.6 -1.1667 TD
(LockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.4 0 TD
[( allo)25 (wing)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.975 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
( to continue. At this point)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
10.4733 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(, w)10 (ould ha)20 (v)15 (e)0 ( the meta-lock.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
-22.2483 -1.75 TD
[(Case)-282 (2:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 112.78 383 Tm
(T2)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 130.57 383 Tm
[(loc)20 (ks)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12 0 2.551 12 158.38 383 Tm
(T1->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 284.18 383 Tm
[(\336r)10 (st)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
1.5458 0 TD
[(.)-282 (I)0 (n)-283 (this)-282 (case,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.63 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4825 0 TD
[(will)-282 (\336nd)-283 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.46 0 TD
(T1->bitsFor-)Tj
-31.8 -1.1667 TD
(Grab)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6433 0 TD
(is)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.9108 0 TD
(FALSE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3 0 TD
[(,)-243 (s)0 (o)-244 (i)0 (t)-243 (will)-244 (tak)10 (e)-243 (the)-244 (else)-244 (branch)-243 (in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
13.3758 0 TD
(getMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
[(,)-243 (set)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
1.8483 0 TD
(T1->succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.2433 0 TD
(to)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-38.2217 -1.1667 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-194 (and)-193 (w)9 (ait)-194 (on)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.1817 0 TD
(T1->metaLockCondvar)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.5942 0 TD
(\(releasing)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
4.1375 0 TD
(T1->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
[(\))-194 (for)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
1.8867 0 TD
(T2->got-)Tj
-34.2 -1.1667 TD
(MetaLockSlow)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.5467 0 TD
[(to)-346 (be)-347 (set)-346 (by)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.2192 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(.)-347 (When)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.3308 0 TD
(T1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5467 0 TD
[(subsequently)-346 (obtains)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.8042 0 TD
(T1->metaLockMutex)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
0.347 Tc
[(,i)347 (t)]TJ
-37.8475 -1.1667 TD
0 Tc
[(will)-265 (\336nd)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.6417 0 TD
(T1->succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.265 0 TD
[(set)-266 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.4192 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
[(,)-265 (s)0 (o)-265 (i)0 (t)-265 (will)-265 (tak)10 (e)-265 (the)-265 (if)-265 (branch)-265 (in)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12.6242 0 TD
(releaseMetaLockSlow\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12.6 0 TD
(,)Tj
-38.75 -1.1667 TD
[(write)-311 (out)-311 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.4875 0 TD
(releaseBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.9108 0 TD
(into)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.8675 0 TD
(T2->metaLockBits)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
9.6 0 TD
[(,)-311 (and)-311 (reset)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.5142 0 TD
(T1->succEE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.3108 0 TD
[(before)-311 (set-)]TJ
-34.6908 -1.1667 TD
(ting)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.8792 0 TD
(T2->gotMetaLockSlow)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.7225 0 TD
(to)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.1008 0 TD
(TRUE)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.7233 0 TD
[(and)-323 (signal)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.4783 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5225 0 TD
[(that)-323 (it)-322 (has)-323 (been)-323 (handed)-323 (the)-323 (meta-lock,)]TJ
-23.4267 -1.1667 TD
[(allo)25 (wing)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
3.725 0 TD
(T2)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.2 0 TD
( to continue with the meta-lock.)Tj
-4.925 -1.75 TD
[(Thus,)-387 (e)25 (v)15 (ery)-387 (thread)-387 (that)-387 (attempts)-387 (to)-387 (obtain)-387 (the)-386 (meta-lock)-387 (will)-386 (e)25 (v)15 (entually)-386 (obtain)-387 (the)-387 (meta-lock,)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(ensuring freedom from lock)11 (out.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 215.33 Tm
(6  Extensions to the basic algorithm)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 192 Tm
[(In)-239 (this)-238 (section,)-238 (we)-239 (discuss)-238 (e)16 (xtensions)-238 (to)-239 (our)-238 (algorithm,)-238 (related)-239 (to)-238 (management)-238 (of)-239 (lock)-238 (records)-239 (and)]TJ
T*
[(optimization)-250 (of)-249 (cases)-249 (where)-249 (we)-250 (may)-249 (safely)-249 (a)20 (v)20 (oid)-249 (meta-locking)-249 (because)-249 (the)-250 (change)-250 (in)-249 (the)-250 (object\325)55 (s)]TJ
T*
[(lock)-450 (state)-450 (requires)-450 (only)-449 (one)-450 (w)10 (ord)-449 (to)-450 (be)-449 (updated.)-450 (W)80 (e)-450 (also)-450 (demonstrate)-450 (the)-450 (\337e)15 (xibility)-450 (of)-449 (our)]TJ
T*
[(approach)-231 (and)-230 (outline)-230 (ho)25 (w)-231 (t)0 (o)-230 (implement)-231 (it)-230 (on)-231 (hardw)10 (are)-231 (that)-230 (does)-230 (not)-231 (pro)16 (vide)-230 (atomic)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
33.5058 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.0308 0 TD
(or)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.0633 0 TD
(SWAP)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-36.6 -1.1667 TD
(operations.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 19 19
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(16)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 710.67 Tm
0 Tw
[(6.1  Lock r)18 (ecord allocation)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 686 Tm
[(As)-273 (we)-272 (discussed)-273 (in)-273 (Section)-272 (3,)-272 (each)-273 (of)-273 (the)-273 (locking)-272 (schemes)-273 (we)-272 (kno)25 (w)-273 (about,)-273 (including)-273 (the)-272 (present)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(one,)-302 (at)-301 (least)-301 (occasionally)-302 (allocates)-302 (data)-301 (structures)-301 (related)-301 (to)-302 (locking.)-301 (This)-301 (section)-301 (discusses)-302 (ho)25 (w)]TJ
T*
[(those)-270 (data)-270 (structures)-270 (are)-270 (allocated)-270 (and)-269 (deallocated.)-270 (The)-270 (original)-270 (JDK)-270 (allocates)-269 (monitors)-270 (globally)65 (,)]TJ
T*
[(causing)-353 (serialization)-353 (of)-354 (monitor)-353 (cache)-354 (operations)-353 (and)-353 (resulting)-353 (scalability)-354 (bottlenecks.)-353 (Periodi-)]TJ
T*
[(cally)65 (,)-262 (unused)-261 (monitors)-262 (are)-261 (reclaimed.)-261 (The)-262 (thin)-261 (locks)-261 (scheme)-262 (globally)-262 (allocates)-261 (\322f)10 (at)-261 (locks,)70 (\323)-262 (which)]TJ
T*
(remain allocated for the lifetime of the associated object [3].)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(In)-258 (our)-258 (scheme,)-257 (lock)-258 (records)-258 (are)-258 (the)-257 (unit)-258 (of)-258 (allocation.)-257 (Each)-258 (thread)-258 (has)-258 (a)-258 (set)-258 (of)-257 (lock)-258 (records)-258 (for)-258 (its)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(e)15 (xclusi)25 (v)15 (e)-235 (use,)-234 (link)9 (ed)-235 (together)-234 (in)-235 (a)-235 (free)-235 (list.)-235 (Lock)-236 (records)-234 (on)-236 (a)-235 (thread\325)55 (s)-235 (free)-235 (list)-235 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-235 (as)-235 (man)15 (y)-236 (\336elds)]TJ
T*
[(as)-266 (possible)-267 (preinitialized:)-266 (the)-266 (o)25 (wner)-266 (\336eld)-267 (points)-266 (to)-267 (the)-266 (o)25 (wning)-267 (thread,)-266 (the)-266 (count)-267 (\336elds)-266 (contains)-266 (1,)]TJ
T*
[(which)-435 (is)-435 (the)-435 (proper)-435 (count)-435 (when)-435 (locks)-435 (are)-435 (\336rst)-435 (acquired,)-435 (and)-434 (the)-435 (queue)-434 (\336eld)-434 (contains)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36.6 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-36.6 -1.1667 TD
[(because)-268 (uncontended)-268 (locking)-268 (is)-268 (most)-268 (frequent)-269 (\(separation)-268 (of)-268 (the)-269 (free-list)-268 (link)-268 (and)-268 (the)-268 (queue)-269 (link,)]TJ
T*
[(see)-267 (Figure)-250 (4,)-267 (allo)25 (ws)-266 (the)-267 (queue)-267 (\336eld)-266 (to)-267 (be)-267 (preset)-267 (to)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
20.4183 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(\).)-267 (Lock)-267 (record)-267 (allocation)-267 (is)-266 (optimized)-266 (to)]TJ
-22.8183 -1.1667 TD
[(a)20 (v)20 (oid)-234 (an)16 (y)-234 (test)-233 (for)-233 (an)-233 (empty)-233 (free)-233 (list;)-234 (instead,)-233 (an)-233 (attempt)-233 (to)-234 (dereference)-233 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
28.8467 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6333 0 TD
[(pointer)-234 (generates)-233 (a)]TJ
-31.48 -1.1667 TD
[(signal.)-343 (The)-344 (signal)-343 (handler)-343 (recognizes)-344 (the)-344 (situation,)-343 (re\336lls)-344 (the)-344 (thread\325)55 (s)-344 (lock)-344 (record)-343 (free)-343 (list,)-344 (and)]TJ
T*
[(retries)-317 (the)-317 (operation.)-318 (Threads)-316 (start)-317 (with)-318 (8)-317 (free)-318 (lock)-317 (records)-317 (and)-318 (add)-317 (an)-318 (e)16 (xponentially)-317 (increasing)]TJ
T*
[(number each time the)16 (y e)15 (xhaust the free list.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(When)-273 (a)-274 (thread)-273 (unlocks)-273 (an)-273 (object,)-273 (the)-273 (lock)-273 (record)-273 (used)-274 (by)-273 (the)-273 (thread)-273 (to)-273 (accomplish)-273 (the)-274 (locking)-272 (is)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(returned)-233 (to)-234 (the)-233 (thread\325)55 (s)-233 (free)-233 (list.)-234 (In)-233 (our)-233 (current)-233 (implementation,)-233 (the)-233 (set)-233 (of)-233 (lock)-233 (records)-234 (allocated)-232 (to)]TJ
T*
[(a)-234 (g)0 (i)25 (v)15 (en)-235 (thread)-234 (only)-234 (gro)25 (ws;)-235 (there)-234 (is)-235 (no)-235 (pro)15 (vision)-234 (for)-235 (remo)15 (ving)-234 (lock)-235 (records)-234 (from)-234 (a)-235 (thread\325)55 (s)-235 (free)-234 (list)]TJ
T*
[(if)-264 (the)-264 (thread)-263 (brie\337y)-264 (locks)-264 (man)15 (y)-264 (objects,)-264 (b)21 (u)0 (t)-264 (usually)-263 (locks)-264 (fe)25 (w)65 (.)-263 (This)-264 (is)-264 (not)-264 (so)-264 (bad;)-264 (the)-264 (\322high)-264 (w)10 (ater)]TJ
T*
[(mark\323)-321 (of)-320 (allocated)-321 (lock)-320 (records)-321 (is)-320 (limited)-320 (by)-321 (the)-321 (product)-320 (of)-321 (the)-320 (thread)-321 (stack)-321 (size)-321 (and)-320 (the)-320 (maxi-)]TJ
T*
[(mum)-245 (le)15 (xical)-245 (nesting)-245 (depth)-245 (of)-245 (synchronized)-244 (statements)-245 (\(at)-245 (least)-245 (for)-246 (bytecode)-245 (created)-245 (by)-245 (compiling)]TJ
T*
[(Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-373 (language)-373 (source)-372 (code,)-374 (as)-373 (discussed)-373 (in)-373 (Section)-373 (2.2\).)-374 (If)-372 (we)-373 (wished)-374 (to)-373 (add)-373 (a)-374 (mechanism)-372 (to)]TJ
T*
[(return)-238 (lock)-239 (records)-238 (on)-238 (free)-238 (lists)-238 (to)-238 (the)-238 (global)-238 (memory)-238 (pool,)-238 (it)-238 (w)9 (ould)-238 (be)-238 (a)-238 (simple)-239 (matter)-237 (to)-239 (do)-238 (so)-238 (as)]TJ
T*
[(part)-257 (of)-257 (garbage)-257 (collection,)-257 (as)-258 (long)-257 (as)-258 (we)-257 (can)-258 (guarantee)-257 (that)-257 (no)-257 (thread)-258 (is)-257 (accessing)-257 (the)-258 (lock)-257 (record)]TJ
T*
[(free)-261 (list)-262 (during)-261 (garbage)-262 (collection.)-261 (Our)-262 (system)-261 (has)-261 (a)-261 (general)-261 (mechanism)-261 (for)-261 (restricting)-261 (when)-261 (gar-)]TJ
T*
[(bage collection occurs that can be used to pro)16 (vide this guarantee.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 275.67 Tm
(6.2  Extra fast locking and unlocking of uncontended objects)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 251 Tm
[(W)80 (e)-238 (can)-238 (optimize)-238 (the)-238 (algorithm)-238 (further)-238 (in)-239 (the)-238 (case)-238 (of)-239 (uncontended)-238 (objects.)-238 (This)-239 (optimization)-238 (fuses)]TJ
T*
[(the)-390 (meta-lock)-389 (and)-389 (monitor)21 (-lock)-390 (operations)-389 (into)-390 (a)-389 (single)-389 (step.)-390 (W)40 (ith)-389 (this)-390 (optimization,)-389 (a)-389 (thread)]TJ
T*
[(attempting)-293 (to)-294 (lock)-293 (an)-294 (object)-293 (reads)-293 (the)-294 (object\325)55 (s)-293 (multi-use)-293 (w)10 (ord.)-294 (If)-294 (the)-293 (object\325)55 (s)-293 (lock)-293 (state)-294 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
36.6 0 TD
(NEU-)Tj
-36.6 -1.1667 TD
(TRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(,)-276 (then)-276 (an)-276 (\322e)16 (xtra)-277 (f)11 (ast\323)-276 (path)-276 (is)-276 (tried.)-275 (The)-277 (thread)-276 (copies)-276 (the)-275 (hash)-276 (and)-276 (age)-276 (bits)-276 (into)-276 (a)-276 (fresh)-276 (lock)]TJ
-2.4 -1.1667 TD
[(record)-233 (and)-233 (b)20 (uilds)-234 (a)-233 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-234 (multi-use)-233 (v)25 (alue)-233 (containing)-234 (the)-234 (lock)-234 (record)-233 (address)-233 (and)-233 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
33.0833 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8333 0 TD
(state.)Tj
-36.9167 -1.1667 TD
(A)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
0.99 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.0675 0 TD
[(instruction)-268 (is)-268 (then)-267 (used)-268 (to)-268 (atomically)-267 (change)-268 (the)-268 (multi-use)-268 (w)10 (ord)-268 (to)-268 (the)-268 (ne)26 (w)-268 (v)25 (alue)-268 (if)-267 (it)-267 (has)]TJ
-3.0575 -1.1667 TD
[(not)-279 (changed)-279 (since)-280 (it)-280 (w)10 (a)0 (s)-280 (read.)-280 (If)-280 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.8633 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.08 0 TD
[(succeeds,)-279 (then)-280 (the)-280 (object)-280 (is)-280 (lock)10 (ed;)-280 (otherwise,)-280 (the)-280 (nor-)]TJ
-16.9433 -1.1667 TD
[(mal)-249 (meta-locking)-249 (protocol)-248 (is)-250 (used.)-249 (W)40 (ith)-249 (this)-249 (optimization,)-249 (the)-249 (e)15 (xtra)-248 (f)10 (ast)-249 (path)-249 (for)-249 (locking)-249 (uses)-249 (one)]TJ
T*
[(atomic)-292 (instruction)-291 (rather)-292 (than)-292 (the)-291 (tw)10 (o)-292 (needed)-292 (for)-291 (meta-locking)-292 (and)-292 (meta-unlocking)-292 (and)-292 (the)-291 (total)]TJ
T*
[(number of instructions is smaller \(15 SP)93 (ARC\252 instructions\).)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(A)-287 (similar)-287 (e)15 (xtra)-287 (f)10 (ast)-286 (path)-287 (for)-287 (unlocking)-286 (is)-287 (slightly)-286 (more)-287 (complicated.)-287 (When)-287 (the)-287 (e)16 (xtra)-287 (f)11 (ast)-287 (locking)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(path)-230 (succeeds,)-230 (the)-230 (only)-229 (lock)-230 (record)-229 (in)-230 (its)-229 (queue)-230 (is)-230 (that)-230 (of)-229 (the)-230 (locking)-229 (thread;)-230 (the)-230 (queue)-229 (\336eld)-230 (of)-229 (that)]TJ
T*
[(lock)-225 (record)-225 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
5.6192 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-225 (Another)-225 (thread)-225 (may)-225 (add)-225 (a)-225 (lock)-225 (record)-225 (to)-225 (the)-225 (queue,)-226 (changing)-225 (this)-225 (queue)-225 (\336eld)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 20 20
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(17)Tj
-19 56.4858 TD
[(at)-331 (an)15 (y)-332 (time.)-331 (So)-331 (the)-331 (e)15 (xtra)-332 (f)10 (ast)-331 (unlocking)-331 (path)-332 (must)-331 (atomically)-332 (change)-331 (the)-331 (multi-use)-331 (w)9 (ord)-331 (of)-332 (the)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(object)-363 (back)-362 (to)-363 (its)-362 (original)-362 (contents,)-363 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-363 (only)-362 (if)-362 (the)-363 (queue)-363 (\336eld)-362 (of)-363 (the)-362 (\336rst)-362 (lock)-363 (record)-363 (remains)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
T*
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-258 (Unfortunately)65 (,)-259 (this)-258 (\322double-compare-and-sw)10 (ap\323)-258 (operation)-259 (is)-259 (not)-259 (supported)-258 (in)-259 (man)15 (y)-259 (archi-)]TJ
-2.4 -1.1667 TD
[(tectures)-266 (\(though)-265 (it)-266 (is)-265 (not)-265 (completely)-266 (unheard)-266 (of;)-265 (see)-265 ([10]\).)-266 (T)80 (o)-266 (get)-265 (around)-265 (this,)-265 (we)-266 (add)-265 (a)-266 (n)0 (e)25 (w)-265 (con-)]TJ
T*
[(straint)-322 (to)-322 (the)-322 (slo)25 (w)-322 (path.)-322 (W)80 (e)-323 (require)-322 (that)-322 (lock)-322 (records)-323 (be)-322 (allocated)-322 (with)-322 (eight-byte)-321 (alignment,)-322 (so)]TJ
T*
[(that)-229 (three)-229 (bits)-228 (are)-230 (zero)-229 (in)-229 (the)-230 (address)-228 (of)-229 (a)-228 (lock)-230 (record.)-228 (In)-229 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
23.95 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8292 0 TD
[(state,)-229 (this)-229 (e)16 (xtra)-229 (bit)-230 (is)-229 (used)-229 (to)]TJ
-27.7792 -1.1667 TD
[(summarize)-243 (the)-243 (state)-242 (of)-243 (the)-243 (queue)-243 (\336eld)-243 (of)-243 (the)-243 (\336rst)-242 (lock)-243 (record:)-243 (we)-242 (maintain)-242 (the)-243 (in)40 (v)25 (ariant)-242 (that)-243 (when)]TJ
T*
[(the)-307 (bit)-307 (is)-307 (0,)-307 (the)-307 (queue)-307 (\336eld)-307 (is)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12.2075 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-308 (I)0 (f)-307 (the)-307 (bit)-307 (is)-307 (1,)-307 (the)-307 (queue)-307 (may)-307 (be)-308 (non-)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.7925 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
[(.)-307 (Thus,)-307 (the)-307 (\336rst)]TJ
-32.8 -1.1667 TD
[(thread)-303 (to)-303 (enqueue)-303 (a)-303 (lock)-302 (record)-303 (after)-303 (the)-302 (initial)-303 (one)-303 (is)-303 (required)-303 (to)-303 (set)-302 (this)-303 (bit)-303 (when)-302 (releasing)-303 (the)]TJ
T*
[(meta-lock.)-247 (Once)-247 (this)-247 (in)40 (v)25 (ariant)-247 (may)-247 (be)-248 (assumed,)-247 (we)-247 (can)-248 (construct)-247 (an)-247 (e)15 (xtra)-247 (f)10 (ast)-247 (unlock)-247 (path:)-247 (check)]TJ
T*
[(the)-261 (locking)-262 (depth,)-261 (decrementing)-262 (it)-261 (and)-261 (returning)-262 (if)-261 (it)-261 (is)-261 (greater)-261 (than)-261 (one.)-262 (Otherwise,)-261 (construct)-262 (the)]TJ
T*
[(e)15 (xpected)-357 (current)-357 (v)25 (alue)-357 (of)-358 (the)-357 (multi-use)-358 (w)10 (ord)-358 (\(pointer)-357 (to)-357 (same)-357 (lock)-358 (record,)-357 (queue)-358 (\336eld)-358 (bit)-357 (still)]TJ
T*
[(clear)40 (,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.5008 0 TD
(LOCKED)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.9475 0 TD
[(state\),)-347 (and)-348 (the)-347 (desired)-348 (ne)25 (w)-347 (v)25 (alue)-347 (\(original)-347 (multi-use)-348 (bits,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
23.7967 0 TD
(NEUTRAL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.5475 0 TD
[(state\),)-347 (and)]TJ
-34.7925 -1.1667 TD
[(perform)-257 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
4.1792 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.0575 0 TD
[(instruction)-257 (to)-257 (write)-257 (the)-257 (ne)25 (w)-257 (v)25 (alue)-257 (if)-256 (the)-257 (current)-257 (v)25 (alue)-257 (is)-257 (still)-257 (the)-257 (e)15 (xpected)-257 (v)25 (alue.)-257 (If)]TJ
-6.2367 -1.1667 TD
[(no)-332 (other)-331 (thread)-332 (has)-331 (enqueued)-331 (a)-332 (lock)-331 (record,)-331 (then)-331 (the)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
21.9467 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.1317 0 TD
[(succeeds)-331 (and)-332 (the)-331 (object)-331 (is)-331 (unlock)10 (ed;)]TJ
-24.0783 -1.1667 TD
[(otherwise,)-316 (we)-316 (re)25 (v)15 (ert)-316 (to)-316 (the)-315 (normal)-316 (meta-locking)-315 (protocol.)-316 (If)-316 (recursi)25 (v)15 (e)-316 (locking)-316 (were)-316 (found)-315 (to)-316 (be)]TJ
T*
[(v)15 (ery)-231 (rare,)-231 (this)-232 (proposal)-231 (could)-231 (be)-231 (e)15 (xtended)-231 (to)-231 (also)-231 (summarize)-231 (the)-231 (lock)-231 (count)-231 (in)-231 (the)-231 (e)16 (xtra)-232 (bit,)-231 (so)-231 (that)]TJ
T*
[(a)-236 (zero)-236 (bit)-236 (observ)14 (ed)-236 (by)-236 (an)-235 (unlocking)-236 (thread)-236 (implied)-236 (both)-235 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
23.1317 0 TD
(NULL)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6358 0 TD
[(queue)-236 (\336eld)-236 (and)-235 (a)-236 (lock)-236 (count)-235 (of)-236 (1,)]TJ
-25.7675 -1.1667 TD
0 Tw
[(eliminating the e)16 (xplicit test for recursion.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-287 (instruction)-286 (count)-286 (of)-286 (the)-287 (e)16 (xtra)-287 (f)10 (ast)-286 (unlocking)-286 (sequence)-286 (is)-286 (similar)-287 (to)-286 (that)-287 (of)-286 (e)15 (xtra)-287 (f)10 (ast)-286 (locking,)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(and)-376 (both)-376 (use)-376 (a)-376 (single)-376 (atomic)-376 (instruction.)-376 (The)-376 (thin)-376 (locks)-376 (scheme)-376 (uses)-376 (no)-376 (atomic)-376 (instruction)-375 (in)]TJ
T*
[(unlocking,)-300 (b)20 (ut,)-299 (as)-299 (we)-300 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-299 (discussed,)-299 (pays)-299 (for)-300 (that)-300 (lack)-300 (with)-299 (the)-300 (possibility)-299 (of)-299 (unbounded)-300 (b)20 (usy-)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (aiting.)-284 (W)80 (e)-284 (feel)-285 (that)-284 (in)-284 (man)15 (y)-285 (situations)-284 (the)-285 (trade-of)25 (fs)-285 (made)-284 (in)-284 (our)-284 (algorithm)-284 (will)-285 (be)-284 (more)-285 (desir-)]TJ
T*
(able.)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 350.67 Tm
(6.3  Flexibility)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 326 Tm
[(One)-346 (of)-346 (the)-345 (main)-346 (adv)25 (antages)-345 (we)-346 (ha)20 (v)16 (e)-346 (claimed)-346 (for)-346 (the)-345 (meta-locking)-345 (approach)-346 (is)-345 (\337e)15 (xibility)65 (.)-346 (This)]TJ
T*
[(\337e)15 (xibility)-309 (results)-309 (from)-309 (the)-309 (f)10 (act)-309 (that)-309 (we)-309 (place)-309 (fe)25 (w)-310 (constraints)-308 (on)-309 (the)-310 (nature)-308 (of)-309 (the)-309 (data)-309 (structures)]TJ
T*
[(protected)-289 (by)-289 (the)-290 (meta-lock.)-288 (Speci\336cally)65 (,)-289 (i)0 (t)-289 (enables)-289 (separation)-289 (of)-289 (mechanism)-289 (and)-289 (polic)15 (y)65 (,)-289 (to)-289 (allo)25 (w)]TJ
T*
[(implementation of a v)26 (ariety of monitor semantics.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(W)80 (e)-301 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-302 (tested)-301 (this)-302 (\337e)15 (xibility)-302 (claim)-301 (to)-301 (some)-301 (e)15 (xtent)-302 (in)-301 (an)-302 (attempt)-302 (to)-301 (address)-302 (tw)10 (o)-302 (potential)-301 (short-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(comings)-459 (of)-459 (our)-459 (simple)-460 (link)10 (ed-list)-459 (data)-459 (structure:)-459 (lack)-459 (of)-459 (f)11 (airness)-460 (and)-459 (long)-459 (searches)-459 (through)]TJ
T*
[(queues.)-232 (First,)-232 (consider)-233 (f)11 (airness.)-232 (Moti)25 (v)25 (ated)-232 (by)-232 (Buhr)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
20.535 0 TD
[(et)-233 (al.,)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
2.465 0 TD
[(who)-232 (classify)-232 (and)-233 (compare)-232 (a)-233 (spectrum)-231 (of)]TJ
-23 -1.1667 TD
[(monitor)-399 (\322styles\323)-399 (that)-399 (of)25 (fer)-399 (dif)25 (ferent)-400 (trade-of)25 (fs)-399 (between)-399 (performance)-399 (and)-399 (f)11 (airness)-400 ([7],)-399 (we)-400 (pro-)]TJ
T*
[(grammed)-338 (a)-338 (v)15 (ersion)-338 (that)-338 (gi)26 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-339 (preference)-338 (to)-338 (a)15 (w)10 (ak)10 (ened)-339 (w)10 (aiters)-338 (\(so-called)-338 (\322priority)-337 (non-blocking)]TJ
T*
[(monitors\323\).)-309 (T)80 (o)-309 (pro)16 (vide)-310 (this)-309 (preference,)-309 (we)-309 (replaced)-309 (the)-309 (single)-309 (queue)-309 (with)-309 (three)-309 (queues,)-309 (holding)]TJ
T*
[(entering,)-294 (w)10 (aiting,)-294 (and)-293 (a)15 (w)10 (ak)10 (ened)-294 (threads,)-293 (respecti)25 (v)15 (ely)65 (.)-293 (N)0 (o)25 (w)-294 (it)-294 (is)-294 (possible)-293 (to)-294 (\336nd)-293 (and)-293 (gi)25 (v)15 (e)-293 (prefer-)]TJ
T*
[(ence)-263 (to)-262 (a)15 (w)9 (ak)11 (ened)-263 (w)9 (aiters)-262 (without)-262 (searching.)-263 (Similarly)65 (,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
22.3358 0 TD
(notify\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.0625 0 TD
[(can)-263 (e)15 (x)15 (ecute)-262 (in)-263 (constant)-262 (time,)]TJ
-27.3983 -1.1667 TD
[(by)-278 (mo)15 (ving)-279 (the)-278 (\336rst)-279 (thread)-278 (from)-278 (the)-279 (w)10 (aiting)-279 (queue)-279 (to)-278 (the)-279 (a)15 (w)10 (ak)10 (ened)-279 (queue.)-279 (Second,)-278 (consider)-278 (con-)]TJ
T*
[(tention.)-270 (T)79 (o)-271 (allo)25 (w)-270 (threads)-271 (to)-270 (append)-270 (lock)-271 (records)-270 (to)-271 (queues)-270 (without)-270 (ha)20 (ving)-271 (to)-270 (search)-271 (to)-270 (the)-271 (end)-270 (of)]TJ
T*
[(the)-272 (queue,)-273 (a)-272 (search)-273 (which)-272 (could)-272 (become)-272 (costly)-273 (if)-272 (queues)-272 (get)-272 (long,)-272 (we)-272 (k)10 (ept)-272 (head)-273 (and)-272 (tail)-272 (pointers)]TJ
T*
[(for)-367 (each)-367 (of)-368 (the)-367 (three)-367 (queues.)-368 (T)80 (ail)-367 (pointers)-367 (also)-367 (allo)25 (w)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
22.3133 0 TD
(notifyAll\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.9675 0 TD
[(to)-367 (run)-368 (in)-367 (constant)-367 (time,)]TJ
-29.2808 -1.1667 TD
[(re)15 (gardless)-305 (of)-304 (the)-305 (number)-305 (of)-304 (threads)-305 (w)10 (aiting,)-305 (via)-305 (list)-305 (concatenation.)-305 (While)-305 (this)-305 (alternati)26 (v)15 (e)-305 (imple-)]TJ
T*
[(mentation)-286 (w)9 (a)0 (s)-287 (straightforw)11 (ard,)-287 (performance)-287 (turned)-287 (out)-287 (to)-287 (be)-287 (inferior)-287 (to)-287 (our)-287 (single-queue)-286 (system)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 21 21
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(18)Tj
-19 56.4858 TD
[(because)-349 (greater)-349 (f)11 (airness)-350 (incurs)-348 (a)-349 (higher)-349 (conte)15 (xt)-349 (switch)-349 (rate)-349 (and)-348 (the)-350 (three-queue)-348 (data)-349 (structures)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
0 Tw
[(were more hea)20 (vyweight.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 665.67 Tm
[(6.4  Hard)15 (war)18 (e without)]TJ
/N98 1 Tf
9.8829 0 TD
(SWAP)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
2.4 0 TD
( or)Tj
/N98 1 Tf
1.4443 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 641 Tm
[(The)-230 (meta-lock)-229 (algorithm)-230 (relies)-230 (on)-230 (tw)10 (o)-230 (\322)0 (e)16 (xotic\323)-230 (atomic)-230 (operations:)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
26.6508 0 TD
(SWAP)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.63 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.6733 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(.)-230 (First,)-230 (note)-230 (that)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
-32.7542 -1.1667 TD
(SWAP)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.6483 0 TD
[(is)-248 (easily)-249 (simulated)-248 (using)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
10.0492 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(:)-249 (repeatedly)-247 (read)-249 (the)-248 (memory)-248 (location)-249 (and)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
17.1233 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.0475 0 TD
[(until)-248 (success.)]TJ
-33.6683 -1.1667 TD
(The)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.9692 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.2142 0 TD
[(operation,)-414 (or)-414 (some)-414 (other)-414 (suf)25 (\336ciently)-413 (po)25 (werful)-414 (primiti)25 (v)15 (e)-414 (such)-414 (as)-414 (\322load-lock)10 (ed/store-)]TJ
-4.1833 -1.1667 TD
[(conditional,)70 (\323)-423 (seem)-422 (to)-423 (be)-422 (a)20 (v)25 (ailable)-423 (on)-422 (most)-422 (modern)-422 (architectures,)-422 (including)-422 (mainstream)-422 (Intel,)]TJ
T*
[(UltraSP)92 (ARC\252, Po)26 (werPC, and Alpha microprocessors.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-296 (JVM)-296 (in)-295 (which)-296 (we)-296 (implemented)-296 (our)-295 (synchronization)-296 (must)-296 (run)-295 (on)-296 (the)-296 (pre)25 (vious)-295 (generation)-295 (of)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(SP)92 (ARC)-314 (processors,)-314 (which)-314 (has)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12.58 0 TD
(SWAP)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.7142 0 TD
[(b)20 (u)0 (t)-314 (does)-314 (not)-314 (ha)20 (v)16 (e)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
7.4783 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(.)-314 (While)-314 (correctness)-313 (cannot)-314 (be)-314 (com-)]TJ
-24.5725 -1.1667 TD
[(promised,)-251 (it)-251 (w)10 (a)0 (s)-251 (deemed)-251 (acceptable)-251 (to)-251 (trade)-252 (a)16 (w)9 (ay)-251 (some)-251 (performance)-251 (and)-251 (scalability)-250 (on)-252 (this)-251 (older)]TJ
T*
[(hardw)10 (are.)-322 (W)80 (e)-323 (\336rst)-323 (dropped)-322 (the)-323 (e)15 (xtra)-322 (f)10 (ast)-322 (synchronization)-322 (optimization)-323 (because)-322 (it)-323 (relies)-322 (directly)]TJ
T*
(on)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.2633 0 TD
(CAS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(.)-263 (N)0 (e)15 (xt,)-263 (we)-263 (modi\336ed)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.2033 0 TD
(getMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.0633 0 TD
[(to)-263 (use)-264 (a)-263 (test-and-set)-263 (protocol)-263 (\(where)-263 (\322set\323)-263 (means)]TJ
-19.33 -1.1667 TD
[(sw)10 (apping)-311 (out)-311 (the)-311 (lock)10 (ed)-311 (v)25 (alue)-311 (1)-312 (and)-311 (\322test\323)-311 (means)-312 (obtaining)-311 (a)-311 (non-lock)10 (ed)-312 (v)25 (alue\).)-311 (When)-311 (the)-311 (test)]TJ
T*
[(f)10 (ails,)-368 (the)-370 (thread)-369 (yields)-369 (and)-369 (optionally)-369 (sleeps)-369 (\(using)-369 (e)16 (xponential)-369 (back-of)25 (f)-369 (a)0 (s)-369 (i)0 (n)-369 ([1]\).)-369 (The)-369 (corre-)]TJ
T*
(sponding)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
3.945 0 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.4775 0 TD
[(operation)-277 (simply)-278 (stores)-278 (back)-278 (the)-277 (release)-277 (bit)-278 (pattern,)-277 (which)-278 (of)]TJ
-14.4225 -1.1667 TD
[(course must be dif)25 (ferent from the lock)10 (ed v)25 (alue 1.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 417.33 Tm
[(7  P)20 (erf)25 (ormance)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 394 Tm
[(Usually)65 (,)-373 (good)-373 (performance)-373 (is)-373 (tak)10 (en)-373 (to)-374 (mean)-373 (that)-373 (both)-373 (memory)-373 (and)-373 (CPUs)-373 (are)-374 (used)-373 (ef)25 (\336ciently)65 (.)]TJ
T*
[(Since)-289 (dif)25 (ferent)-289 (systems)-289 (must)-288 (mak)10 (e)-289 (space/time)-288 (trade-of)25 (fs)-289 (dif)25 (ferently)65 (,)-289 (w)0 (e)-288 (shall)-289 (consider)-288 (space)-288 (and)]TJ
T*
[(time)-393 (costs)-393 (for)-392 (our)-393 (synchronization)-392 (algorithm)-393 (separately)66 (.)-393 (All)-393 (our)-393 (measurements)-393 (were)-393 (collected)]TJ
T*
[(using)-256 (a)-257 (near)20 (-FCS)-257 (v)15 (ersion)-257 (of)-256 (EVM)-257 (on)-257 (a)-256 (lightly)-257 (loaded)-256 (4-CPU)-257 (296)-257 (MHz)-257 (UltraSP)92 (ARC)-256 (system)-256 (with)]TJ
T*
[(2)-284 (gigabytes)-284 (of)-284 (RAM)-284 (and)-284 (the)-285 (Solaris\252)-284 (2.6)-284 (operating)-284 (system.)-283 (Some)-284 (measurements)-284 (were)-284 (obtained)]TJ
T*
[(by)-302 (adding)-300 (counters)-302 (to)-301 (the)-301 (code.)-301 (T)80 (o)-302 (minimize)-301 (the)-301 (disturbance)-301 (resulting)-301 (from)-301 (the)-301 (instrumentation,)]TJ
T*
[(we used per)20 (-thread counters that were accumulated into global totals as threads e)17 (xited.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 277.67 Tm
(7.1  Benchmarks)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 253 Tm
[(T)80 (able)-250 (1)-235 (sho)26 (ws)-235 (the)-234 (benchmarks)-234 (we)-234 (use)-234 (to)-234 (assess)-234 (the)-235 (performance)-234 (of)-234 (our)-234 (synchronization)-234 (code.)-234 (The)]TJ
T*
[(HelloW)80 (orld)-491 (program)-491 (sho)25 (ws)-491 (ho)25 (w)-490 (the)-490 (minimal)-491 (program)-491 (beha)21 (v)15 (es.)-491 (The)-490 (ne)15 (xt)-491 (se)26 (v)15 (e)0 (n)-491 (lines)-491 (sho)25 (w)]TJ
T*
[(widely-kno)25 (wn)-370 (SPECjvm98)-370 (benchmarks)-370 ([26].)-371 (Finally)66 (,)-371 (w)0 (e)-371 (include)-370 (a)-371 (selection)-370 (of)-370 (multi-threaded)]TJ
T*
[(benchmarks,)-270 (some)-270 (of)-270 (which)-270 (perform)-271 (signi\336cant)-270 (amounts)-270 (of)-270 (I/O)-270 (and)-270 (some)-270 (of)-270 (which)-270 (use)-270 (graphics.)]TJ
T*
[(The e)15 (x)15 (ecution times in the table are best of tw)11 (o runs.)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 164.67 Tm
[(7.2  Space perf)25 (ormance)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 140 Tm
[(W)80 (e)0 ( consider separately the space costs of)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
16.7758 0 TD
(used)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8333 0 TD
( and)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
1.9442 0 TD
(unused)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.8325 0 TD
[( synchronization capability)65 (.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
-23.3858 -1.75 TD
[(Cost)-271 (of)-270 (used)-271 (sync)15 (hr)45 (onization)-270 (capability:)-270 (the)-271 (cost)-271 (for)-270 (objects)-270 (that)-271 (ar)37 (e)-270 (actually)-271 (sync)15 (hr)45 (onized)-271 (upon.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
0 -1.1667 TD
[(From)-243 (the)-243 (description)-242 (of)-244 (our)-243 (algorithm,)-242 (it)-243 (follo)25 (ws)-243 (that)-242 (this)-243 (space)-243 (cost)-242 (is)-243 (proportional)-243 (to)-243 (the)-243 (number)]TJ
T*
[(of)-371 (lock)-371 (records)-370 (in)-371 (use)-371 (at)-371 (an)15 (y)-371 (point)-371 (in)-371 (time.)-371 (More)-371 (precisely)65 (,)-371 (since)-371 (threads)-371 (rec)15 (ycle)-371 (lock)-370 (records)]TJ
T*
[(locally)-240 (rather)-240 (than)-240 (globally)65 (,)-240 (w)0 (e)-240 (report)-240 (the)-240 (number)-240 (of)-239 (lock)-240 (records)-239 (allocated)-240 (by)-241 (the)-240 (global)-240 (allocator)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 22 22
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(19)Tj
-19 20.0692 TD
[(during)-334 (the)-334 (e)15 (x)15 (ecution)-334 (of)-334 (each)-335 (benchmark.)-333 (This)-334 (higher)-334 (number)-334 (re\337ects)-334 (our)-334 (implementation)-334 (more)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(accurately)65 (.)-314 (I)0 (n)-314 (the)-315 (w)10 (orst)-315 (case,)-314 (a)-315 (program)-314 (will)-314 (synchronize)-314 (on)-314 (e)25 (v)15 (ery)-315 (object)-314 (allocated)-315 (\(see)-314 (Section)]TJ
T*
[(2.2\),)-252 (making)-252 (the)-252 (w)10 (orst-case)-252 (space)-252 (cost)-251 (of)-252 (our)-252 (algorithm,)-252 (as)-252 (well)-251 (as)-252 (of)-252 (an)15 (y)-252 (other)-252 (algorithm)-252 (that)-252 (we)]TJ
T*
[(kno)25 (w)-235 (of,)-235 (proportional)-234 (to)-235 (the)-235 (size)-235 (of)-234 (the)-235 (heap.)-234 (F)15 (ortunately)65 (,)-235 (this)-235 (number)-235 (is)-235 (f)10 (a)0 (r)-235 (more)-235 (pessimistic)-235 (than)]TJ
T*
[(the)-242 (beha)20 (vior)-242 (typical)-243 (programs)-242 (e)15 (xhibit.)-243 (T)80 (able)-250 (2)-243 (sho)26 (ws)-243 (that)-242 (for)-242 (our)-243 (benchmarks,)-242 (the)-243 (total)-242 (number)-242 (of)]TJ
T*
[(lock)-225 (records)-225 (allocated)-225 (is)-225 (v)15 (ery)-225 (small,)-225 (and)-225 (pales)-225 (in)-225 (comparison)-225 (with)-225 (the)-225 (total)-225 (number)-226 (of)-224 (objects)-225 (allo-)]TJ
T*
[(cated.)-240 (Moreo)14 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-240 (at)-240 (24)-240 (bytes)-241 (per)-240 (lock)-240 (record,)-240 (e)25 (v)15 (en)-240 (the)-240 (w)10 (orst)-240 (program)-240 (seen,)-240 (the)-240 (v)20 (olano)-240 (serv)15 (er)40 (,)-241 (con-)]TJ
T*
[(sumes)-337 (77)-336 (Kbytes)-336 (for)-336 (lock)-336 (records,)-336 (a)-336 (tri)25 (vial)-337 (amount)-336 (compared)-336 (with)-336 (the)-336 (se)25 (v)15 (eral)-336 (Mbytes)-337 (used)-336 (for)]TJ
T*
0 Tw
(objects and thread stacks.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Cost)-272 (of)-272 (unused)-272 (sync)15 (hr)45 (onization)-272 (capability:)-272 (the)-272 (cost)-271 (for)-272 (objects)-272 (that)-271 (ar)37 (e)-272 (n)0 (e)15 (ver)-271 (sync)15 (hr)46 (onized)-272 (upon)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
38.75 0 TD
(.)Tj
-38.75 -1.1667 TD
[(This)-272 (cost,)-271 (in)-271 (our)-272 (meta-lock)-272 (scheme,)-272 (amounts)-271 (to)-272 (tw)10 (o)-272 (bits)-272 (per)-271 (object.)-272 (Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-272 (an)-272 (alternati)26 (v)15 (e)-272 (vie)25 (w)]TJ
T*
[(is)-251 (that)-252 (the)-252 (cost)-251 (is)-251 (either)-252 (0)-252 (o)0 (r)-251 (1)-252 (w)10 (ord,)-251 (since)-252 (it)-251 (is)-252 (impractical)-251 (to)-252 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-252 (objects)-251 (of)-252 (fractional)-251 (w)10 (ord)-252 (sizes)]TJ
T*
[(on)-417 (contemporary)-417 (hardw)11 (are.)-417 (Put)-417 (dif)25 (ferently)65 (,)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
18.3142 0 TD
(if)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.9725 0 TD
[(tw)10 (o)-417 (spare)-417 (bits)-417 (can)-417 (be)-417 (found)-417 (in)-417 (objects)-417 (without)]TJ
-19.2867 -1.1667 TD
[(increasing)-291 (object)-292 (sizes,)-291 (our)-291 (locking)-291 (algorithm)-292 (has)-291 (no)-291 (space)-291 (cost)-291 (for)-291 (objects)-291 (that)-292 (are)-291 (not)-291 (synchro-)]TJ
T*
[(nized)-309 (upon.)-308 (Otherwise,)-309 (if)-309 (\336nding)-308 (tw)10 (o)-309 (bits)-309 (requires)-309 (increasing)-308 (the)-309 (size)-309 (of)-309 (objects)-309 (by)-309 (a)-309 (full)-309 (w)10 (ord,)]TJ
9.5708 53.3333 TD
[(T)80 (able 1. Characterization of benchmark programs)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 461.9 687.33 Tm
[(r)18 (eal time, seconds)]TJ
-38.926 -2.9 TD
[(Benchmark)-2573 (Description)-18031 ( #lines)]TJ
8 0 0 8 405.08 662.33 Tm
(a)Tj
10 0 0 10 415.81 658.33 Tm
[(#thr)18 (eads)]TJ
8 0 0 8 452.85 662.33 Tm
(b)Tj
10 0 0 10 469.64 670.33 Tm
(with)Tj
-0.943 -1.2 TD
(extrafast)Tj
4.314 1.2 TD
(without)Tj
-0.249 -1.2 TD
(extrafast)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-42.822 -1.7 TD
[(Hello)-5351 (Hello w)10 (orld program)-17433 (5)-4004 (1)-2754 (0.7)-2875 (0.7)]TJ
T*
[(_201_compress)-1296 (LZW compression and decompression)-9453 (927)-4004 (1)-2254 (45.8)-2375 (46.0)]TJ
T*
[(_202_jess)-3573 (V)111 (ersion of N)35 (ASA)111 (\325)55 (s)0 ( CLIPS e)15 (xpert system shell)-5111 (10,579)-4004 (1)-2254 (22.3)-2375 (24.8)]TJ
T*
[(_209_db)-4073 (Search and modify a database)-12176 (1,028)-4004 (1)-2254 (72.1)-2375 (87.9)]TJ
T*
[(_213_ja)21 (v)25 (a)0 (c)-3009 (Source to bytecode compiler)-12147 (25,211)-4004 (1)-2254 (42.7)-2375 (48.9)]TJ
T*
[(_222_mpe)15 (g)6 (audio)-650 (Decompress audio \336le)-16202 (n/a)-4004 (1)-2254 (50.4)-2375 (51.3)]TJ
T*
[(_227_mtrt)-3406 (Multi-threaded image rendering)-11342 (3,799)-4004 (2)-2254 (13.2)-2375 (13.6)]TJ
T*
[(_228_jack)-3407 (P)16 (arser generator generating itself)-10887 (8,194)-4004 (1)-2254 (34.5)-2375 (38.0)]TJ
T*
[(_224_richards)-1852 (Fi)25 (v)16 (e)-247 (threads)-246 (running)-246 (multiple)-247 (v)15 (ersions)-246 (of)-246 (O/S)-247 (simulator)-1836 (3,637)-4004 (5)-2254 (17.3)-2375 (19.0)]TJ
T*
[(_233_tmix)-3239 (Thread mix: sort, crc, producer)19 (-consumer)40 (, primes, etc.)-2376 (8,194)-3504 (14)-2254 (28.8)-2375 (29.1)]TJ
T*
[(SwingMark)-2851 (Benchmark and test of swing libraries)-8925 (3,998)-4004 (8)-2254 (51.3)-2375 (51.5)]TJ
T*
[(v)21 (olano serv)14 (er)]TJ
8 0 0 8 126.43 458.33 Tm
(c)Tj
10 0 0 10 148.37 454.33 Tm
[(\322Chat serv)15 (er)41 (,)69 (\323)0 ( reads and distrib)21 (utes messages)-7072 (n/a)-3004 (406)]TJ
33.624 -0.85 TD
[(9.6)-2375 (10.3)]TJ
-41.197 -0.85 TD
[(v)21 (olano client)-2400 (Generates w)11 (ork-load to stress serv)13 (er)-10618 (n/a)-3004 (402)]TJ
0 -1.7 TD
(JWS)Tj
8 0 0 8 91.53 424.33 Tm
(d)Tj
10 0 0 10 148.37 420.33 Tm
[(Ja)21 (v)25 (a)0 ( W)80 (eb Serv)14 (er\252, serving 20,000 requests)-5531 (200,000)-3504 (63)-2254 (25.7)-2375 (27.3)]TJ
ET
0 G
2 J
0 j
0.36 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
203.63 410.15 m
77.64 410.15 l
S 
BT
10 0 0 10 71.64 400.33 Tm
[(a.)-385 (Approximate lines of source code in the benchmark itself, e)14 (xcluding class library code.)]TJ
0 -1.5 TD
[(b)40 (.)-369 (Maximum)-327 (number)-327 (of)-327 (acti)25 (v)15 (e)-327 (threads,)-327 (e)15 (xcluding)-327 (three)-327 (system)-327 (threads)-327 (\(\336nalizer)40 (,)-327 (reference)-327 (handler)40 (,)-327 (and)-326 (signal)-327 (dis-)]TJ
1.079 -1.2 TD
[(patcher\).)-300 (All)-300 (SPEC)-300 (programs)-300 (actually)-300 (run)-300 (a)-300 (second)-300 (user)20 (-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-300 (thread)-300 (\(secondary)-300 (\336nalizer\))-300 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-300 (since)-300 (this)-299 (thread)-301 (is)]TJ
T*
[(v)14 (ery short-li)25 (v)16 (ed, we do not count it.)]TJ
-1.079 -1.5 TD
[(c.)-385 (V)129 (olanoMark v)14 (ersion 2.0.0 b)20 (uild 137 [22].)]TJ
T*
[(d.)-329 (http://www)64 (.sun.com/softw)11 (are/jwebserv)15 (er/inde)14 (x.html.)]TJ
ET
0 J
0.6 w
71.64 414.25 m
71.64 680.75 l
B* 
147.37 413.75 m
147.37 681.25 l
B* 
373.17 413.75 m
373.17 681.25 l
B* 
414.03 413.75 m
414.03 681.25 l
B* 
459.07 413.75 m
459.07 697.75 l
B* 
499.11 413.75 m
499.11 681.25 l
B* 
540.36 414.25 m
540.36 697.75 l
B* 
540.61 698 m
458.82 698 l
B* 
540.61 681 m
71.39 681 l
B* 
540.11 653.25 m
71.89 653.25 l
B* 
540.11 650.75 m
71.89 650.75 l
B* 
540.11 636.25 m
71.89 636.25 l
B* 
540.11 633.75 m
71.89 633.75 l
B* 
540.61 618 m
71.39 618 l
B* 
540.61 601 m
71.39 601 l
B* 
540.61 584 m
71.39 584 l
B* 
540.61 567 m
71.39 567 l
B* 
540.61 550 m
71.39 550 l
B* 
540.61 533 m
71.39 533 l
B* 
540.11 517.25 m
71.89 517.25 l
B* 
540.11 514.75 m
71.89 514.75 l
B* 
540.61 499 m
71.39 499 l
B* 
540.61 482 m
71.39 482 l
B* 
540.61 465 m
71.39 465 l
B* 
459.32 448 m
71.39 448 l
B* 
540.61 431 m
71.39 431 l
B* 
540.61 414 m
71.39 414 l
B* 
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 23 23
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(20)Tj
-19 30.0692 TD
[(then)-287 (a)-288 (dif)25 (ferent)-287 (synchronization)-287 (algorithm)-287 (that)-287 (tak)10 (es)-288 (adv)25 (antage)-287 (of)-287 (a)-288 (full)-287 (w)9 (ord)-287 (of)-287 (memory)-288 (should)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(\(probably\))-296 (be)-298 (used.)-297 (Thus,)-297 (it)-296 (can)-297 (be)-297 (ar)18 (gued,)-297 (our)-297 (algorithm)-297 (has)-297 (no)-297 (space)-296 (o)15 (v)15 (erhead)-297 (for)-296 (objects)-297 (that)]TJ
T*
0 Tw
(are not synchronized upon.)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 334.67 Tm
[(7.3  T)18 (ime perf)26 (ormance)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 310 Tm
[(W)80 (e)-263 (study)-264 (time)-264 (performance)-263 (of)-264 (our)-264 (algorithm)-263 (in)-264 (tw)10 (o)-263 (w)10 (ays.)-264 (First,)-263 (we)-264 (compare)-263 (the)-264 (cost)-263 (of)-264 (synchro-)]TJ
T*
[(nization)-255 (in)-256 (our)-255 (system)-256 (with)-255 (that)-256 (of)-256 (the)-255 (original)-255 (JVM)-256 (found)-256 (in)-255 (the)-255 (\322JDK)-256 (1.2)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
30.2517 0 TD
[(Refer)37 (ence)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.2167 0 TD
[(Release)-256 (for)]TJ
-34.4683 -1.1667 TD
[(Solaris.)70 (\323)-298 (F)15 (or)-299 (this)-298 (study)65 (,)-298 (a)0 (s)-299 (e)15 (xplained)-297 (belo)25 (w)65 (,)-298 (we)-298 (use)-299 (synthetic)-298 (benchmarks.)-298 (Second,)-298 (we)-298 (study)-299 (the)]TJ
T*
[(beha)20 (vior)-310 (of)-310 (our)-310 (algorithm)-311 (on)-310 (the)-310 (more)-310 (realistic)-310 (programs)-310 (sho)25 (wn)-310 (in)-310 (T)80 (able)-250 (1.)-311 (W)80 (e)-310 (do)-310 (not)-310 (compare)]TJ
T*
[(the)-285 (absolute)-286 (performance)-286 (of)-285 (the)-285 (tw)9 (o)-285 (JVMs)-286 (since)-286 (the)15 (y)-286 (dif)25 (fer)-286 (in)-285 (man)15 (y)-286 (other)-286 (respects)-285 (than)-285 (the)-286 (syn-)]TJ
T*
(chronization code.)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
0 -2.3333 TD
[(7.3.1  T)18 (ime perf)26 (ormance comparison with the original JVM)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
0 -1.8333 TD
[(In)-314 (this)-314 (section)-314 (we)-314 (compare)-314 (the)-315 (speed)-314 (of)-314 (our)-314 (synchronization)-314 (algorithm)-314 (in)-314 (EVM,)-315 (using)-315 (the)-314 (e)15 (xtra)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(f)10 (ast)-239 (e)15 (xtension,)-239 (with)-240 (that)-239 (of)-239 (the)-240 (monitor)-239 (cache)-240 (approach)-240 (in)-239 (the)-240 (original)-239 (JVM.)-240 (T)80 (o)-240 (measure)-239 (the)-239 (speed)]TJ
T*
[(of)-280 (synchronization)-281 (rather)-280 (than)-280 (the)-280 (speed)-280 (of)-281 (conte)15 (xt)-280 (switching)-281 (pro)16 (vided)-280 (by)-281 (the)-280 (underlying)-281 (operat-)]TJ
T*
[(ing)-248 (system,)-248 (we)-247 (use)-248 (programs)-248 (that)-247 (primarily)-248 (do)-247 (uncontended)-248 (synchronization.)-247 (Section)-248 (6.3.2)-247 (sho)25 (ws)]TJ
T*
[(that)-259 (contention)-259 (is)-259 (relati)25 (v)14 (ely)-259 (infrequent)-259 (for)-259 (typical)-259 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-258 (programs,)-259 (justifying)-258 (this)-259 (approach,)-259 (at)-259 (least)]TJ
T*
(in part.)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(Ideally)65 (,)-325 (w)0 (e)-324 (w)10 (ould)-324 (compare)-324 (dif)24 (ferent)-324 (synchronization)-324 (algorithms)-324 (directly)-324 (by)-324 (implementing)-325 (them)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(as)-298 (alternati)26 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-297 (i)0 (n)-298 (the)-297 (same)-297 (virtual)-297 (machine.)-298 (In)-297 (our)-298 (case,)-297 (ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-297 (this)-297 (approach)-297 (w)9 (a)0 (s)-297 (impractical.)]TJ
T*
[(First,)-308 (the)-307 (implementation)-307 (ef)25 (fort)-307 (is)-307 (non-tri)25 (vial.)-307 (Second,)-307 (an)-308 (algorithm)-307 (added)-307 (quickly)-307 (to)-307 (a)-308 (JVM)-307 (for)]TJ
3.7517 53.4167 TD
[(T)79 (able 2. Objects allocated, objects synchronized on, and lock records all\
ocated)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 141.62 687.33 Tm
[(Benchmark)-5556 (# objects)-2691 (# objs sync\325ed on)-1574 (# lock r)18 (ecords)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
0 -1.7 TD
[(Hello)-11867 (2,076)-2970 (262)-250 ( \(12.6%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_201_compress)-7812 (8,917)-2970 (936)-250 ( \(10.5%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_202_jess)-8339 (7,934,141)-2720 (6,545)-250 ( \(0.1%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_209_db)-8839 (3,213,429)-2220 (17,123)-500 (\(0.5%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_213_ja)20 (v)25 (a)0 (c)-7774 (5,912,859)-1720 (351,538)-500 (\(5.9%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_222_mpe)15 (gaudio)-6665 (12,009)-3470 (994)-250 ( \(8.3%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_227_mtrt)-8172 (6,641,320)-2720 (1,195)-500 (\(0.0%\))-7218 (60)]TJ
T*
[(_228_jack)-8173 (6,841,290)-1720 (506,157)-250 ( \(7.4%\))-7218 (40)]TJ
T*
[(_224_richards)-7868 (36,065)-2720 (1,878)-500 (\(5.2%\))-7218 (80)]TJ
T*
[(_233_tmix)-8005 (1,366,985)-1220 (169,823)-250 ( \(12.4%\))-6718 (140)]TJ
T*
[(SwingMark)-7617 (2,345,281)-2220 (69,245)-500 (\(3.0%\))-6718 (100)]TJ
T*
[(v)20 (olano serv)15 (er)-7709 (140,335)-2720 (6,334)-500 (\(4.5%\))-5968 (3,280)]TJ
T*
[(v)20 (olano client)-7915 (661,199)-2720 (3,643)-500 (\(0.6%\))-5968 (3,240)]TJ
T*
[(JWS)-10450 (1,336,170)-1970 (258,960)-500 (\(19%\))-6718 (540)]TJ
ET
0 G
0 J
0 j
0.6 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
140.62 443.25 m
140.62 697.75 l
B* 
224.83 442.75 m
224.83 698.25 l
B* 
307.01 442.75 m
307.01 698.25 l
B* 
389.2 442.75 m
389.2 698.25 l
B* 
471.38 443.25 m
471.38 697.75 l
B* 
471.63 698 m
140.37 698 l
B* 
471.13 682.25 m
140.87 682.25 l
B* 
471.13 679.75 m
140.87 679.75 l
B* 
471.13 665.25 m
140.87 665.25 l
B* 
471.13 662.75 m
140.87 662.75 l
B* 
471.63 647 m
140.37 647 l
B* 
471.63 630 m
140.37 630 l
B* 
471.63 613 m
140.37 613 l
B* 
471.63 596 m
140.37 596 l
B* 
471.63 579 m
140.37 579 l
B* 
471.63 562 m
140.37 562 l
B* 
471.13 546.25 m
140.87 546.25 l
B* 
471.13 543.75 m
140.87 543.75 l
B* 
471.63 528 m
140.37 528 l
B* 
471.63 511 m
140.37 511 l
B* 
471.63 494 m
140.37 494 l
B* 
471.63 477 m
140.37 477 l
B* 
471.63 460 m
140.37 460 l
B* 
471.63 443 m
140.37 443 l
B* 
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 24 24
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(21)Tj
-19 36.1108 TD
[(the)-239 (purpose)-240 (of)-239 (measuring)-239 (will)-239 (be)-239 (at)-240 (an)-238 (inherent)-239 (disadv)25 (antage)-239 (compared)-238 (with)-239 (an)-239 (algorithm)-238 (that)-239 (has)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(been)-260 (tuned)-260 (with)-260 (the)-260 (rest)-260 (of)-260 (the)-260 (system)-260 (o)15 (v)15 (e)0 (r)-260 (a)-260 (long)-259 (period.)-261 (Third,)-260 (it)-261 (may)-260 (be)-260 (technically)-260 (impossible)]TJ
T*
[(to)-339 (k)10 (eep)-339 (all)-339 (other)-340 (f)10 (actors)-339 (constant,)-339 (since)-339 (each)-340 (algorithm)-339 (may)-340 (tak)10 (e)-339 (adv)26 (antage)-340 (of)-339 (features)-339 (that)-340 (the)]TJ
T*
[(other)-230 (one)-229 (does)-230 (not)-229 (use)-229 (\(e.g.,)-230 (the)-230 (monitor)-229 (cache)-230 (w)10 (orks)-230 (best)-230 (in)-229 (the)-230 (presence)-230 (of)-229 (handles\).)-229 (Since)-230 (EVM)]TJ
T*
[(and)-235 (the)-235 (original)-235 (JVM)-235 (dif)25 (fer)-236 (in)-235 (man)15 (y)-236 (respects,)-235 (comparing)-235 (bottom-line)-235 (performance)-235 (does)-235 (not)-235 (re)25 (v)15 (eal)]TJ
T*
[(much)-585 (about)-584 (the)-585 (tw)10 (o)-584 (systems\325)-584 (synchronization)-584 (code.)-584 (F)15 (ortunately)65 (,)-584 (a)-584 (dif)25 (ferent)-585 (measurement)]TJ
T*
[(approach)-250 (can)-250 (gi)25 (v)15 (e)-250 (us)-250 (the)-250 (information)-250 (we)-251 (w)10 (ant.)-250 (Consider)-250 (a)-250 (program)-1361 (that)-251 (performs)-250 (synchroniza-)]TJ
T*
[(tion.)-285 (Construct)-285 (the)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
7.7725 0 TD
(baseline)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.6183 0 TD
[(program)-1146 (,)-285 (which)-285 (is)-285 (just)-285 (lik)10 (e)-1147 (,)-285 (e)15 (xcept)-285 (that)-285 (all)-285 (synchronization)-285 (has)]TJ
-11.3908 -1.1667 TD
[(been)-275 (stripped)-275 (out.)-276 (The)-276 (dif)25 (ference)-275 (in)-275 (e)15 (x)15 (ecution)-276 (time,)-13274 (,)-276 (re\337ects)-276 (the)]TJ
T*
[(cost)-273 (of)-274 (synchronization.)-273 (Computing)-4229 (for)-273 (EVM)-274 (and)-273 (the)-273 (original)-274 (JVM)-273 (gi)26 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-274 (numbers)-273 (that)]TJ
T*
0 Tw
(can be compared.)Tj
0 -1.75 TD
[(The)-369 (main)-370 (limitation)-369 (of)-369 (this)-369 (approach)-369 (is)-370 (that)-369 (real)-369 (programs)-369 (usually)-368 (rely)-370 (on)-369 (synchronization)-369 (for)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(their)-256 (correct)-256 (e)15 (x)15 (ecution,)-256 (so)-257 (to)-256 (ensure)-256 (that)-257 (the)-256 (presence)-256 (or)-256 (absence)-256 (of)-256 (synchronization)-256 (does)-257 (not)-256 (oth-)]TJ
T*
[(erwise)-302 (af)25 (fect)-301 (the)-302 (computation,)-301 (we)-302 (limit)-302 (our)-302 (study)-301 (to)-302 (synthetic)-301 (benchmarks.)-302 (T)80 (o)-302 (this)-302 (end,)-302 (we)-302 (con-)]TJ
T*
[(structed)-230 (a)-230 (set)-230 (of)-230 (simple)-230 (benchmarks:)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
14.7108 0 TD
(SyncMethod)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.1733 0 TD
[(calls)-229 (a)-230 (synchronized)-230 (method;)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
11.8067 0 TD
(SyncStmt)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
3.8958 0 TD
[(e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)]TJ
-35.5867 -1.1667 TD
[(a)-309 (synchronized)-309 (statement;)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
10.8158 0 TD
(RecSyncMethod)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6.7517 0 TD
[(calls)-309 (tw)10 (o)-310 (nested)-309 (synchronized)-309 (methods)-310 (on)-309 (an)-310 (object;)]TJ
-17.5675 -1.1667 TD
(and)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
1.7867 0 TD
(RecSyncStmt)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.5075 0 TD
[(e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-343 (a)-343 (pair)-343 (of)-342 (nested)-343 (synchronized)-342 (statements)-343 (on)-342 (an)-343 (object.)-343 (The)-342 (\336rst)-343 (tw)10 (o)]TJ
-7.2942 -1.1667 TD
[(benchmarks)-235 (measure)-235 (the)-235 (cost)-236 (of)-235 (a)-235 (non-recursi)25 (v)15 (e)-235 (lock/unlock)-235 (pair)41 (,)-236 (and)-235 (the)-235 (second)-235 (tw)11 (o)-236 (measure)-235 (the)]TJ
T*
[(sum)-250 (of)-250 (the)-250 (costs)-250 (of)-250 (a)-250 (non-recursi)25 (v)15 (e)-250 (and)-251 (recursi)25 (v)15 (e)-250 (lock/unlock)-250 (pair)55 (.)-250 (Each)-251 (benchmark)-250 (completes)-250 (10)]TJ
T*
[(million)-239 (iterations,)-239 (c)15 (ycling)-238 (through)-239 (an)-238 (array)-239 (of)-239 (length)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
21.1442 0 TD
(N)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.9058 0 TD
[(to)-239 (select)-239 (the)-239 (objects)-239 (to)-239 (synchronize)-239 (on.)-238 (W)80 (e)]TJ
-22.05 -1.1667 TD
(let)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
1.2933 0 TD
(N)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.96 0 TD
[(range)-294 (from)-293 (1)-293 (t)0 (o)-294 (512K)-293 (and)-293 (plot)-293 (the)-294 (cost)-293 (per)-293 (iterations;)-293 (see)-294 (Figure)-250 (10.)-293 (As)-293 (one)-293 (w)10 (ould)-294 (e)15 (xpect,)]TJ
-2.2533 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-380 (meta-locking)-380 (scheme)-380 (deli)25 (v)15 (ers)-380 (unchanged)-380 (performance)-379 (re)15 (gardless)-380 (of)-380 (the)-380 (number)-380 (of)-379 (objects)]TJ
T*
[(synchronized)-288 (upon)-288 (whereas)-287 (the)-288 (monitor)-288 (cache)-288 (approach)-288 (suf)25 (fers)-288 (an)-288 (increasing)-288 (slo)25 (wdo)25 (wn,)-288 (despite)]TJ
T*
[(the)-325 (f)10 (act)-324 (that)-325 (in)-324 (all)-324 (of)-324 (these)-324 (tests,)-324 (no)-324 (more)-324 (than)-324 (one)-324 (object)-324 (is)-325 (lock)10 (ed)-324 (at)-325 (an)16 (y)-324 (time.)-324 (The)-324 (graph)-325 (also)]TJ
T*
[(sho)25 (ws)-271 (that)-272 (the)-270 (absolute)-272 (cost)-271 (of)-271 (a)-271 (synchronization)-271 (operation)-271 (in)-271 (EVM)-271 (is)-270 (al)10 (w)10 (ays)-271 (signi\336cantly)-271 (lo)25 (wer)]TJ
T*
[(than)-313 (in)-313 (the)-313 (original)-313 (JVM.)-313 (F)15 (o)0 (r)-313 (e)15 (xample,)-312 (a)-313 (non-recursi)26 (v)15 (e)-313 (synchronized)-313 (method)-312 (call,)-313 (the)-313 (most)-312 (fre-)]TJ
T*
[(quent)-276 (form)-277 (of)-277 (synchronization,)-276 (e)15 (x)15 (ecutes)-277 (in)-277 (about)-276 (220)-277 (ns)-277 (on)-277 (EVM)-276 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-277 (tak)10 (es)-277 (550)-277 (ns)-277 (to)-276 (1500)-277 (ns)-277 (on)]TJ
T*
(the original JVM.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
27.1967 25.0833 TD
(P)Tj
-12.0492 -1.1667 TD
(P)Tj
ET
0 G
2 J
0 j
0.6 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
259.9 380.24 m
254.97 380.24 l
S 
BT
12 0 0 12 356.76 369.5 Tm
(P)Tj
-2.5567 -1.1667 TD
0.059 Tc
[(sync)-404 (P)]TJ
/N96 1 Tf
2.0133 0 TD
0.753 Tc
(\(\))Tj
/N94 1 Tf
2.9817 0 TD
0.059 Tc
[(time)-405 (P)]TJ
/N96 1 Tf
1.9583 0 TD
0.753 Tc
(\(\))Tj
/N94 1 Tf
2.4183 0 TD
0.059 Tc
[(time)-405 (P)]TJ
/N96 1 Tf
1.9583 0 TD
0.753 Tc
(\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
-2.7083 0 TD
0 Tc
(\320)Tj
-4.69 0 TD
(=)Tj
ET
473.02 366.24 m
468.08 366.24 l
S 
BT
/N94 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 249.12 341.5 Tm
0.059 Tc
[(sync)-404 (P)]TJ
/N96 1 Tf
2.0133 0 TD
0.753 Tc
(\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0 9 -9 0 93.5 568.5 Tm
0 Tc
(Synchronization cost per iteration \(ns\))Tj
9 0 0 9 211.5 546.5 Tm
(Number of objects \()Tj
/N94 1 Tf
8.0256 0 TD
(N)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
0.6678 0 TD
(\))Tj
ET
1 g
96.5 716.5 442 -160 re
f* 
1 J
1 j
0.7 w
122.5 570.5 m
374.5 570.5 l
122.5 570.5 m
122.5 565.5 l
135.763 570.5 m
135.763 568.5 l
143.522 570.5 m
143.522 568.5 l
149.026 570.5 m
149.026 568.5 l
153.296 570.5 m
153.296 568.5 l
156.785 570.5 m
156.785 568.5 l
159.734 570.5 m
159.734 568.5 l
162.289 570.5 m
162.289 568.5 l
164.543 570.5 m
164.543 568.5 l
166.559 570.5 m
166.559 565.5 l
179.822 570.5 m
179.822 568.5 l
187.581 570.5 m
187.581 568.5 l
193.086 570.5 m
193.086 568.5 l
197.355 570.5 m
197.355 568.5 l
200.844 570.5 m
200.844 568.5 l
203.794 570.5 m
203.794 568.5 l
206.349 570.5 m
206.349 568.5 l
208.602 570.5 m
208.602 568.5 l
210.618 570.5 m
210.618 565.5 l
223.882 570.5 m
223.882 568.5 l
231.64 570.5 m
231.64 568.5 l
237.145 570.5 m
237.145 568.5 l
241.415 570.5 m
241.415 568.5 l
244.903 570.5 m
244.903 568.5 l
247.853 570.5 m
247.853 568.5 l
250.408 570.5 m
250.408 568.5 l
252.662 570.5 m
252.662 568.5 l
254.678 570.5 m
254.678 565.5 l
267.941 570.5 m
267.941 568.5 l
275.699 570.5 m
275.699 568.5 l
281.204 570.5 m
281.204 568.5 l
285.474 570.5 m
285.474 568.5 l
288.963 570.5 m
288.963 568.5 l
291.912 570.5 m
291.912 568.5 l
294.467 570.5 m
294.467 568.5 l
296.721 570.5 m
296.721 568.5 l
298.737 570.5 m
298.737 565.5 l
312 570.5 m
312 568.5 l
319.759 570.5 m
319.759 568.5 l
325.263 570.5 m
325.263 568.5 l
329.533 570.5 m
329.533 568.5 l
333.022 570.5 m
333.022 568.5 l
335.971 570.5 m
335.971 568.5 l
338.526 570.5 m
338.526 568.5 l
340.78 570.5 m
340.78 568.5 l
342.796 570.5 m
342.796 565.5 l
356.059 570.5 m
356.059 568.5 l
363.818 570.5 m
363.818 568.5 l
369.323 570.5 m
369.323 568.5 l
373.592 570.5 m
373.592 568.5 l
S 
BT
/N97 1 Tf
9 0 0 9 120.25 557.1 Tm
0 g
[(1)-4145 (1)0 (0)-3646 (100)-3146 (1000)-2646 (10000)-2146 (100000)]TJ
ET
122.5 570.5 m
122.5 714.5 l
122.5 570.5 m
117.5 570.5 l
122.5 575.264 m
120.5 575.264 l
122.5 580.028 m
120.5 580.028 l
122.5 584.792 m
120.5 584.792 l
122.5 589.556 m
120.5 589.556 l
122.5 594.32 m
120.5 594.32 l
122.5 599.084 m
120.5 599.084 l
122.5 603.848 m
120.5 603.848 l
122.5 608.612 m
120.5 608.612 l
122.5 613.376 m
120.5 613.376 l
122.5 618.14 m
117.5 618.14 l
122.5 622.904 m
120.5 622.904 l
122.5 627.667 m
120.5 627.667 l
122.5 632.431 m
120.5 632.431 l
122.5 637.195 m
120.5 637.195 l
122.5 641.959 m
120.5 641.959 l
122.5 646.723 m
120.5 646.723 l
122.5 651.487 m
120.5 651.487 l
122.5 656.251 m
120.5 656.251 l
122.5 661.015 m
120.5 661.015 l
122.5 665.779 m
117.5 665.779 l
122.5 670.543 m
120.5 670.543 l
122.5 675.307 m
120.5 675.307 l
122.5 680.071 m
120.5 680.071 l
122.5 684.835 m
120.5 684.835 l
122.5 689.599 m
120.5 689.599 l
122.5 694.363 m
120.5 694.363 l
122.5 699.127 m
120.5 699.127 l
122.5 703.891 m
120.5 703.891 l
122.5 708.655 m
120.5 708.655 l
122.5 713.419 m
117.5 713.419 l
S 
BT
9 0 0 9 110 567.8 Tm
(0)Tj
-1.4999 5.2933 TD
(1000)Tj
T*
(2000)Tj
T*
(3000)Tj
ET
122.5 659.6 m
135.763 657.328 l
149.026 660.339 l
162.289 678.299 l
175.553 695.158 l
188.816 698.555 l
202.079 701.423 l
215.342 713.924 l
228.605 711.975 l
241.868 713.219 l
255.132 713.414 l
268.395 712.818 l
281.658 713.933 l
294.921 713.314 l
308.184 714.5 l
321.447 713.547 l
334.711 713.642 l
347.974 708.497 l
361.237 711.623 l
374.5 711.032 l
S 
124.52 659.58 m
124.52 660.684 123.624 661.58 122.52 661.58 c
121.416 661.58 120.52 660.684 120.52 659.58 c
120.52 658.476 121.416 657.58 122.52 657.58 c
123.624 657.58 124.52 658.476 124.52 659.58 c
B 
137.78 657.3 m
137.78 658.404 136.884 659.3 135.78 659.3 c
134.676 659.3 133.78 658.404 133.78 657.3 c
133.78 656.196 134.676 655.3 135.78 655.3 c
136.884 655.3 137.78 656.196 137.78 657.3 c
B 
151.04 660.3 m
151.04 661.404 150.144 662.3 149.04 662.3 c
147.936 662.3 147.04 661.404 147.04 660.3 c
147.04 659.196 147.936 658.3 149.04 658.3 c
150.144 658.3 151.04 659.196 151.04 660.3 c
B 
164.3 678.3 m
164.3 679.404 163.404 680.3 162.3 680.3 c
161.196 680.3 160.3 679.404 160.3 678.3 c
160.3 677.196 161.196 676.3 162.3 676.3 c
163.404 676.3 164.3 677.196 164.3 678.3 c
B 
177.56 695.16 m
177.56 696.264 176.664 697.16 175.56 697.16 c
174.456 697.16 173.56 696.264 173.56 695.16 c
173.56 694.056 174.456 693.16 175.56 693.16 c
176.664 693.16 177.56 694.056 177.56 695.16 c
B 
190.82 698.58 m
190.82 699.684 189.924 700.58 188.82 700.58 c
187.716 700.58 186.82 699.684 186.82 698.58 c
186.82 697.476 187.716 696.58 188.82 696.58 c
189.924 696.58 190.82 697.476 190.82 698.58 c
B 
204.08 701.46 m
204.08 702.564 203.184 703.46 202.08 703.46 c
200.976 703.46 200.08 702.564 200.08 701.46 c
200.08 700.356 200.976 699.46 202.08 699.46 c
203.184 699.46 204.08 700.356 204.08 701.46 c
B 
217.34 713.94 m
217.34 715.044 216.444 715.94 215.34 715.94 c
214.236 715.94 213.34 715.044 213.34 713.94 c
213.34 712.836 214.236 711.94 215.34 711.94 c
216.444 711.94 217.34 712.836 217.34 713.94 c
B 
230.6 711.96 m
230.6 713.064 229.704 713.96 228.6 713.96 c
227.496 713.96 226.6 713.064 226.6 711.96 c
226.6 710.856 227.496 709.96 228.6 709.96 c
229.704 709.96 230.6 710.856 230.6 711.96 c
B 
243.86 713.22 m
243.86 714.324 242.964 715.22 241.86 715.22 c
240.756 715.22 239.86 714.324 239.86 713.22 c
239.86 712.116 240.756 711.22 241.86 711.22 c
242.964 711.22 243.86 712.116 243.86 713.22 c
B 
257.12 713.4 m
257.12 714.504 256.224 715.4 255.12 715.4 c
254.016 715.4 253.12 714.504 253.12 713.4 c
253.12 712.296 254.016 711.4 255.12 711.4 c
256.224 711.4 257.12 712.296 257.12 713.4 c
B 
270.38 712.8 m
270.38 713.904 269.484 714.8 268.38 714.8 c
267.276 714.8 266.38 713.904 266.38 712.8 c
266.38 711.696 267.276 710.8 268.38 710.8 c
269.484 710.8 270.38 711.696 270.38 712.8 c
B 
283.64 713.94 m
283.64 715.044 282.744 715.94 281.64 715.94 c
280.536 715.94 279.64 715.044 279.64 713.94 c
279.64 712.836 280.536 711.94 281.64 711.94 c
282.744 711.94 283.64 712.836 283.64 713.94 c
B 
296.96 713.34 m
296.96 714.444 296.064 715.34 294.96 715.34 c
293.856 715.34 292.96 714.444 292.96 713.34 c
292.96 712.236 293.856 711.34 294.96 711.34 c
296.064 711.34 296.96 712.236 296.96 713.34 c
B 
310.16 714.48 m
310.16 715.584 309.264 716.48 308.16 716.48 c
307.056 716.48 306.16 715.584 306.16 714.48 c
306.16 713.376 307.056 712.48 308.16 712.48 c
309.264 712.48 310.16 713.376 310.16 714.48 c
B 
323.48 713.58 m
323.48 714.684 322.584 715.58 321.48 715.58 c
320.376 715.58 319.48 714.684 319.48 713.58 c
319.48 712.476 320.376 711.58 321.48 711.58 c
322.584 711.58 323.48 712.476 323.48 713.58 c
B 
336.68 713.64 m
336.68 714.744 335.784 715.64 334.68 715.64 c
333.576 715.64 332.68 714.744 332.68 713.64 c
332.68 712.536 333.576 711.64 334.68 711.64 c
335.784 711.64 336.68 712.536 336.68 713.64 c
B 
350 708.48 m
350 709.584 349.104 710.48 348 710.48 c
346.896 710.48 346 709.584 346 708.48 c
346 707.376 346.896 706.48 348 706.48 c
349.104 706.48 350 707.376 350 708.48 c
B 
363.2 711.66 m
363.2 712.764 362.304 713.66 361.2 713.66 c
360.096 713.66 359.2 712.764 359.2 711.66 c
359.2 710.556 360.096 709.66 361.2 709.66 c
362.304 709.66 363.2 710.556 363.2 711.66 c
B 
376.52 711.06 m
376.52 712.164 375.624 713.06 374.52 713.06 c
373.416 713.06 372.52 712.164 372.52 711.06 c
372.52 709.956 373.416 709.06 374.52 709.06 c
375.624 709.06 376.52 709.956 376.52 711.06 c
B 
122.5 624.561 m
135.763 626.334 l
149.026 626.191 l
162.289 644.098 l
175.553 656.442 l
188.816 662.301 l
202.079 661.063 l
215.342 672.11 l
228.605 674.073 l
241.868 673.454 l
255.132 673.497 l
268.395 674.621 l
281.658 673.254 l
294.921 673.13 l
308.184 673.42 l
321.447 672.901 l
334.711 672.977 l
347.974 669.524 l
361.237 671.772 l
374.5 672.577 l
S 
120.5 622.561 4 4 re
B 
133.763 624.334 4 4 re
B 
147.026 624.191 4 4 re
B 
160.289 642.098 4 4 re
B 
173.553 654.442 4 4 re
B 
186.816 660.301 4 4 re
B 
200.079 659.063 4 4 re
B 
213.342 670.11 4 4 re
B 
226.605 672.073 4 4 re
B 
239.868 671.454 4 4 re
B 
253.132 671.497 4 4 re
B 
266.395 672.621 4 4 re
B 
279.658 671.254 4 4 re
B 
292.921 671.13 4 4 re
B 
306.184 671.42 4 4 re
B 
319.447 670.901 4 4 re
B 
332.711 670.977 4 4 re
B 
345.974 667.524 4 4 re
B 
359.237 669.772 4 4 re
B 
372.5 670.577 4 4 re
B 
122.5 611.246 m
135.763 611.051 l
149.026 612.752 l
162.289 638.367 l
175.553 642.564 l
188.816 648.457 l
202.079 651.23 l
215.342 661.649 l
228.605 663.126 l
241.868 662.063 l
255.132 662.935 l
268.395 662.692 l
281.658 663.33 l
294.921 662.806 l
308.184 662.754 l
321.447 662.582 l
334.711 662.006 l
347.974 660.043 l
361.237 664.121 l
374.5 663.492 l
120.5 609.246 m
124.5 613.246 l
120.5 613.246 m
124.5 609.246 l
133.763 609.051 m
137.763 613.051 l
133.763 613.051 m
137.763 609.051 l
147.026 610.752 m
151.026 614.752 l
147.026 614.752 m
151.026 610.752 l
160.289 636.367 m
164.289 640.367 l
160.289 640.367 m
164.289 636.367 l
173.553 640.564 m
177.553 644.564 l
173.553 644.564 m
177.553 640.564 l
186.816 646.457 m
190.816 650.457 l
186.816 650.457 m
190.816 646.457 l
200.079 649.23 m
204.079 653.23 l
200.079 653.23 m
204.079 649.23 l
213.342 659.649 m
217.342 663.649 l
213.342 663.649 m
217.342 659.649 l
226.605 661.126 m
230.605 665.126 l
226.605 665.126 m
230.605 661.126 l
239.868 660.063 m
243.868 664.063 l
239.868 664.063 m
243.868 660.063 l
253.132 660.935 m
257.132 664.935 l
253.132 664.935 m
257.132 660.935 l
266.395 660.692 m
270.395 664.692 l
266.395 664.692 m
270.395 660.692 l
279.658 661.33 m
283.658 665.33 l
279.658 665.33 m
283.658 661.33 l
292.921 660.806 m
296.921 664.806 l
292.921 664.806 m
296.921 660.806 l
306.184 660.754 m
310.184 664.754 l
306.184 664.754 m
310.184 660.754 l
319.447 660.582 m
323.447 664.583 l
319.447 664.583 m
323.447 660.582 l
332.711 660.006 m
336.711 664.006 l
332.711 664.006 m
336.711 660.006 l
345.974 658.043 m
349.974 662.043 l
345.974 662.043 m
349.974 658.043 l
359.237 662.121 m
363.237 666.121 l
359.237 666.121 m
363.237 662.121 l
372.5 661.492 m
376.5 665.492 l
372.5 665.492 m
376.5 661.492 l
122.5 596.664 m
135.763 596.807 l
149.026 596.416 l
162.289 615.467 l
175.553 627.363 l
188.816 631.264 l
202.079 632.45 l
215.342 643.465 l
228.605 642.255 l
241.868 642.536 l
255.132 643.16 l
268.395 642.498 l
281.658 642.359 l
294.921 642.398 l
308.184 643.074 l
321.447 642.812 l
334.711 642.722 l
347.974 641.926 l
361.237 641.864 l
374.5 641.612 l
S 
124.5 594.664 m
122.5 598.664 l
120.5 594.664 l
b 
137.763 594.807 m
135.763 598.807 l
133.763 594.807 l
b 
151.026 594.416 m
149.026 598.416 l
147.026 594.416 l
b 
164.289 613.467 m
162.289 617.467 l
160.289 613.467 l
b 
177.553 625.363 m
175.553 629.363 l
173.553 625.363 l
b 
190.816 629.264 m
188.816 633.264 l
186.816 629.264 l
b 
204.079 630.45 m
202.079 634.45 l
200.079 630.45 l
b 
217.342 641.465 m
215.342 645.465 l
213.342 641.465 l
b 
230.605 640.255 m
228.605 644.255 l
226.605 640.255 l
b 
243.868 640.536 m
241.868 644.536 l
239.868 640.536 l
b 
257.132 641.16 m
255.132 645.16 l
253.132 641.16 l
b 
270.395 640.498 m
268.395 644.498 l
266.395 640.498 l
b 
283.658 640.359 m
281.658 644.359 l
279.658 640.359 l
b 
296.921 640.398 m
294.921 644.398 l
292.921 640.398 l
b 
310.184 641.074 m
308.184 645.074 l
306.184 641.074 l
b 
323.447 640.812 m
321.447 644.812 l
319.447 640.812 l
b 
336.711 640.722 m
334.711 644.722 l
332.711 640.722 l
b 
349.974 639.926 m
347.974 643.926 l
345.974 639.926 l
b 
363.237 639.864 m
361.237 643.864 l
359.237 639.864 l
b 
376.5 639.612 m
374.5 643.612 l
372.5 639.612 l
b 
122.5 596.602 m
135.763 596.749 l
149.026 596.749 l
162.289 596.716 l
175.553 596.64 l
188.816 596.468 l
202.079 596.43 l
215.342 596.726 l
228.605 596.54 l
241.868 596.826 l
255.132 596.435 l
268.395 596.473 l
281.658 596.23 l
294.921 596.516 l
308.184 596.497 l
321.447 596.526 l
334.711 596.645 l
347.974 596.93 l
361.237 596.64 l
374.5 597.159 l
122.5 585.021 m
135.763 584.778 l
149.026 584.949 l
162.289 584.978 l
175.553 584.52 l
188.816 584.668 l
202.079 584.74 l
215.342 584.963 l
228.605 584.406 l
241.868 585.021 l
255.132 584.725 l
268.395 584.897 l
281.658 585.044 l
294.921 585.073 l
308.184 584.906 l
321.447 584.787 l
334.711 584.811 l
347.974 584.463 l
361.237 584.72 l
374.5 584.849 l
120.5 585.021 m
124.5 585.021 l
122.5 583.021 m
122.5 587.021 l
133.763 584.778 m
137.763 584.778 l
135.763 582.778 m
135.763 586.778 l
147.026 584.949 m
151.026 584.949 l
149.026 582.949 m
149.026 586.949 l
160.289 584.978 m
164.289 584.978 l
162.289 582.978 m
162.289 586.978 l
173.553 584.52 m
177.553 584.52 l
175.553 582.52 m
175.553 586.52 l
186.816 584.668 m
190.816 584.668 l
188.816 582.668 m
188.816 586.668 l
200.079 584.74 m
204.079 584.74 l
202.079 582.74 m
202.079 586.74 l
213.342 584.963 m
217.342 584.963 l
215.342 582.963 m
215.342 586.963 l
226.605 584.406 m
230.605 584.406 l
228.605 582.406 m
228.605 586.406 l
239.868 585.021 m
243.868 585.021 l
241.868 583.021 m
241.868 587.021 l
253.132 584.725 m
257.132 584.725 l
255.132 582.725 m
255.132 586.725 l
266.395 584.897 m
270.395 584.897 l
268.395 582.897 m
268.395 586.897 l
279.658 585.044 m
283.658 585.044 l
281.658 583.044 m
281.658 587.044 l
292.921 585.073 m
296.921 585.073 l
294.921 583.073 m
294.921 587.073 l
306.184 584.906 m
310.184 584.906 l
308.184 582.906 m
308.184 586.906 l
319.447 584.787 m
323.447 584.787 l
321.447 582.787 m
321.447 586.787 l
332.711 584.811 m
336.711 584.811 l
334.711 582.811 m
334.711 586.811 l
345.974 584.463 m
349.974 584.463 l
347.974 582.463 m
347.974 586.463 l
359.237 584.72 m
363.237 584.72 l
361.237 582.72 m
361.237 586.72 l
372.5 584.849 m
376.5 584.849 l
374.5 582.849 m
374.5 586.849 l
S 
[1 3.2 ]0 d
122.5 585.368 m
135.763 585.535 l
149.026 585.759 l
162.289 585.549 l
175.553 585.468 l
188.816 586.154 l
202.079 585.492 l
215.342 585.649 l
228.605 585.411 l
241.868 585.287 l
255.132 585.278 l
268.395 584.935 l
281.658 584.816 l
294.921 584.873 l
308.184 584.987 l
321.447 585.673 l
334.711 585.716 l
347.974 585.797 l
361.237 585.768 l
374.5 586.193 l
S 
[4 ]0 d
122.5 581.338 m
135.763 581.348 l
149.026 581.395 l
162.289 581.405 l
175.553 581.348 l
188.816 580.957 l
202.079 581.167 l
215.342 581.224 l
228.605 581.281 l
241.868 581.295 l
255.132 581.386 l
268.395 581.295 l
281.658 581.305 l
294.921 581.309 l
308.184 581.314 l
321.447 581.429 l
334.711 581.552 l
347.974 581.362 l
361.237 581.476 l
374.5 581.938 l
S 
[]0 d
389.5 680.3 m
413.5 680.3 l
S 
403.52 680.28 m
403.52 681.384 402.624 682.28 401.52 682.28 c
400.416 682.28 399.52 681.384 399.52 680.28 c
399.52 679.176 400.416 678.28 401.52 678.28 c
402.624 678.28 403.52 679.176 403.52 680.28 c
B 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 677.6 Tm
(Original-RecSyncStmt)Tj
ET
389.5 669.5 m
413.5 669.5 l
S 
399.5 667.5 4 4 re
B 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 666.8 Tm
(Original-RecSyncMethod      )Tj
ET
389.5 658.7 m
413.5 658.7 l
399.5 656.7 m
403.5 660.7 l
399.5 660.7 m
403.5 656.7 l
S 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 656 Tm
(Original-SyncStmt)Tj
ET
389.5 647.9 m
413.5 647.9 l
S 
403.5 645.9 m
401.5 649.9 l
399.5 645.9 l
b 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 645.2 Tm
(Original-SyncMethod)Tj
ET
389.5 637.1 m
413.5 637.1 l
S 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 634.4 Tm
(EVM-RecSyncStmt)Tj
ET
389.5 626.3 m
413.5 626.3 l
399.5 626.3 m
403.5 626.3 l
401.5 624.3 m
401.5 628.3 l
S 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 623.6 Tm
(EVM-RecSyncMethod)Tj
ET
[1 3.2 ]0 d
389.5 615.5 m
413.5 615.5 l
S 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 612.8 Tm
(EVM-SyncStmt)Tj
ET
[4 ]0 d
389.5 604.7 m
413.5 604.7 l
S 
BT
9 0 0 9 417.5 602 Tm
(EVM-SyncMethod)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 225.25 516.5 Tm
(Figure 10. Cost of synchronization)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 25 25
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(22)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
-19 56.4858 TD
0 Tw
[(7.3.2  Beha)26 (vior of our algorithm on r)18 (ealistic pr)18 (ograms)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
0 -1.8333 TD
[(Consider)-325 (no)25 (w)-325 (the)-325 (algorithm\325)55 (s)-324 (beha)20 (vior)-325 (on)-325 (realistic)-324 (programs.)-324 (W)80 (e)-325 (\336rst)-325 (study)-325 (the)-325 (\322pure\323)-325 (form)-324 (of)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-231 (meta-lock)-231 (algorithm,)-232 (without)-231 (e)16 (xtra)-232 (f)11 (ast)-231 (locking)-232 (and)-231 (unlocking.)-231 (In)-231 (this)-231 (case,)-231 (each)-231 (monitor)20 (-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)]TJ
T*
[(synchronization)-297 (operation)-298 (in)40 (v)20 (olv)16 (es)-299 (a)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
15.115 0 TD
(getMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.0983 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.7417 0 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.4983 0 TD
[(call.)-298 (The)]TJ
-35.4533 -1.1667 TD
[(left)-309 (half)-308 (of)-308 (T)79 (able)-250 (3)-308 (sho)25 (ws)-308 (that)-308 (the)-309 (f)10 (ast)-309 (path)-308 (is)-309 (tak)10 (en)-308 (in)-309 (all)-308 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-309 (a)0 (n)-308 (e)15 (xtremely)-308 (small)-309 (fraction)-308 (of)-309 (the)]TJ
T*
[(cases;)-337 (that)-337 (is,)-337 (meta-lock)-337 (contention)-337 (is)-337 (e)15 (xtremely)-337 (rare.)-337 (W)80 (e)-337 (instrumented)-337 (only)-337 (meta-lock)-337 (acquisi-)]TJ
T*
[(tion,)-281 (since)-281 (the)-281 (algorithm)-281 (is)-280 (such)-281 (that)-281 (the)-280 (number)-281 (of)-281 (f)11 (ast/slo)25 (w)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
24.7475 0 TD
(getMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
8.0808 0 TD
[(calls)-280 (equals)-282 (the)]TJ
-32.8283 -1.1667 TD
[(number of f)10 (ast/slo)25 (w)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
8.2142 0 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
( calls.)Tj
-18.4142 -30 TD
[(Ha)20 (ving)-234 (con\336rmed)-233 (that)-234 (the)-234 (meta-locking)-233 (f)10 (ast)-234 (paths)-233 (dominate,)-234 (let)-233 (us)-233 (study)-234 (those)-234 (f)11 (ast)-234 (paths)-233 (on)-234 (a)-234 (typ-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(ical)-303 (RISC)-304 (processor)56 (.)-304 (Figure)-250 (11)-304 (sho)25 (ws)-304 (the)-304 (SP)92 (ARC)-304 (instructions)-304 (that)-303 (result)-305 (from)-303 (translating)-304 (a)-304 (syn-)]TJ
T*
(chronization operation of the form:)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 108 199.33 Tm
(multiUseWord = getMetaLock\(ee, obj\);)Tj
2.4 -1.2 TD
(newMultiUseWord = bodyOfSynchronizationOperation\(ee, obj,)Tj
29.4 -1.2 TD
(multiUseWord\);)Tj
-31.8 -1.2 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(ee, obj, newMultiUseWord\);)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 143 Tm
[(On)-345 (entry)65 (,)-346 (w)0 (e)-346 (assume)-345 (that)-346 (re)15 (gister)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
14.1292 0 TD
(%i0)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.1458 0 TD
[(holds)-345 (the)-346 (address)-345 (of)-345 (the)-345 (e)15 (x)15 (ecution)-346 (en)41 (vironment)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
19.735 0 TD
(ee)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.5458 0 TD
(and)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-37.5558 -1.1667 TD
(%i1)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.0475 0 TD
[(holds)-247 (the)-247 (address)-248 (of)-247 (an)-247 (object)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
12.0925 0 TD
(obj)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.8 0 TD
[(.)-247 (I)0 (t)-247 (tak)10 (es)-247 (se)25 (v)15 (e)0 (n)-248 (instructions)-247 (to)-247 (perform)-247 (the)-247 (f)10 (ast)-247 (path)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
20.66 0 TD
(get-)Tj
-36.6 -1.1667 TD
(MetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
6 0 TD
[(,)-302 (including)-303 (e)15 (xtracting)-302 (the)-302 (high)-303 (30)-302 (bits)-303 (of)-302 (the)-303 (multi-use)-303 (w)10 (ord)-303 (into)-302 (one)-303 (re)15 (gister)-302 (and)]TJ
-6 -1.1667 TD
[(the)-242 (lo)26 (w)-242 (2)-243 (bits)-242 (\(the)-242 (lock)-242 (state\))-242 (into)-241 (another)55 (.)-242 (The)-242 (code)-242 (for)-242 (the)-241 (body)-242 (of)-242 (the)-242 (synchronization)-242 (operation)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ould)-344 (follo)25 (w)64 (.)-343 (At)-343 (the)-344 (end,)-343 (we)-343 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-344 (4)-343 (instructions)-344 (for)-344 (the)-343 (f)10 (ast)-343 (path)-344 (of)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
28.55 0 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
(.)Tj
-27.9783 41.25 TD
[(T)80 (able 3. Frequenc)16 (y of meta-lock contention)]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
10 0 0 10 220.65 557.33 Tm
[(without extra fast)-10388 (with extra fast)]TJ
-12.542 -1.7 TD
[(Benchmark)-3832 (# getMetaLock)-1246 (#getMetaLockSlo)10 (w)-1246 (#)0 ( getMetaLock)-1375 (#getMetaLockSlo)10 (w)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
T*
[(Hello)-11647 (3,054)-8059 (0)-6309 (1,418)-8317 (0)]TJ
T*
[(_201_compress)-7092 (22,180)-8059 (3)-6309 (2,269)-8317 (2)]TJ
T*
[(_202_jess)-8119 (9,619,742)-7559 (19)-6309 (4,171)-7817 (10)]TJ
T*
[(_209_db)-7619 (106,829,540)-8059 (1)-6309 (2,024)-8317 (5)]TJ
T*
[(_213_ja)20 (v)25 (a)0 (c)-7054 (34,380,756)-7559 (50)-5809 (39,949)-7817 (61)]TJ
T*
[(_222_mpe)15 (gaudio)-6445 (22,813)-7559 (10)-6309 (2,620)-8317 (5)]TJ
T*
[(_227_mtrt)-7952 (1,424,925)-8059 (1)-6309 (2,397)-8317 (3)]TJ
T*
[(_228_jack)-7453 (23,851,600)-8059 (8)-6309 (2,979)-8317 (5)]TJ
T*
[(_224_richards)-7648 (70,560)-7559 (59)-6309 (3,434)-7817 (52)]TJ
T*
[(_233_tmix)-7785 (8,711,428)-6309 (1,612)-4559 (2,183,531)-6567 (1,730)]TJ
T*
[(SwingMark)-7397 (4,062,787)-6309 (2,508)-5309 (465,758)-6567 (1,977)]TJ
T*
[(v)20 (olano serv)15 (er)-6739 (9,622,570)-7059 (587)-5309 (209,341)-7317 (542)]TJ
T*
[(v)20 (olano client)-6945 (9,495,680)-8059 (6)-5809 (17,625)-8317 (3)]TJ
T*
[(JWS)-10230 (1,783,691)-6309 (7,800)-5309 (162,586)-6567 (2,743)]TJ
ET
0 G
0 J
0 j
0.6 w
3.86 M
[]0 d
94.23 296.25 m
94.23 550.75 l
B* 
172.83 295.75 m
172.83 567.75 l
B* 
258.42 295.75 m
258.42 551.25 l
B* 
344.01 295.75 m
344.01 568.25 l
B* 
429.6 295.75 m
429.6 551.25 l
B* 
517.77 296.25 m
517.77 567.75 l
B* 
518.02 568 m
172.58 568 l
B* 
518.02 551 m
93.98 551 l
B* 
517.52 535.25 m
94.48 535.25 l
B* 
517.52 532.75 m
94.48 532.75 l
B* 
517.52 518.25 m
94.48 518.25 l
B* 
517.52 515.75 m
94.48 515.75 l
B* 
518.02 500 m
93.98 500 l
B* 
518.02 483 m
93.98 483 l
B* 
518.02 466 m
93.98 466 l
B* 
518.02 449 m
93.98 449 l
B* 
518.02 432 m
93.98 432 l
B* 
518.02 415 m
93.98 415 l
B* 
517.52 399.25 m
94.48 399.25 l
B* 
517.52 396.75 m
94.48 396.75 l
B* 
518.02 381 m
93.98 381 l
B* 
518.02 364 m
93.98 364 l
B* 
518.02 347 m
93.98 347 l
B* 
518.02 330 m
93.98 330 l
B* 
518.02 313 m
93.98 313 l
B* 
518.02 296 m
93.98 296 l
B* 
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 26 26
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(23)Tj
-19 36.2892 TD
[(This)-369 (gi)25 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-369 (u)0 (s)-370 (a)-369 (total)-370 (of)-369 (11)-369 (instructions)-370 (for)-370 (the)-370 (f)11 (ast)-370 (paths)-370 (of)-369 (meta-lock)-370 (acquisition)-369 (and)-370 (release.)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(While)-327 (a)-327 (careful)-326 (analysis)-327 (of)-327 (the)-326 (c)15 (ycles)-327 (consumed)-326 (by)-327 (an)-327 (optimal)-327 (implementation)-326 (is)-327 (interesting)-326 (in)]TJ
T*
[(the)-263 (conte)15 (xt)-263 (of)-262 (a)-263 (particular)-263 (architecture,)-262 (for)-263 (the)-262 (present)-263 (purposes)-262 (we)-263 (shall)-263 (be)-263 (satis\336ed)-262 (with)-263 (consid-)]TJ
T*
[(ering)-413 (the)-414 (SP)92 (ARC)-414 (implementation)-413 (representati)25 (v)15 (e)-413 (of)-414 (a)-414 (typical)-414 (RISC)-414 (implementation.)-413 (The)-413 (most)]TJ
T*
[(costly)-427 (instructions)-427 (are)-426 (the)-427 (tw)10 (o)-427 (atomic)-426 (instructions,)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
21.6158 0 TD
(swap)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.8267 0 TD
(in)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
1.205 0 TD
(getMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
7.8 0 TD
[(,)-427 (and)]TJ
/N95 1 Tf
2.5475 0 TD
(cas)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.2267 0 TD
(in)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
-38.2217 -1.1667 TD
(releaseMetaLock\(\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.2 0 TD
0 Tw
(.)Tj
-10.2 -1.75 TD
[(No)25 (w)-276 (consider)-275 (the)-276 (performance)-276 (of)-275 (the)-276 (system)-275 (with)-276 (e)15 (xtra)-276 (f)10 (ast)-276 (synchronization)-276 (enabled.)-276 (Recall)-276 (that)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(this)-323 (optimization)-323 (fuses)-323 (meta-locking)-323 (and)-323 (monitor)20 (-locking)-323 (to)-324 (allo)25 (w)-323 (monitor)21 (-lock)-323 (acquisition)-323 (and)]TJ
T*
[(release)-326 (each)-326 (with)-326 (a)-326 (single)-326 (atomic)-326 (instruction)-326 (in)-326 (uncontended)-326 (cases,)-326 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-326 (i)0 (n)-326 (contended)-326 (cases)-327 (f)11 (alls)]TJ
T*
[(back)-229 (to)-229 (the)-230 (meta-lock)-229 (protocol)-229 (for)-230 (a)-229 (total)-229 (cost)-230 (of)-229 (three)-229 (atomic)-230 (instructions.)-229 (If)-229 (monitor)20 (-lock)-229 (conten-)]TJ
T*
[(tion)-261 (is)-261 (rare,)-262 (as)-261 (Bacon)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
8.7225 0 TD
[(et)-261 (al)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
1.7617 0 TD
[(.)70 (\325)56 (s)-262 (data)-261 (indicate)-261 ([3],)-261 (this)-261 (will)-261 (be)-262 (a)-261 (net)-262 (win;)-261 (otherwise,)-261 (it)-261 (could)-262 (be)-261 (a)-262 (loss.)]TJ
-10.4842 -1.1667 TD
[(T)80 (able)-250 (1)-402 (sho)25 (ws)-401 (the)-401 (bottom)-402 (line)-401 (on)-402 (e)15 (xtra)-402 (f)10 (ast)-401 (synchronization)-402 (for)-401 (our)-401 (benchmarks:)-401 (no)-401 (program)]TJ
T*
[(slo)25 (ws)-354 (do)25 (wn,)-353 (and)-353 (se)25 (v)15 (eral)-353 (speed)-354 (up)-353 (signi\336cantly)65 (.)-353 (Comparing)-353 (the)-354 (left)-354 (and)-353 (right)-353 (halv)15 (es)-354 (of)-354 (T)80 (able)-250 (3)]TJ
T*
[(sho)25 (ws)-276 (that)-276 (the)-276 (speedup)-276 (results)-276 (from)-276 (a)-276 (signi\336cant)-276 (reduction)-275 (in)-276 (the)-276 (number)-276 (of)-276 (meta-locking)-275 (opera-)]TJ
T*
[(tions,)-313 (con\336rming)-313 (that)-313 (monitor)20 (-lock)-313 (contention)-314 (is)-313 (indeed)-314 (rare.)-313 (Ho)25 (we)25 (v)15 (e)0 (r)40 (,)-313 (T)80 (able)-250 (3)-313 (also)-314 (sho)25 (ws)-313 (that,)]TJ
T*
[(for)-433 (some)-432 (programs,)-433 (the)-433 (f)10 (all-back)-433 (case)-433 (is)-433 (suf)25 (\336ciently)-433 (frequent)-433 (that)-432 (its)-432 (performance)-433 (cannot)-433 (be)]TJ
T*
[(ne)15 (glected.)-263 (Finally)65 (,)-264 (the)-264 (similar)-264 (number)-263 (of)-264 (slo)25 (w)-264 (meta-lock)-264 (operations)-263 (in)-264 (the)-264 (left)-264 (and)-263 (right)-264 (halv)15 (es)-264 (of)]TJ
T*
[(T)80 (able)-250 (3)-279 (implies)-279 (that)-278 (e)15 (xtra)-279 (f)10 (ast)-279 (synchronization)-278 (does)-279 (not)-279 (reduce)-279 (contention)-279 (on)-279 (the)-279 (meta-lock.)-279 (\(F)16 (or)]TJ
T*
[(completeness,)-286 (we)-286 (should)-286 (mention)-285 (that)-286 (a)-286 (f)0 (e)25 (w)-285 (of)-286 (the)-285 (meta-lock)-286 (operations)-286 (that)-286 (remain)-285 (when)-286 (using)]TJ
T*
[(e)15 (xtra)-304 (f)10 (ast)-304 (synchronization)-304 (result)-304 (from)-303 (layers)-304 (in)-304 (EVM,)-304 (such)-304 (as)-304 (class)-304 (loading)-304 (and)-303 (JNI,)-304 (that)-304 (do)-303 (not)]TJ
T*
[(use the e)15 (xtra f)11 (ast operations.\))]TJ
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 147.98 Tm
[(8  Conclusions and futur)18 (e w)10 (ork)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 124.64 Tm
[(W)80 (e)-251 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-251 (presented)-250 (a)-251 (meta-locking)-251 (algorithm)-251 (that)-251 (supports)-251 (a)-251 (v)25 (ariety)-251 (of)-250 (higher)20 (-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-251 (locking)-251 (proto-)]TJ
T*
[(cols,)-319 (by)-319 (pro)15 (viding)-319 (e)15 (xclusi)25 (v)15 (e)-319 (access)-319 (to)-319 (the)-320 (data)-319 (structures)-319 (used)-319 (in)-319 (the)-319 (higher)20 (-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-320 (protocol.)-318 (This)]TJ
T*
[(meta-locking)-258 (algorithm)-257 (has)-258 (se)26 (v)15 (eral)-258 (virtues.)-258 (Lik)10 (e)-258 (the)-258 (HotSpot)-257 (system)-258 (that)-257 (introduced)-258 (header)-257 (w)10 (ord)]TJ
T*
[(displacement,)-349 (the)-350 (meta-locking)-349 (algorithm)-350 (is)-350 (highly)-351 (space-ef)25 (\336cient,)-350 (requiring)-350 (only)-350 (tw)10 (o)-350 (reserv)16 (ed)]TJ
T*
[(bits)-263 (in)-264 (each)-264 (object,)-263 (and)-263 (a)-264 (number)-263 (of)-264 (lock)-263 (records)-264 (that)-264 (is)-263 (small)-264 (for)-263 (normal)-264 (programs.)-264 (It)-263 (is)-264 (also)-263 (rea-)]TJ
5.2808 37.3217 TD
[(Figure 11. F)16 (ast path for a synchronization operation wrapped)]TJ
7.38 -1 TD
(in meta-lock and unlock)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
8 0 0 8 99 711.17 Tm
(! getMetaLock)Tj
0 -1.25 TD
(or      %i0, 3, %l0             ! %l0 = my busy value)Tj
T*
(add     %i1, 4, %l1             ! %l1 = multi-use word address)Tj
T*
(swap    [%l1], %l0              ! Swap out busy value)Tj
T*
(and     %l0, 3, %l2             ! %l2 = meta-lock state)Tj
T*
(cmp     %l2, 3                  ! Is lock state busy?)Tj
T*
(beq     slowGetMetaLockPath)Tj
T*
(sub     %l0, %l2, %l0           ! In delay slot compute high 30 bits)Tj
19.2 -1.25 TD
(! Slow path gets predecessor EE in %l0)Tj
T*
(! and synch operation gets lock)Tj
T*
(! record pointer or age&hash in %l0)Tj
-19.2 -1.25 TD
(... %l2 = body of synchronization operation)Tj
T*
(! releaseMetaLock)Tj
T*
(or      %i0, 3, %l0             ! %l0 = my busy value)Tj
T*
(cas     [%l1], %l0, %l2         ! if [%l1] == %l0 then swap\([%l0],%l2\)\
)Tj
T*
(cmp     %l0, %l2                ! did we do the swap?)Tj
T*
(bne     slowReleaseMetaLockPath)Tj
T*
(! unfilled delay slot here)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 27 27
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(24)Tj
-19 56.4858 TD
[(sonably)-270 (time-ef)25 (\336cient)-270 (in)-269 (the)-270 (normal)-270 (case,)-270 (requiring)-270 (7)-270 (instructions)-269 (to)-270 (acquire)-269 (and)-270 (4)-270 (instructions)-269 (to)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(release)-454 (an)-454 (uncontended)-454 (meta-lock.)-454 (Each)-454 (of)-454 (those)-454 (paths)-454 (includes)-454 (a)-454 (single)-454 (atomic)-454 (instruction.)]TJ
T*
[(Finally)65 (,)-342 (i)0 (t)-343 (i)0 (s)-343 (careful)-343 (to)-343 (a)20 (v)20 (oid)-343 (pathologies)-343 (when)-343 (there)-343 (is)-343 (contention:)-343 (the)-343 (algorithm)-342 (introduces)-343 (no)]TJ
T*
0 Tw
[(b)20 (usy-w)10 (aiting, and only v)15 (ery rarely allocates from global memory)66 (.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(W)80 (e)-397 (ha)20 (v)15 (e)-397 (also)-397 (presented)-397 (a)-398 (particular)-397 (higher)20 (-le)25 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-397 (locking)-397 (protocol,)-397 (based)-397 (on)-397 (this)-397 (meta-locking)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(algorithm,)-267 (for)-267 (the)-267 (synchronization)-267 (primiti)26 (v)15 (e)0 (s)-268 (o)0 (f)-267 (the)-268 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-268 (virtual)-267 (machine.)-268 (An)-267 (optimization)-267 (of)-268 (this)]TJ
T*
[(protocol)-248 (gains)-249 (the)-249 (ef)25 (\336cienc)15 (y)-249 (o)0 (f)-249 (a)20 (v)20 (oiding)-248 (meta-locking)-249 (in)-249 (most)-249 (cases,)-248 (b)20 (u)0 (t)-249 (the)-248 (ability)-249 (to)-249 (f)10 (all)-248 (back)-249 (to)]TJ
T*
[(meta-locking in uncommon cases re)16 (gularizes and simpli\336es the protocol.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(Finally)65 (,)-274 (w)0 (e)-275 (h)0 (a)20 (v)15 (e)-274 (implemented)-274 (and)-275 (v)25 (alidated)-275 (the)-275 (performance)-274 (of)-274 (the)-275 (meta-lock)-274 (in)-275 (the)-275 (conte)15 (xt)-274 (of)-274 (a)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(high-performance)-427 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-428 (virtual)-427 (machine.)-428 (Our)-427 (measurements,)-428 (which)-428 (include)-428 (a)-428 (study)-428 (of)-428 (se)26 (v)15 (eral)]TJ
T*
[(multi-threaded)-257 (programs)-258 (running)-257 (on)-257 (a)-258 (4-CPU)-257 (system,)-258 (indicate)-257 (that)-257 (the)-257 (meta-lock)-257 (algorithm)-257 (oper-)]TJ
T*
[(ates)-323 (with)-323 (a)-323 (l)0 (o)26 (w)-323 (contention)-324 (rate)-323 (to)-323 (ensure)-323 (that)-323 (the)-323 (f)10 (ast)-323 (path)-323 (strongly)-323 (dominates)-323 (the)-323 (performance.)]TJ
T*
[(Synthetic)-366 (benchmarks)-366 (designed)-366 (to)-366 (isolate)-366 (the)-366 (cost)-366 (of)-366 (synchronization)-366 (indicate)-366 (that)-366 (our)-366 (scheme)]TJ
T*
[(outperforms the original monitor cache scheme by a f)11 (actor of three or more.)]TJ
0 -1.75 TD
[(In)-241 (the)-242 (future,)-241 (we)-241 (may)-241 (w)10 (ork)-241 (on)-242 (e)15 (xtending)-241 (the)-242 (e)16 (xtra)-242 (f)10 (ast)-241 (instruction)-241 (sequences)-242 (to)-241 (handle)-241 (more)-242 (cases)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(while)-309 (continuing)-308 (to)-309 (use)-309 (the)-309 (meta-lock)-309 (protocol)-308 (as)-309 (a)-309 (comfortable)-309 (f)10 (all-back.)-309 (F)14 (o)0 (r)-309 (e)15 (xample,)-308 (if)-309 (mea-)]TJ
T*
[(surements)-317 (justify)-317 (it,)-318 (e)15 (xtra)-317 (f)11 (ast)-318 (locking)-317 (could)-317 (be)-318 (e)15 (xtended)-317 (to)-318 (allo)25 (w)-317 (a)-318 (non-empty)-318 (queue)-318 (with)-318 (lock)]TJ
T*
(state)Tj
/N95 1 Tf
2.135 0 TD
(WAITERS)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.2 0 TD
[(.)-302 (W)81 (e)-303 (are)-301 (also)-302 (in)40 (v)15 (estigating)-302 (whether)-302 (the)-302 (high-le)26 (v)15 (e)0 (l)-302 (synchronization)-302 (state)-302 (could)-302 (be)]TJ
-6.335 -1.1667 TD
[(made)-298 (to)-299 (in\337uence)-298 (the)-298 (order)-299 (in)-298 (which)-298 (threads)-299 (acquire)-298 (meta-locks.)-298 (F)15 (o)0 (r)-299 (e)16 (xample,)-298 (it)-299 (might)-298 (impro)15 (v)15 (e)]TJ
T*
[(ef)25 (\336cienc)14 (y)-257 (i)0 (f)-257 (a)-258 (thread)-258 (attempting)-258 (to)-258 (release)-257 (a)-258 (monitor)20 (-lock)-257 (could)-258 (be)-258 (gi)26 (v)14 (e)0 (n)-258 (preferential)-257 (treatment)-258 (at)]TJ
T*
[(the meta-lock le)25 (v)15 (el.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
0 -1.75 TD
[(Ac)20 (knowledgments.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
7.6825 0 TD
[(Lars)-232 (Bak,)-231 (Da)20 (vid)-232 (Dice,)-231 (Da)20 (vid)-232 (Holmes,)-231 (Urs)-232 (H\232lzle,)-232 (Doug)-231 (Lea,)-232 (and)-231 (Hong)-232 (Zhang)]TJ
-7.6825 -1.1667 TD
[(pro)15 (vided v)15 (ery useful comments on a draft of the paper)56 (.)]TJ
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 28 28
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(25)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
16 0 0 16 72 709.33 Tm
[(Refer)18 (ences)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 686 Tm
[(1.)-750 (Tom)-231 (Anderson.)-232 (The)-231 (Performance)-231 (of)-232 (Spin)-231 (Lock)-232 (Alternatives)-231 (for)-231 (Shared-Memory)-231 (Multiproces-)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
(sors.)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
2.1108 0 TD
0 Tw
(IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems,)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
22.8892 0 TD
(1\(1\), p. 6-16, January 1990.)Tj
-26.44 -1.4167 TD
[(2.)-750 (Ken)-341 (Arnold)-340 (and)-341 (James)-341 (Gosling.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
15.0075 0 TD
[(The)-341 (Java)-340 (Programming)-340 (Language)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
14.0208 0 TD
[(.)-341 (The)-341 (Java)-340 (Series,)-340 (Addi-)]TJ
-27.5883 -1.1667 TD
(son-Wesley, 1996.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(3.)-750 (David)-392 (F.)-391 (Bacon,)-392 (Ravi)-391 (Konuru,)-391 (Chet)-392 (Murthy,)-391 (and)-392 (Mauricio)-391 (Serrano.)-391 (Thin)-391 (Locks:)-392 (Feather-)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
[(weight)-309 (Synchronization)-309 (for)-309 (Java.)-309 (In)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
14.8475 0 TD
[(Proc.)-308 (ACM)-309 (SIGPLAN)-309 (\32498)-309 (Conference)-309 (on)-309 (Programming)]TJ
-14.8475 -1.1667 TD
(Language Design and Implementation \(PLDI\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
18.4983 0 TD
(, p. 258-268, Montreal, Canada, June 1998.)Tj
-19.9383 -1.4167 TD
[(4.)-750 (Lars)-245 (Bak,)-244 (presentation)-244 (on)-244 (the)-245 (HotSpot)-244 (JVM,)-245 (Panel:)-244 (The)-244 (New)-244 (Crop)-245 (Of)-244 (Java)-245 (Virtual)-244 (Machines.)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
(In)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
1.2342 0 TD
[(Proc.)-401 (ACM)-401 (SIGPLAN)-401 (\32498)-401 (Conference)-401 (on)-401 (Object-Oriented)-401 (Programming)-400 (Systems,)-400 (Lan-)]TJ
-1.2342 -1.1667 TD
(guages, and Applications)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
10.1392 0 TD
(, p. 179-182, Vancouver, Canada, October 1998.)Tj
-11.5792 -1.4167 TD
[(5.)-750 (Andrew)-389 (Birrell.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
8.36 0 TD
[(An)-389 (Introduction)-389 (to)-389 (Programming)-389 (with)-389 (Threads)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
19.4458 0 TD
[(.)-389 (Digital)-389 (Systems)-389 (Research)]TJ
-26.3658 -1.1667 TD
(Center report no. 35, 1989.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(6.)-750 (David)-226 (R.)-226 (Butenhof.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
9.5108 0 TD
[(Programming)-226 (with)-225 (POSIX)]TJ
9.6 0 0 9.6 312.89 507.8 Tm
(\250)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 322.9 503 Tm
[(Threads.)-225 (Addison-Wesley)-225 (Professional)-226 (Com-)]TJ
-19.4683 -1.1667 TD
(puting Series, 1997.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(7.)-750 (Peter)-269 (A.)-268 (Buhr,)-269 (Michel)-269 (Fortier,)-269 (and)-268 (Michael)-269 (H.)-269 (Coffin.)-269 (Monitor)-268 (Classification.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
33.12 0 TD
[(ACM)-269 (Comput-)]TJ
-31.68 -1.1667 TD
(ing Surveys)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
4.6383 0 TD
(, 27\(1\), p. 63-107, March 1995.)Tj
-6.0783 -1.4167 TD
[(8.)-750 (Sylvia)-387 (Dieckmann)-386 (and)-387 (Urs)-387 (H\232lzle.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
16.405 0 TD
[(A)-387 (Study)-386 (of)-387 (the)-387 (Allocation)-387 (Behavior)-387 (of)-387 (the)-386 (SPECjvm98)]TJ
-14.965 -1.1667 TD
[(Java)-304 (Benchmarks)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
7.1342 0 TD
[(.)-303 (Technical)-303 (Report)-303 (TRCS98-33,)-303 (Computer)-303 (Science)-303 (Department,)-304 (University)]TJ
-7.1342 -1.1667 TD
(of California, Santa Barbara, December 1998.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(9.)-750 (Edsgar)-233 (Dijkstra.)-234 (Solution)-233 (of)-234 (a)-233 (Problem)-233 (in)-234 (Concurrent)-233 (Programming)-233 (Control.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
32.2217 0 TD
(Communications)Tj
-30.7817 -1.1667 TD
[(of the A)30 (C)0 (M)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
4.5808 0 TD
( 8\(9\), p. 569, August 1965.)Tj
-6.0208 -1.4167 TD
[(10.)-250 (Michael)-324 (Greenwald)-324 (and)-325 (David)-325 (Cheriton.)-325 (The)-325 (Synergy)-324 (Between)-325 (Non-blocking)-325 (Synchroniza-)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
[(tion)-350 (and)-350 (Operating)-350 (System)-351 (Structure.)-350 (In)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
16.7942 0 TD
[(2nd)-350 (Symposium)-350 (on)-350 (Operating)-350 (Systems)-350 (Design)-350 (and)]TJ
-16.7942 -1.1667 TD
(Implementation \(OSDI \32596\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
11.0533 0 TD
(, p. 123-136, Seattle, WA, October 1996.)Tj
-12.4933 -1.4167 TD
[(11.)-250 (Per)-239 (Brinch)-239 (Hansen.)-239 (Monitors)-239 (and)-239 (Concurrent)-238 (Pascal:)-239 (a)-239 (personal)-238 (history.)-238 (In)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
31.5683 0 TD
[(Pr)45 (oceedings)-238 (of)-239 (the)]TJ
-30.1283 -1.1667 TD
[(Second)-396 (A)30 (C)0 (M)-397 (SIGPLAN)-396 (Confer)37 (ence)-396 (on)-396 (History)-397 (of)-396 (Pr)45 (o)10 (g)0 (r)15 (amming)-395 (Langua)9 (g)10 (e)0 (s)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
31.3992 0 TD
[(,)-397 (p)0 (.)-396 (1-35.)-396 (Pub-)]TJ
-31.3992 -1.1667 TD
(lished as)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
3.7217 0 TD
[(A)29 (CM SIGPLAN Notices)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
9.5817 0 TD
( 28\(3\), March 1993.)Tj
-14.7433 -1.4167 TD
[(12.)-250 (C.)-252 (A.)-253 (R.)-252 (Hoare.)-252 (Monitors:)-252 (An)-253 (Operating)-252 (System)-252 (Structuring)-252 (Concept.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
29.7175 0 TD
[(Communications)-252 (of)-253 (the)]TJ
-28.2775 -1.1667 TD
-0.03 Tc
[(AC)-30 (M)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
2.0808 0 TD
0 Tc
( 17\(10\), p. 549-557, October 1974.)Tj
-3.5208 -1.4167 TD
[(13.)-250 (Andreas)-355 (Krall.)-355 (Efficient)-355 (JavaVM)-355 (Just-in-Time)-355 (Compilation.)-355 (In)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
27.7067 0 TD
[(Proc.)-355 (International)-355 (Confer-)]TJ
-26.2667 -1.1667 TD
[(ence)-473 (on)-472 (Parallel)-473 (Architectures)-473 (and)-472 (Compilation)-473 (Techniques)-472 (\(PACT\32598\),)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
31.0308 0 TD
[(p.)-473 (12-18.)-473 (Paris,)]TJ
-31.0308 -1.1667 TD
(France, October 1998.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(14.)-250 (Andreas)-227 (Krall)-227 (and)-227 (Mark)-227 (Probst.)-227 (Monitors)-227 (and)-228 (Exceptions:)-227 (How)-227 (to)-228 (implement)-227 (Java)-227 (efficiently.)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
(In)Tj
/N94 1 Tf
1.0725 0 TD
[(ACM)-240 (1998)-240 (Workshop)-240 (on)-240 (Java)-239 (for)-240 (High-Performance)-239 (Computing)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
25.8992 0 TD
[(,)-240 (p)0 (.)-240 (15-24,)-239 (Palo)-240 (Alto,)-239 (Cali-)]TJ
-26.9717 -1.1667 TD
(fornia, March 1998.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(15.)-250 (Leslie)-275 (Lamport.)-276 (Proving)-275 (the)-275 (Correctness)-275 (of)-275 (Multiprocess)-275 (Programs.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
29.09 0 TD
[(IEEE)-275 (Trans.)-276 (Softw.)-275 (Eng.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
-27.65 -1.1667 TD
(SE-3, 2, p. 125-143, March 1977.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(16.)-250 (Leslie)-302 (Lamport.)-302 (A)-302 (Fast)-302 (Mutual)-302 (Exclusion)-302 (Algorithm.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
23.4467 0 TD
[(A)29 (C)0 (M)-302 (T)55 (r)15 (ansactions)-302 (on)-302 (Computing)-302 (Sys-)]TJ
-22.0067 -1.1667 TD
(tem)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
1.4442 0 TD
( 5\(1\), p. 1-11, February 1987.)Tj
-2.8842 -1.4167 TD
[(17.)-250 (Xavier)-926 (Leroy.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
8.71 0 TD
[(The)-926 (LinuxThreads)-925 (library)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
11.685 0 TD
[(.)-926 (http://pauillac.inria.fr/~xleroy/linuxthreads/)]TJ
-18.955 -1.1667 TD
(index.html, 1997.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 29 29
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(26)Tj
-19 56.4858 TD
[(18.)-250 (Timothy)-460 (Lindholm)-460 (and)-459 (Frank)-459 (Yellin.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
17.7158 0 TD
[(The)-460 (Java)-460 (Virtual)-459 (Machine)-460 (Specification)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
16.7825 0 TD
[(.)-460 (The)-460 (Java)]TJ
-33.0583 -1.1667 TD
0 Tw
(Series, Addison-Wesley, 1996.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(19.)-250 (Peter)-287 (Magnusson,)-287 (Anders)-287 (Landin,)-287 (and)-287 (Erik)-286 (Hagersten.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
23.865 0 TD
[(Ef)18 (\336cient)-288 (Softwar)37 (e)-287 (Sync)16 (hr)45 (onization)-287 (on)]TJ
-22.425 -1.1667 TD
[(Lar)37 (g)10 (e)-316 (Cac)15 (he)-316 (Coher)38 (ent)-316 (Multipr)45 (ocessor)10 (s.)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
16.5258 0 TD
[(SICS)-316 (Research)-316 (Report)-316 (T94:07,)-316 (Swedish)-316 (Institute)-315 (of)]TJ
-16.5258 -1.1667 TD
(Computer Science, Box 1263, S-164 28 Kista, Sweden, February 1994.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(20.)-250 (John)-260 (M.)-261 (Mellor-Crummey)-260 (and)-260 (Michael)-260 (L.)-261 (Scott.)-260 (Algorithms)-260 (for)-260 (Scalable)-260 (Synchronization)-260 (on)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
[(Shared-Memory)-368 (Multiprocessors.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
13.9842 0 TD
[(ACM)-368 (Transactions)-368 (on)-368 (Computer)-368 (Systems,)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
17.5908 0 TD
[(9\(1\),)-368 (p.)-367 (21-65,)]TJ
-31.575 -1.1667 TD
(1991.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(21.)-250 (Gilles)-302 (Muller,)-301 (B\207rbara)-301 (Moura,)-301 (Fabrice)-302 (Bellard,)-301 (and)-302 (Charles)-301 (Consel.)-302 (Harissa:)-301 (A)-301 (Flexible)-301 (and)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
[(Efficient)-236 (Java)-235 (Environment)-235 (Mixing)-235 (Bytecode)-236 (and)-235 (Compiled)-236 (Code.)-236 (In)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
27.9233 0 TD
[(Proc.)-236 (of)-235 (the)-235 (3rd)-236 (Confer-)]TJ
-27.9233 -1.1667 TD
[(ence)-310 (on)-309 (Object-Oriented)-309 (Technologies)-309 (and)-309 (Systems)-310 (\(COOTS\),)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
25.6342 0 TD
[(p.)-309 (1-20,)-309 (Berkeley,)-309 (California,)]TJ
-25.6342 -1.1667 TD
(June 1997.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(22.)-250 (John)-439 (Neffinger.)-439 (Which)-440 (Java)-439 (VM)-440 (scales)-439 (best?)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
21.0992 0 TD
(JavaWorld,)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
5.0775 0 TD
[(August)-440 (1998.)-439 (http://www.java-)]TJ
-24.7367 -1.1667 TD
(world.com/javaworld/jw-08-1998/jw-08-volanomark.html. See also www.volan\
o.com.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(23.)-250 (Susan)-439 (Owicki)-439 (and)-439 (Leslie)-439 (Lamport.)-439 (Proving)-439 (Liveness)-440 (Properties)-439 (of)-439 (Concurrent)-439 (Programs,)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
1.44 -1.1667 TD
(ACM Trans. Program. Lang. Syst.)Tj
/N92 1 Tf
13.9733 0 TD
(4, 3, p. 445-495, July 1982.)Tj
-15.4133 -1.4167 TD
[(24.)-250 (Todd)-234 (A.)-235 (Proebsting,)-233 (Gregg)-234 (Townsend,)-234 (Patrick)-234 (Bridges,)-234 (John)-234 (H.)-234 (Hartman,)-234 (Tim)-234 (Newsham,)-234 (and)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
[(Scott)-336 (A.)-336 (Watterson.)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
8.3967 0 TD
[(Toba:)-336 (Java)-336 (For)-337 (Applications\321A)-336 (Way)-336 (Ahead)-336 (of)-336 (Time)-337 (\(WAT\))-336 (Compiler)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
28.9133 0 TD
(.)Tj
-37.31 -1.1667 TD
(Technical Report, Dept. of Computer Science, University of Arizona, Tucs\
on, 1997.)Tj
-1.44 -1.4167 TD
[(25.)-250 (Ali-Reza)-331 (Adl-Tabatabai,)-330 (Michal)-331 (Cierniak,)-332 (Guei-Yuan)-331 (Lueh,)-332 (Vishesh)-330 (M.)-332 (Parakh,)-331 (and)-331 (James)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
[(M.)-415 (Stichnoth.)-415 (Fast,)-415 (Effective)-415 (Code)-416 (Generation)-414 (in)-415 (a)-415 (Just-In-Time)-415 (Java)-415 (Compiler.)-415 (In)]TJ
/N94 1 Tf
35.3658 0 TD
(Proc.)Tj
-35.3658 -1.1667 TD
[(ACM)-476 (SIGPLAN)-476 (\32498)-476 (Conference)-476 (on)-476 (Programming)-476 (Language)-476 (Design)-476 (and)-477 (Implementation)]TJ
T*
(\(PLDI\))Tj
/N92 1 Tf
2.8883 0 TD
(, p. 280-290, Montreal, Canada, June 1998.)Tj
-4.3283 -1.4167 TD
[(26.)-250 (SPECjvm98 Benchmarks. August 19, 1998 release. http://www.spec.org/osg/j\
vm98.)]TJ
T*
[(27.)-250 (Sun)-353 (Microsystems,)-353 (Inc.)-354 (Java)-353 (2)-353 (on-line)-353 (documentation:)-353 (http://java.sun.com/products/jdk/1.2/)]TJ
1.44 -1.1667 TD
(docs/api/index.html.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Page: 30 30
%%BeginPageSetup
userdict /pgsave save put
PDFVars begin PDF begin PDFVars/InitAll get exec
%%EndPageSetup
0 0 612 792 RC
1 g
/N93 /ExtGState findRes gs
1 i
0 0 612 792 re
f 
BT
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 300 34.17 Tm
0 g
0 Tc
(27)Tj
/N91 1 Tf
14 0 0 14 72 710.67 Tm
0 Tw
[(About the A)50 (uthors)]TJ
/N92 1 Tf
12 0 0 12 72 685 Tm
-0.004 Tc
[(Ole)-224 (Agesen)-225 (is)-224 (a)-223 (Senior)-225 (Staf)25 (f)-223 (Engineer)-225 (in)-223 (the)-224 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-224 (T)79 (opics)-225 (Group)-224 (in)-224 (Sun)-225 (Labs.)-224 (Pre)24 (viously)64 (,)-224 (h)0 (e)-224 (w)10 (ork)10 (ed)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(in)-333 (the)-332 (Kanban)-333 (group)-333 (and)-332 (the)-333 (Self)-333 (group,)-333 (also)-333 (in)-333 (Sun)-332 (Labs.)-333 (He)-332 (has)-333 (an)-332 (M.S.)-332 (de)15 (gree)-333 (from)-332 (Aarhus)]TJ
T*
[(Uni)24 (v)15 (ersity in Denmark, and M.S. and Ph.D. de)10 (grees from Stanford Uni)22 (v)14 (ersity in California.)]TJ
0 -1.9167 TD
0 Tc
[(Da)20 (v)15 (e)-392 (Detlefs)-392 (is)-392 (a)-392 (Staf)25 (f)-392 (Engineer)-392 (in)-391 (the)-392 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-392 (T)80 (opics)-392 (Group)-392 (in)-392 (Sun)-392 (Labs.)-392 (He)-391 (obtained)-392 (an)-392 (B.S.)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(de)15 (gree)-257 (from)-257 (MIT)74 (,)-258 (then)-257 (w)10 (ork)10 (ed)-257 (brie\337y)-257 (for)-257 (TR)55 (W)-257 (and)-258 (as)-257 (a)-257 (staf)25 (f)-258 (programmer)-257 (at)-257 (the)-257 (MIT)-257 (Laboratory)]TJ
T*
[(for)-295 (Computer)-294 (Science.)-295 (Fi)25 (v)15 (e)-294 (years)-295 (of)-294 (ef)25 (fort)-295 (yielded)-294 (a)-295 (Ph.D.)-294 (from)-294 (Carne)15 (gie)-295 (Mellon)-294 (in)-294 (1990.)-295 (Then)]TJ
T*
[(he)-229 (joined)-230 (the)-229 (Digital)-229 (Equipment)-230 (Corporation\325)55 (s)-229 (Systems)-229 (Research)-230 (Center)40 (,)-229 (w)10 (orking)-229 (on)-230 (garbage)-229 (col-)]TJ
T*
[(lection and program v)15 (eri\336cation until joining Sun in 1996.)]TJ
0 -1.9167 TD
[(Ale)15 (x)-367 (Garthw)10 (aite)-367 (recently)-367 (joined)-367 (Sun)-367 (Microsystems)-368 (Laboratories)-367 (in)-368 (Burlington,)-367 (Massachusetts,)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(where)-227 (he)-227 (w)10 (orks)-227 (with)-227 (the)-226 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-227 (T)80 (opics)-227 (Group.)-227 (His)-227 (research)-226 (interests)-227 (include)-227 (programming)-227 (language)]TJ
T*
[(implementation)-228 (and)-228 (runtime)-229 (system)-229 (design,)-229 (automatic)-228 (memory)-228 (management,)-229 (and)-228 (synchronization)]TJ
T*
[(techniques.)-290 (Ale)15 (x)-290 (i)0 (s)-290 (also)-291 (a)-290 (graduate)-290 (student)-291 (at)-290 (the)-290 (Uni)25 (v)15 (ersity)-290 (of)-290 (Pennsylv)25 (ania)-290 (w)10 (orking)-291 (with)-290 (Scott)]TJ
T*
[(Nettles.)-260 (He)-261 (is)-260 (currently)-260 (w)10 (orking)-261 (on)-261 (a)-260 (proposal)-260 (for)-261 (his)-260 (doctoral)-260 (thesis)-260 (which)-260 (in)40 (v)15 (estig)6 (ates)-261 (ho)25 (w)-261 (run-)]TJ
T*
[(time services in a Ja)20 (v)25 (a)0 ( VM may be safely implemented using the Ja)22 (v)25 (a)0 ( programming language.)]TJ
0 -1.9167 TD
[(Ross)-247 (Knippel)-247 (is)-247 (a)-247 (Senior)-247 (Staf)25 (f)-247 (Engineer)-247 (in)-247 (the)-247 (Ja)20 (v)25 (a)-247 (T)69 (echnology)-246 (Group)-247 (of)-247 (Solaris)-247 (Softw)10 (are.)-247 (Pre)25 (vi-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(ously)65 (,)-284 (h)0 (e)-284 (w)10 (ork)10 (ed)-283 (at)-285 (both)-284 (Cray)-284 (Research)-283 (and)-284 (Cray)-284 (Computer)40 (,)-283 (d)0 (e)25 (v)15 (eloping)-284 (compilers)-284 (for)-284 (the)-284 (XMP)111 (,)]TJ
T*
[(Cray3, and Cray4. He has a B.S. de)16 (gree in Computer Science from the Uni)26 (v)15 (ersity of Minnesota.)]TJ
0 -1.9167 TD
[(Y)129 (.S.)-259 (Ramakrishna)-259 (is)-260 (a)-260 (Staf)25 (f)-259 (Engineer)-260 (with)-259 (the)-260 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-260 (T)70 (echnology)-260 (Group)-259 (at)-260 (Sun)-260 (Microsystems.)-259 (Pre-)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(viously)65 (,)-302 (h)0 (e)-301 (w)10 (ork)11 (ed)-302 (at)-301 (TIFR,)-301 (Bombay)65 (,)-302 (and)-302 (at)-301 (SUNY)130 (,)-302 (Ston)15 (y)-302 (Brook,)-302 (on)-301 (the)-302 (use)-301 (of)-301 (temporal)-301 (logics)]TJ
T*
[(and)-228 (model-checking)-227 (for)-228 (the)-228 (v)15 (eri\336cation)-227 (of)-228 (concurrent)-228 (systems.)-228 (He)-227 (has)-228 (a)-228 (B.T)70 (ech.)-228 (from)-228 (IIT)-228 (Kanpur)40 (,)]TJ
T*
(and an M.S. and Ph.D. from UC Santa Barbara.)Tj
0 -1.9167 TD
[(Derek)-262 (White)-262 (is)-261 (a)-262 (Staf)25 (f)-262 (Engineer)-261 (at)-262 (Sun)-261 (Microsystems)-261 (Laboratories)-262 (in)-262 (Burlington,)-262 (Massachusetts.)]TJ
0 -1.1667 TD
[(He)-329 (is)-329 (a)-328 (member)-329 (of)-329 (the)-329 (Ja)21 (v)25 (a)-329 (T)80 (opics)-329 (Group,)-329 (which)-328 (has)-329 (de)25 (v)15 (eloped)-329 (a)-328 (JVM)-329 (as)-329 (an)-329 (infrastructure)-329 (for)]TJ
T*
[(de)25 (v)15 (eloping)-347 (soft)-347 (real-time)-347 (and)-348 (scalable)-347 (garbage)-347 (collection)-347 (for)-347 (the)-347 (Ja)20 (v)26 (a)-348 (language.)-347 (The)-347 (group)-347 (has)]TJ
T*
[(also)-229 (studied)-229 (and)-229 (optimized)-230 (JVM)-229 (performance)-228 (as)-229 (a)-229 (whole.)-229 (Other)-230 (interests)-228 (include)-229 (performance)-229 (and)]TJ
T*
[(heap)-444 (analysis)-444 (tools,)-444 (and)-444 (incremental)-445 (de)26 (v)15 (elopment)-444 (en)40 (vironments.)-444 (Prior)-445 (to)-444 (joining)-444 (Sun,)-444 (Derek)]TJ
T*
[(w)10 (ork)10 (ed)-301 (for)-301 (eight)-301 (years)-300 (at)-301 (Apple)-301 (Computer)40 (,)-300 (Inc.,)-301 (where)-300 (he)-301 (w)10 (a)0 (s)-301 (responsible)-301 (for)-301 (the)-300 (Object)-301 (P)15 (ascal)]TJ
T*
[(compiler)-388 (and)-388 (w)10 (ork)10 (ed)-388 (on)-388 (the)-389 (Dylan)-388 (programming)-388 (language)-388 (runtime)-388 (and)-388 (de)25 (v)15 (elopment)-388 (en)40 (viron-)]TJ
T*
(ment.)Tj
ET
PDFVars/TermAll get exec end end
userdict /pgsave get restore
showpage
%%PageTrailer
%%EndPage
%%Trailer
%%EOF
OSSP CVS Repository
